- Oct 28, 2014
- 9,854
- 23,929
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
And is it 1-30 or the whole squad. Thread title is unclear.
Opinion Rank our list 1-30
- Thread starter FR0GGY
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Drugs Are Bad Mackay?
Moderator
- May 24, 2006
- 77,385
- 152,104
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Redbacks, Sturt, Liverpool, Arizona
- Moderator
- #27
1. Walker
2. Dawson
3. Rankine
4. Fogarty
5. Pedlar
6. Soligo
7. Hinge
8. Murray
9. Rachele
10. Thilthorpe
11. Michalanney
12. Cook
13. Milera
14. Laird
15. Worrell
16. Smith
17. Nankervis
18. Berry
19. Jones
20. Crouch
21. Keane
22. Sloane
23. Keays
24. Schoenberg
25. Gollant
26. ROB
27. Butts
28. Sholl
29. Taylor
30. Dowling
Others (in order)
Borlase
Himmelberg
Hamill
McHenry
Murphy
Parnell
Strachan
Bond
Didn't include any of the newbies. Haven't had a chance to grow or grate on me yet
2. Dawson
3. Rankine
4. Fogarty
5. Pedlar
6. Soligo
7. Hinge
8. Murray
9. Rachele
10. Thilthorpe
11. Michalanney
12. Cook
13. Milera
14. Laird
15. Worrell
16. Smith
17. Nankervis
18. Berry
19. Jones
20. Crouch
21. Keane
22. Sloane
23. Keays
24. Schoenberg
25. Gollant
26. ROB
27. Butts
28. Sholl
29. Taylor
30. Dowling
Others (in order)
Borlase
Himmelberg
Hamill
McHenry
Murphy
Parnell
Strachan
Bond
Didn't include any of the newbies. Haven't had a chance to grow or grate on me yet
Drugs Are Bad Mackay?
Moderator
- May 24, 2006
- 77,385
- 152,104
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Redbacks, Sturt, Liverpool, Arizona
- Moderator
- #28
So No 30 is is your most favourite and No 1 your least favourite
Drugs Are Bad Mackay?
Moderator
- May 24, 2006
- 77,385
- 152,104
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Redbacks, Sturt, Liverpool, Arizona
- Moderator
- #29
Wait... I think I did it wrong. We have to guess all the player numbers from 1 to 30?
Head Selector
Senior List
- Apr 30, 2023
- 297
- 316
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
1. Dawson
2. Walker
3. Rankine
4. Murray
5. Fogarty
6. Pedlar
7. Rachele
8. Worrell
9. Michalanney
10. Soligo
11. Laird
12. Hinge
13. Thilthorpe
14. Curtin
15. Jones
16. Keays
17. O'Brien
18. Milera
19. Nankervis
20. Butts
21. Cook
22. Dowling
23. Gollant
24. Taylor
25. Keane
26. Himmelberg
27. Burgess
28. Bond
29. Murphy
30. McHenry
2. Walker
3. Rankine
4. Murray
5. Fogarty
6. Pedlar
7. Rachele
8. Worrell
9. Michalanney
10. Soligo
11. Laird
12. Hinge
13. Thilthorpe
14. Curtin
15. Jones
16. Keays
17. O'Brien
18. Milera
19. Nankervis
20. Butts
21. Cook
22. Dowling
23. Gollant
24. Taylor
25. Keane
26. Himmelberg
27. Burgess
28. Bond
29. Murphy
30. McHenry
Scorpus
Moderator
- Apr 16, 2014
- 58,295
- 151,178
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Moderator
- #31
My top 30 players I'm least frustrated watching in order
1. Dawson
2. Walker
3. Rankine
4. Soligo
5. Michalanney
6. Rachele
7. Hinge
8. Fogarty
9. Murray
10. Pedlar
11. Worrell
12. Thilthorpe
13. Curtin*
14. Milera
15. Nankervis
16. Jones
17. Laird
18. Butts
19. Schoenberg
20. Keane
21. Taylor*
22. Keays
23. Cook
24. Gollant
25. Berry
26. Smith
27. Parnell
28. Burgess
29. Strachan
30. Crouch
*based on the highlights video or SANFL I watched but also considering he hasn't played AFL yet
1. Dawson
2. Walker
3. Rankine
4. Soligo
5. Michalanney
6. Rachele
7. Hinge
8. Fogarty
9. Murray
10. Pedlar
11. Worrell
12. Thilthorpe
13. Curtin*
14. Milera
15. Nankervis
16. Jones
17. Laird
18. Butts
19. Schoenberg
20. Keane
21. Taylor*
22. Keays
23. Cook
24. Gollant
25. Berry
26. Smith
27. Parnell
28. Burgess
29. Strachan
30. Crouch
*based on the highlights video or SANFL I watched but also considering he hasn't played AFL yet
- Oct 28, 2014
- 9,854
- 23,929
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
1. Tex
2. Dawson
3. Rankine
4. Max
5. Fogarty
6. Soligo
7. Rachelle
8. Pedlar
9. Thilthorpe
10. Hinge
11. Murray
12. Crouch
13. Laird
14. Worrell
15. Nankervis
16. ROB
17. Smith
18. Milera
19. Jones
20. Keays
21. Keane
22. Berry
23. Harry
24. Butts
25. Gollant
26. Sloane
27. McHenry
28. Cook
29. Murphy
30. Curtin
2. Dawson
3. Rankine
4. Max
5. Fogarty
6. Soligo
7. Rachelle
8. Pedlar
9. Thilthorpe
10. Hinge
11. Murray
12. Crouch
13. Laird
14. Worrell
15. Nankervis
16. ROB
17. Smith
18. Milera
19. Jones
20. Keays
21. Keane
22. Berry
23. Harry
24. Butts
25. Gollant
26. Sloane
27. McHenry
28. Cook
29. Murphy
30. Curtin
- Oct 28, 2014
- 9,854
- 23,929
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Interesting to revisit at seasons end.
