Trades - Round 12

[jonoman89]

Brad Johnson

any reason in particular? im tempted to get riewoldt, but the saints are shat at the moment and he cant hit a barndoor. bock is meh. is BJ well and truly over injury do you think?

 

[gdogga]

looking to trade out rioli.

so far fowards are: J.BROWN, DIDAK, PAVLICH, N.RIEWOLDT, B.JOHNSON, BURTON, RIOLI, valenti and morton.

i have 150,700 in the kitt, and wen i trade out rioli it ives me 525,800.

Who should i get as my 7th fwd? Richo??

 

[swansfan51]

any reason in particular? im tempted to get riewoldt, but the saints are shat at the moment and he cant hit a barndoor. bock is meh. is BJ well and truly over injury do you think?

Brad Johnson has consistently scored very, very highly for 9 years. Bock isn't meh, I just think he's better in the backline if you need someone there. Riewoldt isn't working hard enough, not taking enough contested marks, not kicking enough goals, not scoring enough points.

looking to trade out rioli.

so far fowards are: J.BROWN, DIDAK, PAVLICH, N.RIEWOLDT, B.JOHNSON, BURTON, RIOLI, valenti and morton.

i have 150,700 in the kitt, and wen i trade out rioli it ives me 525,800.

Who should i get as my 7th fwd? Richo??

Since you can't afford O'Keefe and Franklin who are the best options, yes.

 

[Judd_Magic]

haha nice!

What are you doing with them this week?

Hoping that Harry Taylor comes back so I can cover Bradshaw.

Will have to see what happens with the Chad. If he is out for 5 + weeks then I will bring in Gilbee or Mcdonald.

 

[Athomas]

Hoping that Harry Taylor comes back so I can cover Bradshaw.

Will have to see what happens with the Chad. If he is out for 5 + weeks then I will bring in Gilbee or Mcdonald.

Fair enough.
I have Taylor, Cornes and Bradshaw IN my 22.

Was thinking N Brown can replace Bradshaw if it's 2 weeks or less.
Cornes/Taylor will probably trade 1 if they are both not named.

 

[Biggie]

Yeah if Cornes is gone for the year its Darren Dasher Milburn into the team.

ROK is coming in regardless.

 

[Lotch]

Just an idea if defence problems continue.

Ellis -> Mcleod
Cornes -> Gilbee

or 1 of those and
SDT/Edwards -> Armfield

That would make my defence look like:

Mcleod, Gilbee, Shaw, Bock, Fisher, Kennelly, Milburn
(SDT/Edwards)

or

Gilbee, Shaw, Bock, Fisher, Kennelly, Milburn, Ellis (SDT/Edwards and Armfield)

Thoughts?

 

[adam1302]

Just an idea if defence problems continue.

Ellis -> Mcleod
Cornes -> Gilbee

or 1 of those and
SDT/Edwards -> Armfield

That would make my defence look like:

Mcleod, Gilbee, Shaw, Bock, Fisher, Kennelly, Milburn
(SDT/Edwards)

or

Gilbee, Shaw, Bock, Fisher, Kennelly, Milburn, Ellis (SDT/Edwards and Armfield)

Thoughts?

how many trades have you got? if your running low i wouldn't do the Armfield trade. Ellis to Mcleod and if Cornes is out a trade to Gilbee looks good.

 

[Hawkmad]

Looking for your opinions on some trade options please.

Back - H.Shaw , Johncock , Bradshaw , Wirrapunda , Chornes , Newman & Myers (emerg. Taylor & Proud)
Centre - Ablett (C) , Goodwin , Delidio , Stevens , Swan & Johnstone (emerg. Wellingham & Browne)
Ruck - Cox & McIntosh (emerg. Hampson & Deluca)
Forward - Franklin , Richo , Pavlich , J.Brown , Porps , Aka & Rioli (emerg. Morton & tippett)

Of course everything depends on the outcome of Chornes & Bradshaw.

9 trades & 210k in bank.

1st trade - Out: Rioli In: ROK/Chapman??

2nd trade(option1) - (If Chornes plays) Out:Taylor In: Armfield/Urquhart (bench Bradshaw & play my "In" player until bradshaw returns.)

2nd trade(option2) - (If Chornes out for long period) Out:Chornes In: Gilbee/Milburn?? (Bench Bradshaw & hope either Proud or H.Taylor plays)

If I go with 2nd trade(option1) will have $283,900 still in bank with 7 trades left.

Or if you guy's have any better options as I have confused myself even more after typing out all this

 

[boppin]

trading out H taylor this week- J macdonald or Milburn for 60k less. thoughts please?? still looking at Chad Cornes too, or is that just stupid?

 

[Giggidy Giggidy]

i have 4 trades left and looking at an upgrade since i got 480k in the bank! this is my team. any opinions appreciated!

BACKS
heath milburn bradshaw gilbee mcleod kennelly myers (rance mcnamara)

MIDS
coondog goodwin dal santo stevens palmer cotchin (browne coughlan)

RUCKS
simmonds king (hampson bailey)

FORWARDS
buddy(go capt) pav brown roo johnno chappy fev (valenti sellar)

I'd be slowing down on the trades, but one that stands out there is that you've still got Coughlan?!?! $260K sitting on your bench doing nothing all year. I would upgrade him as # 1 priority and hold your other 3 trades.

 

[jimbob7085]

thx quagmire, giggity giggity goo!

 

[weagles_fan]

What is Palmer's BE?

 

[Parasite]

What is Palmer's BE?

82 points

 

[weagles_fan]

82 points

Cheers

 

[TheWiseOne]

what Is Palmer's Be?

82..

 

[gdogga]

Trading Cyril this week:

Should i get -

STEVE JOHNSON and $107,000
or
RICHO and $1,000

??

 

[fugu]

Just did Rioli>SJ

 

[treefingers]

thoughts on this?
Out - Palmer, Ibbotson
In - Bartel, Mcleod.

It would leave my team complete with 9 trades left.

 

[Headless]

thoughts on this?
Out - Palmer, Ibbotson
In - Bartel, Mcleod.

It would leave my team complete with 9 trades left.

Is there a downside?

 

[C-Dog]

thoughts on this?
Out - Palmer, Ibbotson
In - Bartel, Mcleod.

It would leave my team complete with 9 trades left.

nice knowing your team would be complete with 9 trades left!.

ibbotson to mcleoud seems a bit pointless to me, but i guess he could pull out a big one sooner or later.


My trades this week:

OUT: Ellis, Gibbs

IN: Bartel, gilbee/other

leaning towards gilbee any other options?

 

[Team Mo']

nice Knowing Your Team Would Be Complete With 9 Trades Left!.

Ibbotson To Mcleoud Seems A Bit Pointless To Me, But I Guess He Could Pull Out A Big One Sooner Or Later.


My Trades This Week:

Out: Ellis, Gibbs

In: Bartel, Gilbee/other

Leaning Towards Gilbee Any Other Options?

Jon?

 

[C-Dog]

Jon?

JON has great ability to score high, but i guess i am looking for consistency.

btw JON is a midfielder

 

[Birssman]

So i've got 200,000 to spend I can't decide to whether to upgrade,

Koschitzke, T Cloke or even Palmer.

I was leaning towards Kozi to Chapman. What do you guys reakon?

 

[treefingers]

who the hells JON?
anyway I think I'll just do Palmer for Bartel, then in a few weeks S.Thompson --> Rookie and upgrade Simmonds.