List Mgmt. Trade/Draft SuperMegaUltraThread - 2016 edition?

[wraglesweb]

from all the recent rankings and phantoms, i don't see galluchi anywhere near our pick. He seems to be sliding.

Good

 

[avishka5]

Good

plus we need inside mids. Galluchi looks like one of those that will develop into a winger that can chip in at a CBD at times (e.g Gaff)

 

[wraglesweb]

plus we need inside mids. Galluchi looks like one of those that will develop into a winger that can chip in at a CBD at times (e.g Gaff)

I'm firmy in the Scrimshaw camp. Think he could turn into a Bontempelli Cripps type

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

I don't want either of them anyway so I don't care what their form is like.
I would rather take the gamble on drafting a younger player who may turn into something than rent a 39 year old for a year.

When was the last time one of our players had 30 touches and 3 goals ?
Harvey can take maginnity spot in the team .
He could take lecras spot for next year !

 

[Hap Hapablap]

When was the last time one of our players had 30 touches and 3 goals ?
Harvey can take maginnity spot in the team .
He could take lecras spot for next year !

The sad thing is some morons would think mccampaignery is better than harvey

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

 

[avishka5]

When was the last time one of our players had 30 touches and 3 goals ?
Harvey can take maginnity spot in the team .
He could take lecras spot for next year !

Gaff last year

 

[avishka5]

I'm firmy in the Scrimshaw camp. Think he could turn into a Bontempelli Cripps type

hopefully more of the bont type than cripps

 

[wraglesweb]

hopefully more of the bont type than cripps

Hope he slides to us could be anything.

 

[swooshacummings]

I don't want either of them anyway so I don't care what their form is like.
I would rather take the gamble on drafting a younger player who may turn into something than rent a 39 year old for a year.

You do both in parallel.

Have to organise your list to contend for top 2 every year, see Geelong and Hawthorn.

Never compromise acquisition of young talent but never discount quality senior players if they can play a pivotal role.

After 2 seasons, it is mych more likely the youngster we draft is ready to play the role.

You rarely build a premiership team on drafting alone. Even when you are given upteen concessions ala GWS.

See their list management, Patfull, Johnson etc. and yes Boomer is older but he is a freak of nature, clearly as the games record depicts

 

[swooshacummings]

Against whom?

 

[Godfather32]

When was the last time one of our players had 30 touches and 3 goals ?
Harvey can take maginnity spot in the team .
He could take lecras spot for next year !

You guys have been smoking something if you think bringing a 39 year old into our team is a good idea

 

[swooshacummings]

Gaff last year

Against whom?

 

[Obeanie1]

We'd have to give up this years first round draft pick as well as someone like Andrew Gaff.
As good as O'Meara is in theory it's a lot of risk for a small chance of reward. Probably better we sit this one out.

Forget about O'Mera.

We should take maximum benefit from this situation and trade Masten to Gold Coast.

They've stated they need experienced mids not more picks. Currently have 7 of the top 25 picks before trading Prestia or OMera.

They would give up a 1st rounder for Masten as they have so many picks and need experience. Masto has even hit a bit of form recently.

 

[2006_Eagles]

You guys have been smoking something if you think bringing a 39 year old into our team is a good idea

 

[Godfather32]

You do both in parallel.

Have to organise your list to contend for top 2 every year, see Geelong and Hawthorn.

Never compromise acquisition of young talent but never discount quality senior players if they can play a pivotal role.

After 2 seasons, it is mych more likely the youngster we draft is ready to play the role.

You rarely build a premiership team on drafting alone. Even when you are given upteen concessions ala GWS.

See their list management, Patfull, Johnson etc. and yes Boomer is older but he is a freak of nature, clearly as the games record depicts

Yes but bringing Harvey in is going to stop Partington/Nelson or someone similar from having a spot in the team and developing

 

[Woobla Stainz]

Because you don't uproot your whole family for 1 year to come over to Perth

Didn't stop Stevie J

 

[2006_Eagles]

Didn't stop Stevie J

And Boomer is Simmo's best mate in the world.

Do I smell offer of a front office/coaching role post retirement?

 

[Obeanie1]

Gold Coast should be going hard for Fyfe.

Two first round picks + Garlett or Ah Chee.

Put up Jack Martin + picks and Freo would have to stop and think about that.

 

[2006_Eagles]

Gold Coast should be going hard for Fyfe.

Two first round picks + Garlett or Ah Chee.

Put up Jack Martin + picks and Freo would have to stop and think about that.

I don't think you trade a Brownlow medalist unless you are forced to

 

[Obeanie1]

I don't think you trade a Brownlow medalist unless you are forced to

He's suffering from a reoccurring broken leg, the list needs to rebuild and there is consistent noise about him not getting along with team mates.

 

[avishka5]

Against whom?

Adelaide last year and again in 2014

 

[kerrazy]

They would give up a 1st rounder for Masten as they have so many picks and need experience. Masto has even hit a bit of form recently.

Hahahahahajajahahahahajajajajhahaahajajha

 

[QS]

http://www.watoday.com.au/afl/west-...-fill-nic-nats-big-boots-20160825-gr0pl8.html

Hagdorn!

 

[swooshacummings]

Yes but bringing Harvey in is going to stop Partington/Nelson or someone similar from having a spot in the team and developing

Which of those players will be an automatic starting forward pocket next season?

That line of thinking is flawed. Not only is it a fact that Harvey is a better forward then the two you mention but he is also a much better midfielder.

If Butler retires then Nelson is an automatic replacement. Partington is in direct competition with the midfield group and on the basis of this season where he has not played any senior games it is fair to assume he may not be ready next season also.

It is about list quality and thus competition breeds success.

 

[boondy]

Ha

When was the last time one of our players had 30 touches and 3 goals ?
Harvey can take maginnity spot in the team .
He could take lecras spot for next year !

66 goals a year?

I'd take a punt on that. His skills are shite, but he attacks the footy and clearly has some line breaking speed and size.
Rough gem but worth a look.

Fyfes kicking is crap still