My care factor really starts to fall away after about 15.
My care factor really starts to fall away after about 15.
- Dawson
- Rankine
- Walker
- Laird
- Crouch
- Hinge
- Fog
- Murray
- Rachele
- Max
- Soligo
- Thilthorpe
- Berry
- RoB
- Worrell
- Keane
- Keays
- Jones
- Pedlar
- Smith
- Milera
- Curtin
- Sloane
- Gollant
- Cook
- Butts
- Nankervis
- Dowling
- Strachan
- Murphy
Last edited:
1. Rankine
2. Dawson
3. Rachelle
4. Soligo
5. Max
6. Worrell
7. Tex
8. Pedlar
9. Murray
10. Hinge
11. Curtin
12. Laird
13. Fog
14. Thilthorpe
15. Milera
16. Smith
17.Jones
18. Nank
19. Keays
20. Keane
21. Crouch
22. Berry
23. Schoenberg
24. Cook
25. Gollant
26. Taylor
27. Butts
28. Keane
29. Burgess
30. Borlase
2. Dawson
3. Rachelle
4. Soligo
5. Max
6. Worrell
7. Tex
8. Pedlar
9. Murray
10. Hinge
11. Curtin
12. Laird
13. Fog
14. Thilthorpe
15. Milera
16. Smith
17.Jones
18. Nank
19. Keays
20. Keane
21. Crouch
22. Berry
23. Schoenberg
24. Cook
25. Gollant
26. Taylor
27. Butts
28. Keane
29. Burgess
30. Borlase
kick it to me_
Team Captain
- Jul 12, 2020
- 456
- 1,242
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
1.Taylor Walker
2.Izak Rankine
3.Jordan Dawson
4.Rory Laird
5.Mitchell Hinge
6.Max Michalanney
7.Darcy Fogarty
8.Josh Rachele
9.Jake Soligo
10.Luke Pedlar
11.Riley Thilthorpe
12.Matt Crouch
13.Nick Murray
14.Josh Worrell
15.Wayne Milera
16.Chayce Jones
17.Brodie Smith
18.Mark Keane
19.Luke Nankervis
20.Harry Schoenberg
21.Sam Berry
22.Brayden Cook
23.Zac Taylor
24.Rory Sloane
25.Ben Keays
26.Daniel Curtin
27.Billy Dowling
28.Oscar Ryan
29.Charlie Edwards
30.Reilly O'Brien
31.Lachlan Murphy
32.Jordon Butts
33.Chris Burgess
34.Lachlan Sholl
35.Ned McHenry
36.Lachlan Gollant
37.Elliott Himmelberg
38.Patrick Parnell
39.Kieran Strachan
40.Will Hamill
41.James Borlase
42.Hugh Bond
43.Karl Gallagher
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
2.Izak Rankine
3.Jordan Dawson
4.Rory Laird
5.Mitchell Hinge
6.Max Michalanney
7.Darcy Fogarty
8.Josh Rachele
9.Jake Soligo
10.Luke Pedlar
11.Riley Thilthorpe
12.Matt Crouch
13.Nick Murray
14.Josh Worrell
15.Wayne Milera
16.Chayce Jones
17.Brodie Smith
18.Mark Keane
19.Luke Nankervis
20.Harry Schoenberg
21.Sam Berry
22.Brayden Cook
23.Zac Taylor
24.Rory Sloane
25.Ben Keays
26.Daniel Curtin
27.Billy Dowling
28.Oscar Ryan
29.Charlie Edwards
30.Reilly O'Brien
31.Lachlan Murphy
32.Jordon Butts
33.Chris Burgess
34.Lachlan Sholl
35.Ned McHenry
36.Lachlan Gollant
37.Elliott Himmelberg
38.Patrick Parnell
39.Kieran Strachan
40.Will Hamill
41.James Borlase
42.Hugh Bond
43.Karl Gallagher
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
kick it to me_
Team Captain
- Jul 12, 2020
- 456
- 1,242
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Jul 8, 2016
- 3,688
- 4,564
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
If our list management team are thinking anything close to most of these lists then McHenry will probably be delisted or traded, (if anybody wants him), at the end of the season.
