Werewolf Werewolf Game Discussion Thread

[timtamWB]

Yes, it's a "Rest of AFL" scenario with officials and players.

Can you assign certain players to certain people, not tell them who they are, but incorporate the player into the death story?

 

[ClarkeM]

Can you assign certain players to certain people, not tell them who they are, but incorporate the player into the death story?

I think the people with roles will know their name and then the villagers are just Footy Fans who want the saga to be over.

 

[pantskyle]

I think the people with roles will know their name and then the villagers are just Footy Fans who want the saga to be over.

Is essendon the evil group?

 

[ClarkeM]

Is essendon the evil group?

Yeah they'll be the werewolves I think and ASADA the mob.

 

[pantskyle]

Yeah they'll be the werewolves I think and ASADA the mob.

Should be all Essendon as evil. ASADA are clearly good

 

[Ashton Agar]

Should be all Essendon as evil. ASADA are clearly good

Think you have it the wrong way around! ASADA the wolves, AFL the mob and Essendon the good!

 

[pantskyle]

Think you have it the wrong way around! ASADA the wolves, AFL the mob and Essendon the good!

 

[Ashton Agar]

Great man.

 

[Golumless]

Think you have it the wrong way around! ASADA the wolves, AFL the mob and Essendon the good!

Might want to lay off the Kool Aid man.

 

[ClarkeM]

Here's what I have come up with so far:
Essendon: Werewolves
- Stephen Dank (Chemist - Is immune for one kill attempt. A double-kill or consecutive kills will see them die.)
- Dean Robinson
- David Evans (Seer)
- Ian Robson
- James Hird (Cub - when Hird dies, the wolves get two kills)


ASADA: Mafia
- CEO (Seer)
- Intelligence (Media person - gets to write something in private to use during the day that we can publish anonymously to the rest of the group sometime after day votes have been called off)
- Investigator
- Tester
- Financier (When this person dies, the mafia will recruit one villager as insurance. If all villagers are dead, they will recruit a random member of good).

 

[ClarkeM]

Currently coming up with the good roles but they aren't as fun I don't think.

Would love some input.

I have this as a draft so far:

Heath Shaw and Alan Didak
Flogs
They are two members who will receive a clue each night. They are also able to kill ONCE during one single day phase. This must be sent via PM on the day they choose and before the end of the call for votes.


Barry Hall
Vigilante


Jonathon Brown
Vigilante

 

[Smartys Power]

I like the sound of this a lot.

 

[brahj]

Caro and Robbo as seer/fake seer?

 

[Loonerty]

Chemist - Is immune for one kill attempt. A double-kill or consecutive kills will see them die.

How would this be moderated?

Caro and Robbo as seer/fake seer?

In which order? Can't exactly have 2 fake seers.

 

[ClarkeM]

I'm abolishing the fake seer role this game. Will compensate with something else.

Loonerty, say the vigilante attacks the Chemist, he survives however it won't be told how he survived. There may be an amulet of protection/guardian/both role(s) going around too and they'll all be kept hidden in order to protect the above.

Some nights or days, some people will survive. It's up to the village to decide whether or not they were protected by the amulet, by the guardian or by the immunisation to one kill. Thoughts?

 

[ClarkeM]

Have just about developed my game. Will be a relatively big one but I think it'll work as we could get some non-SFA people in to have some fun.

Will post when I feel like it's an alright time to do so.


Really excited about this one.

 

[The_Reaper]

this is the greatest

 

[Footypie32]

Any future games must disallow any talk surrounding PMs whatsoever. Just ruins the game. And no bloody clues. Clues suck.

 

[TheFreshBanana]

Any future games must disallow any talk surrounding PMs whatsoever. Just ruins the game. And no bloody clues. Clues suck.

It's too hard to keep in check, re: the PMs.

The best solution is to keep PM info brief. There is no need for my action to have a specific name, which is what I caught The_Reaper out with.

And agree with the clues, but like I said previously, they need to be erred on the side of caution, and kept on the harder side, not easier.

How good the clues are, depends on who gives them.

However, you were bit a unfortunate, because the pies meaning Collingwood is a good one, but me and ClarkeM had already been distinguished as good at that point.

You wouldn't have been caught out, had that not been the case.

 

[Footypie32]

The Flogs should be the MRP. Each day they give someone carry-over points so they start the day with 2 votes.

 

[The_Reaper]

I think one clue per game for the flogs is the best.

 

[Footypie32]

It's too hard to keep in check, re: the PMs.

The best solution is to keep PM info brief. There is no need for my action to have a specific name, which is what I caught The_Reaper out with.

And agree with the clues, but like I said previously, they need to be erred on the side of caution, and kept on the harder side, not easier.

How good the clues are, depends on who gives them.

However, you were bit a unfortunate, because the pies meaning Collingwood is a good one, but me and ClarkeM had already been distinguished as good at that point.

You wouldn't have been caught out, had that not been the case.

How is it hard to keep in check? Revealing the contents of PMs is always banned. Should be treated the same way posting after you're dead is treated. If the mod feels you've influenced the game you get Mod-killed.

 

[TheFreshBanana]

I think one clue per game for the flogs is the best.

But then, how easy does the clue have to be?

Because if it's only one clue, then I'm thinking the clue should be a name on a platter type clue, which seems bullshit.

But if a clue is hard, and you only get one per game, it seems a bit useless.

 

[TheFreshBanana]

How is it hard to keep in check? Revealing the contents of PMs is always banned. Should be treated the same way posting after you're dead is treated. If the mod feels you've influenced the game you get Mod-killed.

I HATE restrictions.

It ruins the game.

Being filtered as to what you can and can't say, is a terrible idea.

And since when was revealing the contests of PM always banned? If I was a seer, and I got told you were the Right Hand Man. Well, I'm going to reveal that content. Same as the clue.

 

[ClarkeM]

this is the greatest

congrats you won using the cheapest method ever

What 24 hours can do to some people...