UPDATED 2013 list

[Masked Magician]

Backs ​

Toovey Brown Shaw ​

O'Brien Reid Maxwell ​

Mids ​

Jolly Pendlebury Beams ​

Swan Sidebottom C Young ​

Forwards ​

D Thomas Cloke Goldsack ​

Macaffer Lynch Krakouer ​

Interchange ​

Blair Ball Fasolo Didak ​

EMG (the 6 that will be very close0
Elliott Keeffe J Thomas Paine Witts Seedsman

​

​

​

​

​

Senior Depth ​

​

Good future ​

​

Elliott if blair dids or krak gets injuried he is my #1 replacement i rate him highly,​

Keeffe- any KP role, FWD or back, ​

J Thomas - a big mover for mine ​

Paine - caffer lynch or goldy go done he is in​

Witts - when jolly restedSeedsman - showed signs against swans late in season that I liked​

​

​

Experience
Ben Johnson - likely to play on if we don't secure young
Marty Clarke
C Wood - if we hold onto him
Simon Buckley
Ben Sinclair
Marley williams
Russell

National Draft picks ​

18, 19, 21, 42, 48​

 

[Rusty22]

our draft picks are delish

 

[Pera]

Look at all the depth!

I'd have Johnson start on the bench and Macaffer starting in the two's though. No real rotation off half back if Johnson doesn't play.

Looks amazing though.

 

[jackcass]

What, Williams & Mooney didn't do enough this year to warrant consideration under the "good future" selections... and Ceglar & Gault wont show any further improvement on their 2012 performances....

 

[blaze036]

What, Williams & Mooney didn't do enough this year to warrant consideration under the "good future" selections... and Ceglar & Gault wont show any further improvement on their 2012 performances....

imo williams and mooney will play over 30 games between them next year.

 

[vjknight]

Look at all the depth!

I'd have Johnson start on the bench and Macaffer starting in the two's though. No real rotation off half back if Johnson doesn't play.

Looks amazing though.

imo williams and mooney will play over 30 games between them next year.

much like 2010 (and as i wanted in 2011) i can see a changing of the guard in relation to those who 2013 will be their final year. didak would have to show his '12 form, and johnson & jolly remain injury free for them to be in the team come finals time. most of seedsman, mooney, williams & elliott, along with one of ceglar or witts, need to be in the team on merit to provide that speed & youthful exhuberance we will need.

and obviously interesting to see what magic hine produces, and these new players abilities & desire to force their way in as well.

 

[Bianconerri]

Masked Magician, if you want to see the Pies win the flag in 2013

In Marley Williams

Out Nick Maxwell

 

[tazzawazza]

Although T

Backs


Toovey Brown Shaw


O'Brien Reid Maxwell



Mids


Jolly Pendlebury Beams


Swan Sidebottom (C Young - might get him, if not see depth players)



Forwards


Thomas Cloke Goldsack


Macaffer Lynch Krakouer



Interchange


Blair Ball Fasolo Didak




Senior Depth


Good future

Elliott if blair dids or krak gets injuried he is my #1 replacement i rate him highly,
Keeffe- any KP role, FWD or back,
J Thomas - a big mover for mine
Paine - caffer lynch or goldy go done he is in
Witts - when jolly rested


Seedsman - showed signs against swans late in season that I liked

Experience
Ben Johnson - likely to play on if we don't secure young
Marty Clarke
C Wood - if we hold onto him
Tom Young
Simon Buckley
Ben Sinclair



National Draft picks


17, 18, 20, 39, 45
[/quote

 

[tazzawazza]

Although T

Backs


Toovey Brown Shaw


O'Brien Reid Maxwell



Mids


Jolly Pendlebury Beams


Swan Sidebottom (C Young - might get him, if not see depth players)



Forwards


Thomas Cloke Goldsack


Macaffer Lynch Krakouer



Interchange


Blair Ball Fasolo Didak




Senior Depth


Good future

Elliott if blair dids or krak gets injuried he is my #1 replacement i rate him highly,
Keeffe- any KP role, FWD or back,
J Thomas - a big mover for mine
Paine - caffer lynch or goldy go done he is in
Witts - when jolly rested


Seedsman - showed signs against swans late in season that I liked

Experience
Ben Johnson - likely to play on if we don't secure young
Marty Clarke
C Wood - if we hold onto him
Tom Young
Simon Buckley
Ben Sinclair



National Draft picks


17, 18, 20, 39, 45

Although Thomas is regarded more of a midfielder, I'd like to see him as a permanent forward if we get Young. Daisy is capable of kicking up to 40-50 goals a season as a perm forward IMO and I reckon we would need that considering our dull 2012 forward line. Geelong have done it with Bartel apparently

 

[iGNITER]

B – Maxwell Brown Toovey
HB – Shaw Reid O’Brien
C – Beams Swan Sidebottom
HF – Thomas Cloke Didak
F – Krakouer Lynch Goldsack
R – Jolly Ball Pendlebury

INT – Fasolo Blair Macaffer

SUB – Johnson

EMG – Seedsman Elliott Clarke Mooney


INJ – Keeffe, Paine, Williams


Starting 22 for next season.

Lukey Ball is a massive inclusion to the side.

