Was it Fifty?

[Gouldy]

Everyone knows what I am talking about.

Was it Fifty?

and

Would it have affected the result?

 

[Kahuna]

Yes it should have been 50.

Who knows whether it would of affected the result.

 

[Hallie_Swift]

perhaps, never will know, not the only poor decision the umpires made today.

 

[blues4flag]

Does it matter?

We got the ball down to Fev and had as good a chance as we were going to get it to win the game.

Doesn't matter.

 

[JuddyBuddy]

Yes. Was the same as Rocca last week. Ran off after the call.

 

[Gouldy]

perhaps, never will know, not the only poor decision the umpires made today.

They really turned to poo in the 2nd half of the game, poor decisions both ways. One of them had only umpired like 13 games.

 

[Johnny Friendly]

Yes, but Jeff's $5000 fine has to get him something doesn't it?!

Wouldn't have mattered anyway- Fev should have kicked the goal at the end of the day. Bad miss, nil points, Hawks can go boast all they want - Carlton did really well today.

 

[MBIB]

Wouldn't have mattered but it certainly should have been paid.

 

[Artie Bucco]

Yes is should have been 50, doesn't effect the game at all. We got it down to Fev anyway and missed, that's life. Stevens getting tackled should have been holding the ball / incorrect disposal which wasn't paid.

 

[jiphoc]

Was it 50? Yes

However why I think it was not played was that the umpire was not in the players line of site and and I highly doubt been that close to the Hawks fans who where going nuts at that time they would have heard anything either. I would like to think that that is why 50 was not payed. If so brilliant umpiring.

 

[HBF]

Certainly should have been 50. When you consider it gets paid when the ball isn't delivered back to the player on a silver platter, then it should have been paid.

And no, it shouldn't have affected the game. Fevola should have kicked the goal.

 

[MBIB]

Certainly should have been 50. When you consider it gets paid when the ball isn't delivered back to the player on a silver platter, then it should have been paid.

And no, it shouldn't have affected the game. Fevola should have kicked the goal.

Yes he should have, 100% right. But we should have done a lot more things through the 4 quarters not to have had to rely on the last kick of the day. Which ever way..khe sera I guess.

 

[HeziBarecket]

Fev shoulkd have kicked it. The rest is rubbish.

Jeff Kennett is still a twat who would look like Adolf Hitler if he had the 'mo.

 

[DamoESP]

Fev shoulkd have kicked it. The rest is rubbish.

Jeff Kennett is still a twat who would look like Adolf Hitler if he had the 'mo.

Awww come on, no need to bring Hitler down to that level.

 

[as0l0]

wouldn't have made a difference since the footy gods didn't want us to have this one.

 

[MBIB]

Fev shoulkd have kicked it. The rest is rubbish.

Jeff Kennett is still a twat who would look like Adolf Hitler if he had the 'mo.

He is a twat but I have to say I'm glad someone's taking the bigwigs at the AFL to task and winning.

 

[zeeCFC]

wouldn't have made a difference since the footy gods didn't want us to have this one.

i say we offer cloke to these footy gods as a sacrifice

 

[TBoyleSuperstar]

Definitely 50, but would it have changed th result, probably not. In a way it probably would hacve helped hawthorn in that they would have had time to flood back more, whereas the way it worked, Fev had space deep.

 

[Stig O'Hara]

Probably 50,
but after Fev went all Greg Norman,
there was still a minute and a half after that.

The Roughead mark/free in the first quarter still baffles me.

Am over it now.

 

[jj1978]

Yes shoulda been....

Judd - holding the ball.... (murphy and judd having same hairdo could've been the issue with that one).

Russel - push in the back... Russel was holding the guys arms/shoulders.. hawk player dived forward momentum causing Russ to look like he pushed player in the back.

The umps don't love us like they do some teams.. but today they weren't at their worst.

 

[celtic_pride]

Awww come on, no need to bring Hitler down to that level.

At the end of the day, puh-lease lets not turn into Collingwood fans adn blame the umpires for today's loss, I thought they did a mostly fine job really, have no complaints at all ...

I'm much more annoyed with Thornton's pathetic efforts today on Roughie then Fev's miss.

 

[Beloved]

Should have been a free kick but we got the ball to Fev in the end.

 

[rofltown]

Fev had a chance from an easy shot an blew it so no, it doesn't matter. We lost today because we simply don't have a good enough list to beat these middle range teams and I doubt we'll make finals unless we really change things up. Lost 3 of our last 4 and going into play a Freo team whos on a two game winning streak. Things could start to get sketchy real soon...

 

[Beloved]

Fev had a chance from an easy shot an blew it so no, it doesn't matter. We lost today because we simply don't have a good enough list to beat these middle range teams and I doubt we'll make finals unless we really change things up. Lost 3 of our last 4 and going into play a Freo team whos on a two game winning streak. Things could start to get sketchy real soon...

Of course we do! We went down by four points. It's not as though we weren't in it.

I don't understand how you can say that we don't have the list to beat those kinds of teams. I think it's the loss talking.

 

[macdaddio]

Fev had a chance from an easy shot an blew it so no, it doesn't matter. We lost today because we simply don't have a good enough list to beat these middle range teams and I doubt we'll make finals unless we really change things up. Lost 3 of our last 4 and going into play a Freo team whos on a two game winning streak. Things could start to get sketchy real soon...

Dont mean to jump on your board and add my 2 cents worth but this middle range team you are talking about just won the 2008 permiership, and atm are having a bad run with injuries and with our back line atm you guys should of won easily...