Value: Gibbs vs McGovern

[The Edukator]

Who's value was higher prior to being traded?

Gibbs went for 10, 16, 73.

Should Adelaide receive better than that, ie a pick higher than 10?

 

[juss]

McGovern should not get more than the Gibbs trade.

 

[Masqualero]

Gibbs has runs on the board and good history with injuries.

He would be worth more at the time of the trade than MM is now.

 

[Funk]

Gibbs will probably win Crows B&F this year.

How will MM go?

 

[Stratton_Gun]

When you look at McGoverns stats they really aren't that fantastic. Mostly hype. Hasn't he only kicked 48 goals on his career as a key forward?
Gibbs was older but the much better player. If McGovern wants out then a mid first rounder is his worth

 

[Blackas87]

When you look at McGoverns stats they really aren't that fantastic. Mostly hype. Hasn't he only kicked 48 goals on his career as a key forward?
Gibbs was older but the much better player. If McGovern wants out then a mid first rounder is his worth

67 goals from 48 games.

He’s going to turn 24 in a month.

2nd round pick

 

[pinot]

67 goals from 48 games.

He’s going to turn 24 in a month.

2nd round pick

In a nutshell

 

[SickQwon]

Subtle Adelaide troll.

 

[The Edukator]

Subtle Adelaide troll.

There's been genuine debate between the two supporter groups. I think this poll validates reality vs delusion.

 

[Juddernaut08]

When you look at McGoverns stats they really aren't that fantastic. Mostly hype. Hasn't he only kicked 48 goals on his career as a key forward?
Gibbs was older but the much better player. If McGovern wants out then a mid first rounder is his worth

Gibbs definitely a better player but McGovern has more excitement

 

[juss]

67 goals from 48 games.

He’s going to turn 24 in a month.

2nd round pick

Thought he was younger than that. By that age gun forwards are reasonably more established.

2nd rounder seems about right.

 

[Juddernaut08]

Well looks like we shall soon see. TBH not even the most delusional Crows fanbois think theyre getting two first rounders.

Hope SOS can get it done for a 2nd plus mature.