List Mgmt. Trade/Draft SuperMegaUltraThread - 2016 edition?

[kaiserchief13]

Did anyone else hear on the radio that McKenzie has been looking at a move to Victoria/NSW?

As he should be. He will only make the team now if Barrass or McGovern get injured

 

[Godfather32]

As he should be. He will only make the team now if Barrass or McGovern get injured

Of course, he's been surplus to needs the whole second half the year. Hopefully we can take advantage of it somehow

 

[neng]

Swallow fits our age profile perfectly and will still have plenty of years ahead of him barring injury. Throw our first rounder at them.

 

[new breed]

Why do we have to sell out our depth all the time , besides McKenzie we dont have a key tall to call on if injuries occur !!

 

[Godfather32]

Why do we have to sell out our depth all the time , besides McKenzie we dont have a key tall to call on if injuries occur !!

Brown will re-sign.
Besides if you were McKenzie you'd want to go.

 

[Monocle]

Of course, he's been surplus to needs the whole second half the year. Hopefully we can take advantage of it somehow

I look at it this way Godfather32. History has shown that players coming back from a knee reconstruction generally take until the second season back after the op to get any where near back to their best. So what a bonus if The Big Ezy gets some form back and he can hold down CHB.

Then McGovern gets to play CHF then than spine starts looking super scary;

Barrass
Ezy

McGovern
Kennedy

( Nice Claremont contribution to that spine.... just quietly )

McKenzie is still contracted and I would prefer to keep him , however if he was able garner a very good swap of a player or a pick then we would be silly not to at least entertain the idea. Win / Win.

 

[Godfather32]

I look at it this way Godfather32. History has shown that players coming back from a knee reconstruction generally take until the second season back after the op to get any where near back to their best. So what a bonus if The Big Ezy gets some form back and he can hold down CHB.

Then McGovern gets to play CHF then than spine starts looking super scary;

Barrass
Ezy

McGovern
Kennedy

McKenzie is still contracted and I would prefer to keep him , however if he was able garner a very good swap of a player or a pick then we would be silly not to at least entertain the idea.

Agreed, I'd really like to see McGovern at CHF, I think he'd be amazing there, but I think McKenzie will want to leave. He'd be worried that he won't get a game next year and you couldn't blame him if he wanted to go considering these guys get such short careers and only have a few years to make some decent coin.

 

[new breed]

I look at it this way Godfather32. History has shown that players coming back from a knee reconstruction generally take until the second season back after the op to get any where near back to their best. So what a bonus if The Big Ezy gets some form back and he can hold down CHB.

Then McGovern gets to play CHF then than spine starts looking super scary;

Barrass
Ezy

McGovern
Kennedy

McKenzie is still contracted and I would prefer to keep him , however if he was able garner a very good swap of a player or a pick then we would be silly not to at least entertain the idea.

Plus you dont want to put too much onto young players in Barrass and McGovern , slow build requires good reserves .

 

[mattyc75]

I look at it this way Godfather32. History has shown that players coming back from a knee reconstruction generally take until the second season back after the op to get any where near back to their best. So what a bonus if The Big Ezy gets some form back and he can hold down CHB.

Then McGovern gets to play CHF then than spine starts looking super scary;

Barrass
Ezy

McGovern
Kennedy

( Nice Claremont contribution to that spine.... just quietly )

McKenzie is still contracted and I would prefer to keep him , however if he was able garner a very good swap of a player or a pick then we would be silly not to at least entertain the idea. Win / Win.

What's the least pick you would accept for McKenzie?

Sent from my E6653 using Tapatalk

 

[lewigie]

Swallow fits our age profile perfectly and will still have plenty of years ahead of him barring injury. Throw our first rounder at them.

Are his knees any good though?

 

[Monocle]

What's the least pick you would accept for McKenzie?

Sent from my E6653 using Tapatalk

Early second as that I think at this stage in assessing the kids, before the Combine, that pick would get us SPP or Dylan Clarke.

Therefore keeping our first rounder to get best available or even trade, personally I would like us to keep our first rounder ( which after tonights effort may well be pick # 18 ).

 

[neng]

Are his knees any good though?

I'd back us in. Risk v reward with him. I feel O'Meara's the one that's in worse shape.

 

[Godfather32]

I'd back us in. Risk v reward with him. I feel O'Meara's the one that's in worse shape.

Wonder what GC would want, they've got plenty of picks already

 

[reimersworstguy]

swap of our first rounder for swallow? is that ripping them off? probably.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

[flamingEMBERS]

Yes but bringing Harvey in is going to stop Partington/Nelson or someone similar from having a spot in the team and developing

He could also fast track the development of some of the younger players. Never underestimate the value of veteran leadership at training and game day.

 

[Godfather32]

He could also fast track the development of some of the younger players. Never underestimate the value of veteran leadership at training and game day.

Yeh we don't have any of that around already....

 

[reimersworstguy]

just shut up about Harvey ay. not happening.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

[flamingEMBERS]

The last thing we need is another front runner , incapable of getting his own ball.
Harvey is clever, a good reader of play, knows when and where to run forward of play, has pace and good disposal, all positives.
He is also horrible defensively, almost 40 next year, can't win his own ball, often takes the easy way out and selfish.
An almost 40 year old outside mid with no other positional ability or versatility is the last thing this club needs.

So he's a faster LeCras?

 

[reimersworstguy]

Harvey is extremely selfish and a c u n t

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

[neng]

swap of our first rounder for swallow? is that ripping them off? probably.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

Yeah that's be unders for them. I'd consider adding a future pick of some sort.

 

[WCE_phil]

Mackenzie and 2017 first rounder for swallow. Thx.

 

[reimersworstguy]

Yeah that's be unders for them. I'd consider adding a future pick of some sort.

realistically, we probably get an early 3rd rounder for lamb. lump that in to even it up?

 

[Biggie]

Mackenzie and 2017 first rounder for swallow. Thx.

I'm tempted.

 

[WCE_phil]

I'm tempted.

Pick up SPP with this years first and thats very likely enough high end midfield picks for a while. Will need to start looking for forwards, small defenders and rucks.

 

[SpaceClef]

Pick up SPP with this years first and thats very likely enough high end midfield picks for a while. Will need to start looking for forwards, small defenders and rucks.

just came a little thinking about injecting SPP and Swallow into our team next year