Player Watch Sam Murray - (Delisted 2019)

[NoobPie]

Hilarious reading all the know all here

I'm looking forward to watching him play in the stripes

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Once again, people using a quote referring to this year's draft. It's next year's that people aren't happy about.

Nah, I used it because even those who have some concerns still gave as a B and to show how those in the industry see things differently to those in the sewer

 

[loki04]

Nah, I used it because even those who have some concerns still gave as a B and to show how those in the industry see things differently to those in the sewer

If this is/we are a sewer then that means you're just another tird happily floating in it.

 

[Quicky]

Hey grimlock do you know if Murray is able to shut down an opponent as a small defender? Can he actually defend?

 

[loki04]

Hey grimlock do you know if Murray is able to shut down an opponent as a small defender? Can he actually defend?

I posted a link to the full game of the 17 neafl gf if you want to watch it.

 

[Quicky]

I posted a link to the full game of the 17 neafl gf if you want to watch it.

I would if I had data. Have you watched it? How'd he go?

 

[jmac70]

Yes, they are deflection comments to appease the "sheep".

The draft pick he needs to be compared to is the one we lose in 2018, not a points algorithm of what is left over for this years draft. We had a likely top 30 pick in a very strong draft which we flipped for Murray and a pick in the 40-50s in said draft.

You can not tell me that over 2 drafts there would not be a player of medium height, reasonable pace and a long sometimes accurate, sometimes not, kick. The club could of walked, Swanz were extracting the piss.

What if we still get the player we wanted with the later pick?

 

[DraftBalta]

Its nice to see that the art of fine debate is alive and well.

Yeah

 

[TradeDraft]

I posted a link to the full game of the 17 neafl gf if you want to watch it.

and There are more Games in the NEAFL youtube Channel

 

[DraftBalta]

Thinking it's a good call doesn't make you a spin doctor and thinking it's a bad call doesn't mean you're taking a dump on the club.

Lot of people myself included went off without knowing the full details

 

[TradeDraft]

I would if I had data. Have you watched it? How'd he go?

I downloaded the Game but not Watched much of it yet

 

[BPikkers]

Then you walk away...

We aren't talking about a young Ablett jnr here.

Why would you walk away? You want the player and maybe the swans want the player? I think you totally misunderstood my post.

The guys saying we overpaid seem to feel they know a lot more about what the swan’s intention was with him and how much they valued him. What I’m saying is that these people have no more an idea than any of us who aren’t melting calling for Hine’s resignation.

Have you watched Murray play or just snippets? I’ve got a feeling our recruiting department have been watching him for some time and each of his games. That being the case, who is the better judge to evaluate his potential?

‘Oh but 2018 is a superdraft’. Well, it may be, but I have only heard the same 5-10 names pop up. I hear there are 5 exceptional players who could have gone top 5 this draft. I haven’t heard the names of the ‘amazing’ 15-30 picks.

2013 has been labelled a ‘superdraft’ only recently. Kelly, Bont, Billings are the only players in the top 10 that help this claim. Cripps, McCarthy(?), Jones were picked in 10-20. Crouch, Merrett, Lobb 20-30. 30-40 wouldn’t worry about. 40-50 B Brown and maybe Barrass (?). 50-60 Fantasia, Sicily, Hunt. McGovern, Laird, Rampe were rookie elevation.

What this says to me is that there are no guarantee and a ‘superdraft’ has some top players in the first 10, and 1 in 3/4 every 10 players and spread through to pick 60 (Langdon was mid 60s) and excellent rookie elevations.

So a pick in the 20s or 30s still has a low level of success.

 

[Carringbush2010]

Biggs from Sydney to Bulldaogs.... Flag
Nankervis from Sydney to Tuggers. .. Flag
Murray from Sydney to Collingwood. ......

That's rather optimistic and highly unlikely

 

[Darkyprotector]

Key back? He’s 180cm. Didn’t you just accuse me of not doing any research?

Glad you've caught up, well aware of that
Plays above his height like most these days
Ask 194 cm balta
Happy to bring him to your attention

 

[Darkyprotector]

W

It's not Holtz-Fitz he was referring to, it's Issac Quaynor who's stocks are quickly rising. I hope Dekka didn't shoot himself in the foot.

Well if we pay too much it will be because the words out
It already was
Maybe SOME trust

 

[Darkyprotector]

Isaac Quaynor is the academy player on the watchlist for next year. Plays for Oakleigh Chargers and is a Next Generation Academy member.

5th in the Chargers best and fairest tnis year and best 1st year player.

http://taccup.com.au/quaynor-rising-for-chargers/

Also missed early games

 

[partypie]

It's not Holtz-Fitz he was referring to, it's Issac Quaynor who's stocks are quickly rising. I hope Dekka didn't shoot himself in the foot.

Yep you're right - for some reason I was leading off with Quaynor and Kelly and then for some reason switched it to Holt-Fitz (mostly because I couldn't find the article I'd read on him).

 

[Apex36]

Glad you've caught up, well aware of that
Plays above his height like most these days
Ask 194 cm balta
Happy to bring him to your attention

Oh well in that case lock him in for CHB for the next decade

 

[Darkyprotector]

Oh well in that case lock him in for CHB for the next decade

Maybe also has grown 185
That helps

 

[Apex36]

Maybe also has grown 185
That helps

Oh well if that’s case let’s lock him in to CHB for the next decade.

 

[sr36]

He bounces the ball with his right hand and kicks with his left, not much vision of his opposite side.

That's often a bad sign in terms of kicking, due to the ball drop being with the non-preffered hand or in the case of Swanny two handed and therefore too high. But supposedly it's a good sign in terms of spacial awareness - something to do with an increased ability to cross the midline and switch between eyes .

 

[sr36]

It's not Holtz-Fitz he was referring to, it's Issac Quaynor who's stocks are quickly rising. I hope Dekka didn't shoot himself in the foot.

He's playing TAC Cup. It's not like he was hidden away playing in a remote community, other teams would already be aware of him if he is any good.

 

[dirts]

That's often a bad sign in terms of kicking, due to the ball drop being with the non-preffered hand or in the case of Swanny two handed and therefore too high. But supposedly it's a good sign in terms of spacial awareness - something to do with an increased ability to cross the midline and switch between eyes .

Graham Wright went ok using a left hand bounce being a right footer.

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Maybe also has grown 185
That helps

Holy s**t he's 365 cm tall, that's nearly 12 foot!

 

[sr36]

Graham Wright went ok using a left hand bounce being a right footer.

He did indeed.