- Joined
- May 26, 2013
- Posts
- 25,090
- Reaction score
- 36,758
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Liverpool FC
- Thread starter
- #651
Good thing I bumped this thread so we could find another place to argue about Mackay 

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Super Bowl LVIII Notice Image
New England Patomans v Seattle Microsofts - Live Game Chat Now
PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
BigFooty Tipping Notice Img
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Opening Round
The Golden Ticket - Official AFL on-seller of MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.

Would love to see itSmith to the mids? Its long been a dream and would really add some class footskills and break away speed to the midfield mix. His apprenticeship on the HBF may have run its course?
Smith in midfield with a 26 yo body is worth a lookIt's actually harder than that because Kelly is no longer playing in the backline.
Too many defenders.
Ideally Doedee will step up Rampe style and be able to handle the 2nd tall. Then Hartigan/Keath gets squeezed out against all but the tallest forward lines. We become extremely mobile then with heaps of rebound.
I don't have any faith that this will happen though. We'll just move Smith/Milera somewhere else.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
I think Milera could be better suited to a midfield role. He works better in traffic than Smith and is starting to apply the defensive pressure.
Milera for Dougie in the midfield rotation could be the move eventually.
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
IMO he will leave at the end of the year. We have Milera, Seedsman, Smith and even McPherson in the future who all play his role better.
He just can't fit in, especially when you bear in mind the number of ACTUAL best 22 players we had out last night
True.I hope he does leave/gets delisted as well
We've long shown that we're willing to put up with a worse structure to accommodate him, or leave better options in the reserves.
True.
Milera has stepped up to another level. I hope last night, in the biggest of pressure games, we saw what we are going to see for the next 10 years.
Milera was great last night, not just what he did with the ball, but also with his defensive efforts.
I have been a little harsh on him thus far, but last night was definitely a massive tick.
Maybe he has found his niche in defense.
I think Milera could be better suited to a midfield role. He works better in traffic than Smith and is starting to apply the defensive pressure.
Milera for Dougie in the midfield rotation could be the move eventually.
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
Would love to see it
The thing I thought was most noticeable about Jnr's game last night (and at times throughout the season), Is that he ran HARD! I've been banging the drum about his dawdling from contest to contest, and his half paced chasing of opponents for the last 2 years. It was one of my biggest pet peeves as a spectator.
But when he runs hard through the ball he's an absolute joy to watch. I think he might just be one of those players who needs a rocket before the game to get him in the right headspace! Cause when he's on, he's the missing piece of the puzzle that this team is absolutely desperate for!

Yeah I wouldn't move him off that HBF for the rest of the season, even when Smith comes back. Smith wont be able to go as long as he usually does from all the time away so will need to rotate quite heavily. So it will be cool to seem them split that role this year.Yeah, that's how I saw it, too. I've always said that he clearly has the ability, but the issue with him is more around the lack of intensity. Too often he looks like he's just running along at 60% or milling about aimlessly on the fringes of a contest waiting and hoping the the ball will come out. This year there has still been a fair bit of that, but he has played a handful of very good games like last night that make me think he will make it. I'm not completely buying in yet, but I at least have him on lay-by now
When we've played him across half back he's looked like a potential gun. Play him at half forward and he looks like a middling SANFL player. Definitely needs to develop another string to his bow in addition to half back, whether that's as a forward or maybe on a wing or something. It'll be interesting next year if we're able to rotate Smith, Laird, Seedsman and Milera all through half-back / midfield.
Everytime we've trialled Smith with stints in the middle he barely even resembles a shadow of his normal self. He just can't seem to make it work.
Just seems to read the game so much better from the backlines. We have Atkins, Milera and Seedsman now. Think we should keep Smith where he is most damaging for us.
Give it another go he's more mature now and bigger bodyEverytime we've trialled Smith with stints in the middle he barely even resembles a shadow of his normal self. He just can't seem to make it work.
Just seems to read the game so much better from the backlines. We have Atkins, Milera and Seedsman now. Think we should keep Smith where he is most damaging for us.
The marks were probably what impressed me the most. Big bonus if you can have a smaller rebounding guy take contested marks in the back half.Runs the lines so well off hb. Took some great marks aswell. Is going to be a very good player for us.
looking for all the posters who claimed he is soft at the contest