I like Thomas on a HFF pushing up to the wing because he has X-Factor

Looking forward to using the first 3 draft picks (17,18 & 20) on some quality gun kids. They can play majority of the season for the VFL development but hopefully they all get 2-3 games throughout the year.
Would love to see us get Stringer, Menzel & White.

 

[millsy29gopies]

Masked Magician, if you want to see the Pies win the flag in 2013

In Marley Williams

Out Nick Maxwell

Honestly, what is your obession with getting rid of Maxwell? You really don't seem like a true Collingwood supporter.

 

[tazzawazza]

Honestly, what is your obession with getting rid of Maxwell? You really don't seem like a true Collingwood supporter.

Maxwell 5th in Copeland!

 

[Pie_fan92]

Would love to see Marley Williams and Keeffe consolidate a spot in the 22 this year. Love how Williams goes about it, hes tough and not afraid to throw his body in the contest. Keeffe is very versatile and showed promise before his injury. He actually looked comfortable when thrown in the forward line against Brisbane and kicked a couple of goals IIRC.

 

[Hotpiescoldbeers]

If hine nails this draft, it could be the difference between a flag or a prelim

 

[Masked Magician]

I love marley In hindsight he is stiff not to get a mention... My only worry is his kicking, as he is a bit of a foreigner to the game it is easy to notice some flaws other than that i like him as a player his toughness and pace

 

[Pie_fan92]

If hine nails this draft, it could be the difference between a flag or a prelim

While I do agree with you to a certain extent I think our gameplan needs to be looked at by Bucks and co. and we need improvement from everyone

 

[Masked Magician]

imo williams and mooney will play over 30 games between them next year.

Williams 25 mooney 5

 

[Masked Magician]

While I do agree with you to a certain extent I think our gameplan needs to be looked at by Bucks and co. and we need improvement from everyone

agree sometimes we lacked that plan b eg north game or the pre lim

 

[Pie_fan92]

agree sometimes we lacked that plan b eg north game or the pre lim

Even our plan A was a bit of a mess, we were woeful from the kickouts (both defence and offence) and teams with pace (Carlton, North, Hawthorn) would cut us to shreds through the corridor. I have faith that Bucks can rectify this over the off-season.

 

[blaze036]

Williams 25 mooney 5

mooney played 4 in his first year and his improvement will be steep, he will replace sinclair and become a regular by round 11. Williams will be a regular after round 5-6 and miss a handful through injury i reckon

 

[Masked Magician]

Even our plan A was a bit of a mess, we were woeful from the kickouts (both defence and offence) and teams with pace (Carlton, North, Hawthorn) would cut us to shreds through the corridor. I have faith that Bucks can rectify this over the off-season.

Agree, this year was the year I noticed how easily other teams kicked out and how hard we had to work to get it out of our DEF

 

[TradeDraft]

Backs ​

Toovey Brown Shaw ​

O'Brien Reid Maxwell ​

Mids ​

Jolly Pendlebury Beams ​

Swan Sidebottom (C Young - might get him, if not see depth players)​

Forwards ​

Thomas Cloke Goldsack ​

Macaffer Lynch Krakouer ​

Interchange ​

Blair Ball Fasolo Didak ​

Senior Depth ​

Good future ​

​

Elliott if blair dids or krak gets injuried he is my #1 replacement i rate him highly,​

Keeffe- any KP role, FWD or back, ​

J Thomas - a big mover for mine ​

Paine - caffer lynch or goldy go done he is in​

Witts - when jolly rested​

Seedsman - showed signs against swans late in season that I liked​

​

Experience
Ben Johnson - likely to play on if we don't secure young
Marty Clarke
C Wood - if we hold onto him
Tom Young
Simon Buckley
Ben Sinclair

National Draft picks ​

17, 18, 20, 39, 45​

Well you can Put Young in there Now 100% sure.

Reckon Simon Buckley could be De-Listed now with the Young Signing

 

[Masked Magician]

Well you can Put Young in there Now 100% sure.

Reckon Simon Buckley could be De-Listed now with the Young Signing

Ben johnson might be a 50/50 now
Up side he is a vet, we will see how it pans out

 

[blaze036]

Agree, this year was the year I noticed how easily other teams kicked out and how hard we had to work to get it out of our DEF

yep, in our last few games of the year every opposition kickout they left a pocket free, then had someone lead into it and get an easy mark, then went long and normally had an extra man on the wing and in 5 secs they had gone from kick in to attacking 50. However in our kickins, i didn't really notice any good tactics and we seemed to struggle to get it out.

 

[Knightmare]

With Young and Lynch it's looking interesting.

I have a best side of:

B: Harry O'Brien Lachlan Keeffe Alan Toovey
HB: Nick Maxwell Nathan Brown Ben Reid
CEN: Clinton Young Scott Pendlebury Steele Sidebottom
HF: Alex Fasolo Travis Cloke Dayne Beams
F: Andrew Krakouer Quinten Lynch Tyson Goldsack
FOLL: Darren Jolly Luke Ball Dane Swan
BENCH: Heath Shaw Dale Thomas Jarryd Blair
SUB: Alan Didak
EMG: Jamie Elliott Jackson Paine Ben Johnson