Werewolf Werewolf Game Discussion Thread

[The_Reaper]

But then, how easy does the clue have to be?

Because if it's only one clue, then I'm thinking the clue should be a name on a platter type clue, which seems bullshit.

But if a clue is hard, and you only get one per game, it seems a bit useless.

Good point.

My view is that if the clue is going to suggest someone is innocent- then it can be direct. Otherwise you need to leave room for the evil to be able to argue themselves out of it.

Like lets say the clue is about the wereboncer and you are are the wereboncer.

There are 15 players left and 4 West Coast Wonders. A clue that the GF is wonderful is still useful but still gives the GF some room to survive

 

[The_Reaper]

I HATE restrictions.

It ruins the game.

Being filtered as to what you can and can't say, is a terrible idea.

And since when was revealing the contests of PM always banned? If I was a seer, and I got told you were the Right Hand Man. Well, I'm going to reveal that content. Same as the clue.

Nah.

But asking what the instructions are is pretty cheap.

Like how am I possibly meant to know it was hooked. I mean I get the logic now but if I don't know, escort seems just as valid.

Easiest way to get rid of it would just be to eliminate order commands though.

Should just have to mention a name in bold in the PM

 

[Footypie32]

I HATE restrictions.

It ruins the game.

Being filtered as to what you can and can't say, is a terrible idea.

And since when was revealing the contests of PM always banned? If I was a seer, and I got told you were the Right Hand Man. Well, I'm going to reveal that content. Same as the clue.

A game is just a series of restrictions. Any game. The game should be about detective work and convincing people to trust you and mistrust others. Not just everyone revealing their PMs until evil is uncovered.

 

[Footypie32]

Clues should never lead to one specific poster. They should help narrow things down a little. But not reveal someones exact role.

 

[SM]

A clue every even day is good I think. You'll only get 3 max I would think, you don't have one Night 1, and you make them reasonably difficult. Quiv got killed because of a clue in mine, but they didn't understand the clue relating to Noobz which then implicated several.

Solution as well is just not have so many bloody roles.

 

[ClarkeM]

Ecstatic I was the only one killed. Village heavily outweighing evil, bringing each team down 1 peg today will see a better chance at victory for us.

 

[The_Reaper]

One issue that these werewolf games have compared to Town of Salem is the time.

Day phase lasts for like 10 hours.

The holes in your defence can easily be pointed out in that time.

 

[TheFreshBanana]

Can we please add Jester to games?

Have same criteria. If they get killed, they can lynch anyone who voted for them.

Although, not sure what the incentive might be for someone who would want to get killed early... so yeah might not work. Would be hilarious though.

However, executioner is the perfect role. Let's not go through the bullshit of the Jobe having either true or false information.

Having the Seer, Jobe and Executioner would be ****ing hilarious, and would give evil the extra boost.

 

[BigJoeD_]

New roles and characters are fine - but the clues have to go, it is ruining the game IMO

 

[TheFreshBanana]

Maybe I'll mod a game, I want to try my hand at clues and see if I get em alright

 

[TheFreshBanana]

but i hate modding games....

 

[The_Reaper]

Can we please add Jester to games?

Have same criteria. If they get killed, they can lynch anyone who voted for them.

Although, not sure what the incentive might be for someone who would want to get killed early... so yeah might not work. Would be hilarious though.

However, executioner is the perfect role. Let's not go through the bullshit of the Jobe having either true or false information.

Having the Seer, Jobe and Executioner would be ******* hilarious, and would give evil the extra boost.

I want arsonist.

Greatest role

 

[The_Reaper]

I'm running the next game after ClarkeM

 

[Footypie32]

but i hate modding games....

No you don't!

 

[Noobz0r]

Yeah I'm not a fan of clues.

 

[SM]

I want arsonist.

Greatest role

What's that?

 

[timtamWB]

I hate these bloody clues.

 

[BigJoeD_]

I hate these bloody clues.

There's just no need for them - the idea is to pick evil based on posting, not wait to be spoon fed by the mod

 

[TheFreshBanana]

I hate these bloody clues.

I still don't get how you got found out.

 

[timtamWB]

I still don't get how you got found out.

Neither do I. Somebody investigated me and then got sent a clue pretty much saying I was in the bar.

 

[sante]

Someone should host a game based on Town of Salem

 

[Millky95]

ClarkeM feel free to post the new game

 

[The_Reaper]

Someone should host a game based on Town of Salem

That's basically what the game I am modding after ClarkeM will be.

 

[ClarkeM]

ClarkeM feel free to post the new game

No worries, no rush

 

[sante]

That's basically what the game I am modding after ClarkeM will be.

We're doing it on Richmond board, well about to