Autopsy Same Old St Kilda…..Another Dog Act

[Stronzatello]

Pathetic…..kings of the king hits! Enough said!!!

 

[PIEWITHSAUCE]

I think he was trying for a forearm jolt to the chest but if you take that action (like bumping) you have to deal with the consequences if you get it wrong. If Murph misses next week he's a cert to miss 1-2 himself.

 

[mocamagic]

I think he was trying for a forearm jolt to the chest but if you take that action (like bumping) you have to deal with the consequences if you get it wrong. If Murph misses next week he's a cert to miss 1-2 himself.

4-6 more realistic

 

[Stronzatello]

John Greening as well. Piss weak club!!

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Said this on the main board but it’s a shame if he goes, he makes St Kilda worse IMO

 

[Magpie Since 1986]

Fremantle allegedly paid hush money to their staff after Ross Lyon sexually harassed them in 2018.
Report: Ross Lyon’s alleged harassment remark revealed

This is the character of the person St Kilda thought fit to lead their club ... What do you expect from St Kilda ?

 

[PIEWITHSAUCE]

4-6 more realistic

If he gets 4+ weeks I would be very,very surprised but we'll see. In the end he deserves whatever he gets - I just can't see it myself.

I'll go for 2 weeks (careless/high impact) as I don't think intent was there...............more dumb than malicious.

 

[Harry O]

Is Jim O’Dea a life member at St Kilda. The answer might tell you everything you need to know about this gutter slime of a club

 

[Roverjg]

I think he was trying for a forearm jolt to the chest but if you take that action (like bumping) you have to deal with the consequences if you get it wrong. If Murph misses next week he's a cert to miss 1-2 himself.

It has been confirmed Murph has entered concussion protocols and will miss Anzac Day

On SM-N975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[TradeDraft]

Be O'Dea's Favorite Player

 

[Doc1763]

Is Jim O’Dea a life member at St Kilda. The answer might tell you everything you need to know about this gutter slime of a club

They picked him in their team of the century.

 

[The Ghost of the KPF]

They are a sh*tstain of a club.

3 week holiday but should be taken out the back and flogged

 

[Roverjg]

Pathetic…..kings of the king hits! Enough said!!!

Harsh when Murphy was the instigator

On SM-N975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[TradeDraft]

Been a Assault IF was not on a Footy Field

 

[Kirby]

If he gets 4+ weeks I would be very,very surprised but we'll see. In the end he deserves whatever he gets - I just can't see it myself.

I'll go for 2 weeks (careless/high impact) as I don't think intent was there...............more dumb than malicious.

It’s behind the play and concussed him. He’s a certainty to get at least 3 weeks.

 

[pz5151]

It’s behind the play and concussed him. He’s a certainty to get at least 3 weeks.

What happened? Was at the game and didn’t notice the incident

 

[Kirby]

What happened? Was at the game and didn’t notice the incident

They were niggling near the goals whilst the ball was about 50 metres away and Murphy shoved him in the shoulder neck (facing each other) then Caminiti threw his left arm at him and hit him in the head, knocking him to the ground. Looked like a forearm.

 

[JoinDate]

 

[MoreMoore]

Hate Ross Lyon
Hate his game style
Good to hate the Saints again
Game needs villains

 

[VinnieB]

Hate Ross Lyon
Hate his game style
Good to hate the Saints again
Game needs villains

I hope they win next week.
Bloos fans will cry asking how they ****ed up getting Voss.

 

[Matt_352]

I think he was trying for a forearm jolt to the chest but if you take that action (like bumping) you have to deal with the consequences if you get it wrong. If Murph misses next week he's a cert to miss 1-2 himself.

Anything less than 4 is unacceptable

 

[Apex36]

Saints fans on the main board arguing it was only medium impact, and that because Murphy started it their boy will only get 1-2 weeks.

Delusional.

 

[jonbe54]

They are a sh*tstain of a club.

3 week holiday but should be taken out the back and flogged

That's what would have happened in Gabbo's day, wait for the mongrel to come out of the ground and give a thorough thrashing.

 

[PIEWITHSAUCE]

Anything less than 4 is unacceptable

I'm certainly not saying 4 weeks would be super unfair , but that I think two (perhaps three) is more likely based on how I viewed the intent.

When it comes down to it , is it classed as "intentional high contact" if he intended to hit Murph with a forearm to the chest and misjudged things as he stumbled a bit and copped him in the chin? If that is in fact considered intentional high contact then yeah - I guess I am potentially underestimating the suspension. If it falls under "careless" as I was thinking then I think I am in the right ballpark.

Will be interesting to see how it pans out.

In the end I'll be happy as long as there are no consequences long term for Nathan and his footy , because he's really on the up and up.

 

[barrackers]

Gaff got 8 weeks for what started as a push shove a long way off the ball and ended as a broken jaw due to Brayshaw shifting downwards at the same time Gaff swung.

Injury isn’t as gruesome, but Gaff’s whack was also 5 season’s ago and the AFL has shifted to a harder stance on high contact.

I’m expecting 4-6 weeks for Caminiti, but I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s in the Gaff range.