Trade hypotheticals

[Taylor]

Suggestion?

I've heard Merrett from Brisbane, but I dont think North needs another 30 year old.

Like for like, a tough hard running mid. That's the issue though, every team that has one will keep him.

 

[c4v3m4n99]

Ok excluding Merrett

Bris
gain Beams,45
lose 4,24,53
Pies
gain 4, Greenwood, 53
lose Beams, 28
North
gain 24, 28
lose Greenwood, 45

TBH even getting 24 and an upgrade is bottom barrel for Levi.

Thinking about it more, would we take pick just pick 24?

North gives Greenwood FOR pick 24.

Brisbane gives pick 4 and 24 FOR Beams and pick 30

Collingwood gives Beams and pick 30 FOR Greenwood and pick 4.

 

[SnowRoo]

Thinking about it more, would we take pick just pick 24?

North gives Greenwood FOR pick 24.

Brisbane gives pick 4 and 24 FOR Beams and pick 30

Collingwood gives Beams and pick 30 FOR Greenwood and pick 4.

Im sure this would be up for debate but 24 for Greenwood is way unders.

 

[c4v3m4n99]

Im sure this would be up for debate but 24 for Greenwood is way unders.

Add pick 47/65 from Collingwood then.

 

[MisterMarcus]

Im sure this would be up for debate but 24 for Greenwood is way unders.

24 and 28 (Collingwood's original second round) for Greenwood and 53 (North's third)?

EDIT: Or North's second round (34) maybe?

 

[Taylor]

Add pick 47/65 from Collingwood then.

Do you feel like you will gain anything from further picks later down the order?
You're set for a run at the flag, how does an 18 year old outside of the top 50 in the country help in that?

 

[SnowRoo]

Do you feel like you will gain anything from further picks later down the order?
You're set for a run at the flag, how does an 18 year old outside of the top 50 in the country help in that?

Agreed 3rd and 4th round picks hold little value.

Bris 2nd and Pies 2nd
for Levi and our 3rd
bare minimum

even better sign pig and stay out of it

 

[dlanod]

Ok excluding Merrett

Bris
gain Beams,45
lose 4,24,53
Pies
gain 4, Greenwood, 53
lose Beams, 28
North
gain 24, 28
lose Greenwood, 45

TBH even getting 24 and an upgrade is bottom barrel for Levi.

Where did the Lions get pick 53 from?

 

[c4v3m4n99]

Do you feel like you will gain anything from further picks later down the order?
You're set for a run at the flag, how does an 18 year old outside of the top 50 in the country help in that?

Never know what the lottery might turn up. Another Kayne Turner or Chris Grant perhaps?

Agreed 3rd and 4th round picks hold little value.

Bris 2nd and Pies 2nd
for Levi and our 3rd
bare minimum

even better sign pig and stay out of it

Agreed, just sign him!!

 

[c4v3m4n99]

Okay, last attempt at this. lol

Collingwood gives: Beams and picks 30
Collingwood receives: Greenwood and pick 4

Brisbane gives: picks 4 and 24
Brisbane receives: Beams and pick 37

North gives: Greenwood and pick 37
North receives: picks 24 and pick 30

 

[aussierulesrules]

Okay, last attempt at this. lol

Collingwood gives: Beams and picks 30
Collingwood receives: Greenwood and pick 4

Brisbane gives: picks 4 and 24
Brisbane receives: Beams and pick 37

North gives: Greenwood and pick 37
North receives: picks 24 and pick 30

Not bad at all. Collingwood probably getting shafted a bit and Brisbane winning, but that's probably going to happen to some degree anyway.

 

[Man of Steele]

If Collingwood want Greenwood then why doesn't Brisbane buy him for them

Brisbane 1st pick to Collingwoood
Brisbane 2nd pick to North
Beams to Brisbane
Greenwood to Collingwood

I would like North to 'demand' Collingwood's first pick and a very good player in trade for Levi though.

Greenwood worth high 2nd pick

 

[Vindicater]

Essendon gives: Howlett and 67

Carlton gives: Garlett and 43

 

[eth-dog]

Essendon gives: Howlett and 67

Carlton gives: Garlett and 43

**** no

 

[Frez87]

Okay, last attempt at this. lol

Collingwood gives: Beams and picks 30
Collingwood receives: Greenwood and pick 4

Brisbane gives: picks 4 and 24
Brisbane receives: Beams and pick 37

North gives: Greenwood and pick 37
North receives: picks 24 and pick 30

That seems like a fair trade

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Okay, last attempt at this. lol

Collingwood gives: Beams and picks 30
Collingwood receives: Greenwood and pick 4

Brisbane gives: picks 4 and 24
Brisbane receives: Beams and pick 37

North gives: Greenwood and pick 37
North receives: picks 24 and pick 30

North shafted, pies all the way to the bank.

 

[Defacto]

gilbert + our 4th rounder for brisbanes 3rd rounder?

 

[Carl]

**** no

I agree. Pick 67 is a nothing pick- lucky if any live picks left by then. Howlett doesn't really improve our list much- just looked him up and only averages 15 disposals this year. Garlett and Robinson will go so not expecting the world but don't want to lose a 3rd rounder with them to pick up another average player.

 

[scott_the_man]

GWS lose: O'rourke
GWS gain: Patfull

North lose: Greenwood
North gain: O'rourke

Collingwood lose: Beams
Collingwood gain: pick 5, Greenwood

Brisbane lose: pick 5, Patfull
Brisbane gain: Beams

 

[Tragic sainter]

GWS lose: O'rourke
GWS gain: Patfull

North lose: Greenwood
North gain: O'rourke

Collingwood lose: Beams
Collingwood gain: pick 5, Greenwood

Brisbane lose: pick 5, Patfull
Brisbane gain: Beams

I reckon that looks pretty good

 

[cotter101]

gilbert + our 4th rounder for brisbanes 3rd rounder?

Tied up to one of our academy players in Liam Dawson.

 

[scott_the_man]

gilbert + our 4th rounder for brisbanes 3rd rounder?

What's happened to Gilbert? Was a gun a couple of years ago, haven't heard of him since

 

[detox]

I reckon that looks pretty good

Agree.

Would north take orouke

 

[Defacto]

What's happened to Gilbert? Was a gun a couple of years ago, haven't heard of him since

injuries

 

[Defacto]

Tied up to one of our academy players in Liam Dawson.

bugga