Sorry for the reminder guys but Toyd (unproven) cost us our captain and first rounder. Those suggesting we'll bag Carlisle (proven top quality KPP) for Hunter (unproven) and our first rounder are dreaming. Even if they swap 2nd round picks it'd still be unders from us because we know even early draft picks are still unproven at AFL level (Christian Howard rabble rabble). Don't forget who we're dealing with in Dodoorknob. And.. before you say it, yes I know we paid overs for Tom Boyd but if you think Essendon won't use that trade as an example to increase JC's worth well, again you're dreaming. Dons will want our first rounder and one of our young guns at the least. Lachie will become a very good player but probably not in time for this trade. If he is included then expect to lose another solid young gun. As awesome as having Carlisle would be I don't think we need him as much as the players he'd cost us
That trade is the exception, not the rule.
Our first and Hunter for Carlisle would be accepted every day of the week, imo. It would probably take a while because it's Essendon and the Dodo is hard to deal with.
