Trades - Round 12

[C-Dog]

who the hells JON?
anyway I think I'll just do Palmer for Bartel, then in a few weeks S.Thompson --> Rookie and upgrade Simmonds.

yep very funny.

****head

 

[adam1302]

last thoughts, what do i do with Rutten and S.Stevens in my backline
Rutten 395,200 To Mcleod?
S.Stevens 348,800 Who?

 

[Biggie]

Guys help a Big Man out.

Trade out Gamble or McKinely for ROK?????

I guess I'll just wait for the final sides tomoorow.

 

[fugu]

Trade out Gamble or McKinely for ROK?????

What's the go with McKinley BM? Did he have surgery or not? FWIW I kept him and traded Gamble for ROK the other week but I reckon I picked the wrong one.

 

[pup23]

Im thinking of picking up either gilbee or kennelly for bradshaw...which one of them should i get or is there someone else i should get?

Any thoughts?

 

[Athomas]

who the hells JON?
anyway I think I'll just do Palmer for Bartel, then in a few weeks S.Thompson --> Rookie and upgrade Simmonds.

yep very funny.

****head

Errrrr someone explain please? lol

 

[benny1712]

Im thinking of picking up either gilbee or kennelly for bradshaw...which one of them should i get or is there someone else i should get?

Any thoughts?

Out of those 2: gilbee

 

[adam1302]

last thoughts, what do i do with Rutten and S.Stevens in my backline
Rutten 395,200 To Mcleod?
S.Stevens 348,800 Who?

what should i do ?

 

[fugu]

what should i do ?

Ladson?

 

[benny1712]

what should i do ?

not a lot of good options to pick from.
if you do the mcleod trade, and depending on who you have and how much money, the cheapest player i personally would get would be birchall then gilbee.

 

[adam1302]

Ladson?

he is way to much i have no money in the bank, do you think Rutten to Mcleod would be a good trade and then stevens to someone around 380,000

 

[fugu]

he is way to much i have no money in the bank, do you think Rutten to Mcleod would be a good trade and then stevens to someone around 380,000

I'm really not qualified to give advice but I'd do Rutten>McLeod. Stevens to anyone lower than Birchall would be a waste IMO.

 

[adam1302]

I'm really not qualified to give advice but I'd do Rutten>McLeod. Stevens to anyone lower than Birchall would be a waste IMO.

i did Rutten to McLeod i had to get him at that price, he cant go down anymore. Should i just keep stevens till the end of the year now ?

 

[fugu]

i did Rutten to McLeod i had to get him at that price, he cant go down anymore. Should i just keep stevens till the end of the year now ?

Dunno mate. Take it week by week, check Stevens' previous scores against opponents etc. If you're feeling bold trade Stevens to Urquart, play Myers and upgrade Myers or Urquart to a premium later on. That's what I'd do. Depends on your goals and your attitude to trades.

 

[adam1302]

Dunno mate. Take it week by week, check Stevens' previous scores against opponents etc. If you're feeling bold trade Stevens to Urquart, play Myers and upgrade Myers or Urquart to a premium later on. That's what I'd do. Depends on your goals and your attitude to trades.

yeah i think ill keep him he has scored over 120 twice this year might have another big one.

 

[Hands Open]

Need some pretty urgent advice..

who to chop for McLeod

Ellis $32200 and probably hit his peak or

H Taylor $339000 would leave a bit of extra cash but maybe not a regular player..

Bit of help would be great

 

[TheWiseOne]

JON has great ability to score high, but i guess i am looking for consistency.

btw JON is a midfielder

lol you for real ?

 

[From 45]

In: McLeod, J. Brown
Out: Symes, C.Gardiner

 

[Ling Sting]

In: McLeod, J. Brown
Out: Symes, C.Gardiner

you still have symes???

 

[jonoman89]

Ok who would you get out of these blokes: Barry Hall, Brad Johnson, or Nick Rewioldt? Long-term wise, who would be the best pickup?

Im think of doing this: mckinely to one of the above three and armitage to armfield, then next round bring pfieffer up to nathan bock.

 

[Biggie]

What's the go with McKinley BM? Did he have surgery or not? FWIW I kept him and traded Gamble for ROK the other week but I reckon I picked the wrong one.

Yeah thats why Im pondering this decision Fug.

WC arent being very clear on this injury so I am uncertain but ROK has to com in to complete my forward line.

Bah.

 

[From 45]

you still have symes???

I did... Symes initial injury was for 2 weeks , so I had no intention of trading him then as Symes was scoring quite well .

I wanted to keep him as my 7th backman but couldnt resist Macca at that price

 

[fugu]

Yeah thats why Im pondering this decision Fug.

WC arent being very clear on this injury so I am uncertain but ROK has to com in to complete my forward line.

Bah.

Well if I had my time again I'd keep Gamble. Seems like the Cats forward line works better with him in. Not that either of them are consistent scorers. Either way I agree ROK is a must.

 

[Biggie]

Yeah.

I reckon McKinners is goneski.

Cheers Fug.

 

[StEaLtH]

need to plug backline...

OUT j edwards | proud ?
IN urqhart | armfield ?

I am thinking OUT edwards IN urqhart