1. Rankine
2. Walker
3. Dawson
4. Thilthorpe
5. Curtain
6. Hinge
7. Worrell
8. Fog
9. Rachele
10. Max
11. Pedlar
12. Murray
13. Jones
14. Soligo
15. Keane
15. Schoenberg
16. Laird
17. Crouch
18. Milera
19. Cook
20. Ryan
21. Smith
22. ROB
23. Nank
24. Keays
25. McHenry
26. Butts
27. Parnell
28. Berry
29. Murphy
30. Burgess
2. Walker
3. Dawson
4. Thilthorpe
5. Curtain
6. Hinge
7. Worrell
8. Fog
9. Rachele
10. Max
11. Pedlar
12. Murray
13. Jones
14. Soligo
15. Keane
15. Schoenberg
16. Laird
17. Crouch
18. Milera
19. Cook
20. Ryan
21. Smith
22. ROB
23. Nank
24. Keays
25. McHenry
26. Butts
27. Parnell
28. Berry
29. Murphy
30. Burgess
- Thread starter
- #42
On our list yes
1. Rankine
2. Dawson
3. Tex
4. Rachele
5. Curtin
6. Michaelanny
7. Laird
8. Thilthorpe
All ^ have AA quality at their best
9. Murray
10. Soligo
11. Pedlar
12. Hinge
13. Worrell
14. Fogarty
15. Milera
^ all have A grade quality at their best
16. Jones
17. Keays
18. M Crouch
19. ROB
20. Keane
21. Smith
22. Murphy
^ Workhorse / Role players / hardened afl players
23. Nankervis
24. Ryan
25. Schoenberg
26. Berry
27. Dowling
28. Burgess
29. Mchenry
30. Taylor
^ mainly potential , couple are depth only
No doubt I’ve forgotten some
Edit* included ones I forgot
2. Dawson
3. Tex
4. Rachele
5. Curtin
6. Michaelanny
7. Laird
8. Thilthorpe
All ^ have AA quality at their best
9. Murray
10. Soligo
11. Pedlar
12. Hinge
13. Worrell
14. Fogarty
15. Milera
^ all have A grade quality at their best
16. Jones
17. Keays
18. M Crouch
19. ROB
20. Keane
21. Smith
22. Murphy
^ Workhorse / Role players / hardened afl players
23. Nankervis
24. Ryan
25. Schoenberg
26. Berry
27. Dowling
28. Burgess
29. Mchenry
30. Taylor
^ mainly potential , couple are depth only
No doubt I’ve forgotten some
Edit* included ones I forgot
Last edited:
Jones boy
Walker
Fog
Rankine
Dawson
Murray
Rachelle
Max
Pedlar
Soligo
Curtin
Nank
Jones
Worrell
Berry
Thilthorpe
Hinge
Milera
Taylor
O’Brien
Crouch
Smith
Schoenberg
Laird
Gollant
Keays
mcHenry
Parnell
Keane
Butts
Sloane
now can I go to bed Froggy
Fog
Rankine
Dawson
Murray
Rachelle
Max
Pedlar
Soligo
Curtin
Nank
Jones
Worrell
Berry
Thilthorpe
Hinge
Milera
Taylor
O’Brien
Crouch
Smith
Schoenberg
Laird
Gollant
Keays
mcHenry
Parnell
Keane
Butts
Sloane
now can I go to bed Froggy
Last edited:
In order of jumper number, I went through the list and just wrote down who I'd think would be a bit unlucky to miss being named in a 22. I got to 27.
Jones
Keays
Berry
Murphy
Crouch
Curtin
Thilthorpe
Rachele
Pedlar
Dawson
Walker
Soligo
MM
Hinge
Rankine
Worrell
McHenry
Nankervis
Murray
Laird
Milera
Fog
Smith
Butts
ROB
Gollant
Keane
So that leaves 3 more to get to 30.
I'll add Taylor, Schoenberg and Borlase as players I'd love to see do well.
(I don't have a personal whipping boy, so apologies to the rest of the squad.)
Sloane is definitely a favourite, but like many others I struggle to see his best current role as an on-field one.
Jones
Keays
Berry
Murphy
Crouch
Curtin
Thilthorpe
Rachele
Pedlar
Dawson
Walker
Soligo
MM
Hinge
Rankine
Worrell
McHenry
Nankervis
Murray
Laird
Milera
Fog
Smith
Butts
ROB
Gollant
Keane
So that leaves 3 more to get to 30.
I'll add Taylor, Schoenberg and Borlase as players I'd love to see do well.
(I don't have a personal whipping boy, so apologies to the rest of the squad.)
Sloane is definitely a favourite, but like many others I struggle to see his best current role as an on-field one.
