Transfer discussion thread

[pantskyle]

Sanchez is easily worth more than an RvP off of that season.

 

[Jatz]

Sanchez is easily worth more than an RvP off of that season.

I'm not so sure. Remember...

Vardy > Sanchez

 

[PendlePie]

Sanchez is easily worth more than an RvP off of that season.

Yep, he's probably worth 2 RvPs

 

[Latro]

Alexis has been better than RVP at Arsenal

 

[Brad Goodman]

Siggurdson is on the verge of a £45m move from Swansea to Everton. If you truly understood and accepted that the market has changed, you'd see why Sanchez is worth a shitload more than £25m even in the last year of his contract.

Comparing prices now to prices in 2011 is comparing apples with oranges.

Sigurdsson is very good but if he's going for 45 there's no way Sanchez isn't worth 60

 

[typeclub]

Pool could easily replace Coutinho with half of the 100m they want. Sigurdson is going for around one Kyle Walker and they are asking for 2 Kyle Walkers for Coutinho. Why are they acting like it can't be done

 

[SM]

Simon Grayson certainly doesn't mind the bargain basement signings. Also got Ross The Boss on loan from AVFC so I doubt we'll do much this season to be honest.

Funny thing is we've competed for most signings haha.

 

[pantskyle]

Sigurdsson is very good but if he's going for 45 there's no way Sanchez isn't worth 60

You can't really compare them, everyone knows they aren't worth the same, but a player is worth what someone will pay, if Everton wish to pay 50m for a player worth 30m than that's up to them. Has no bearing on Sanchez value, 12 months left, 50-60m I personally think is ridiculous for someone you can sign for free in 12 months however it's worth it I suppose.

 

[PendlePie]

12 months left, 50-60m I personally think is ridiculous for someone you can sign for free in 12 months however it's worth it I suppose.

Or you can watch City sign for free (if you're PSG) in 12 months.

He'll be 30 next year and both PSG and City should be fearful of the other signing him, while Juve and Bayern should realise this is probably their final chance. Him being off contract means it's more competitive for his signature though.

 

[pantskyle]

Or you can watch City sign for free (if you're PSG) in 12 months.

He'll be 30 next year and both PSG and City should be fearful of the other signing him, while Juve and Bayern should realist this is probably their final chance. Him being off contract means it's more competitive for his signature though.

Technically teams can sign him in January for free.

 

[elhadjihenry]

You can't really compare them, everyone knows they aren't worth the same, but a player is worth what someone will pay, if Everton wish to pay 50m for a player worth 30m than that's up to them. Has no bearing on Sanchez value, 12 months left, 50-60m I personally think is ridiculous for someone you can sign for free in 12 months however it's worth it I suppose.

We don't want to sell him though so you have to offer enough to appease Arsenal. If someone from outside the PL offered 60-70 we might accept it, any less than that and the club would rather keep him and try and get him to sign a new contract which has been their public stance.

In terms of signing him for free in 12 months it's a similar situation to Liverpool and Keita. They could wait 12 months and get him for the 48m buyout however at that point they will be competing with many other clubs at that price, hence them trying to offer 60-70m now. In 12 months Sanchez could pick his own destination (which I personally think is Man City), so anyone else who wants him would have to buy him now to avoid that.

 

[PendlePie]

Technically teams can sign him in January for free.

How so

 

[largebus]

Forgive me if I'm wrong but 222m is Neymar's buyout so if he wants to go nothing Barca can do about it

If buyout clauses really were binding Arsenal would've bought Suarez for £40,000,001

 

[SM]

How so

Players in the last six months of a deal can sign a pre-contract.

 

[SM]

If buyout clauses really were binding Arsenal would've bought Suarez for £40,000,001

That wasn't a buyout clause.

 

[Zidane98]

Technically teams can sign him in January for free.

Only clubs from overseas can agree a pre contract.

 

[pantskyle]

How so

Pre-contract.

 

[Latro]

Players in the last six months of a deal can sign a pre-contract.

English clubs cant.

 

[pantskyle]

Not sure that is really relevant to why I said, sides exist outside of England.

 

[SM]

English clubs cant.

So PSG/Bayern/Juve could.

 

[Milanista28]

If Alexis wants out and makes it clear he will leave for free in 12 months, Arsenal would be foolish to turn down an offer of 40m.

In my non qualified opinion of all transfer window happenings of course.

 

[elhadjihenry]

Pre-contract.

So they agree a contract for the next window but he stays at Arsenal until his contract runs out at the end of the season. Not exactly the same as "signing him for free in January" which implies getting the player in the January window. Doesn't really change anything imo, if he wants to leave at the end of the season he is going to, whether he agrees that in January or next July/August is incidental.

 

[jd2010]

Diego Simeone's son might be our first signing of the summer. Wouldn't have thought he'd be the one to break the duck this summer! Maybe we are lining up the old man in case Poch takes on the national job one day

 

[elhadjihenry]

If Alexis wants out and makes it clear he will leave for free in 12 months, Arsenal would be foolish to turn down an offer of 40m.

In my non qualified opinion of all transfer window happenings of course.

A season of Alexis is worth more to us than 40m quid. The club are still hopeful he will sign a new contract in the coming season anyway, whether they are right or not is still to be seen but you aren't getting him this window unless you pay big.

 

[SM]

So they agree a contract for the next window but he stays at Arsenal until his contract runs out at the end of the season. Not exactly the same as "signing him for free in January" which implies getting the player in the January window. Doesn't really change anything imo, if he wants to leave at the end of the season he is going to, whether he agrees that in January or next July/August is incidental.

Well it doesn't give Arsenal any chance of re-signing him and also puts pressure on English clubs to try and sign him this window.