What would you rather?

[Kipz]

Hypothetical...

Option 1: Cousins to Collingwood, Didak gone.
Option 2: Cousins at St Kilda, Didak stays.
Option 3: Both at Collingwood, but your car and all your money has been stolen (never to return), if you are still in school and have a lack of these, you fail this year and have to repeat.

 

[Brahma Bull]

Depends on what we get for Didak with Option 1

 

[Kipz]

Your choice

 

[Brahma Bull]

So we would be allowed anything for Didak?

Then definitely Option 1

 

[Bloben]

Option 3....

I have lots of insurance but little cash

 

[Kipz]

So we would be allowed anything for Didak?

Then definitely Option 1

Something reasonable, not a straight swap for Lance Franklin or anything.

 

[DidaksLeftFoot]

Option 2.

Are we really going to win a premiership in the next two years?

That's about how long Cousins has, and I for one think we are three or four years away.

Rusling, O'Brien, Harry, Pendles, Thomas, Reid, Dawes, Wood, Brown, McCarthy, Dick, Goldsack, Shaw, Cloke... their best is still ahead of them.

Didak will be entering his late twenties at that time, as will Davis, Fraser, Medhurst... that's when we should be challenging.

I'm excited though for the journey.

 

[Brahma Bull]

Something reasonable, not a straight swap for Lance Franklin or anything.

Well you got my hopes up

 

[GreekLunatic]

Option 3. I think we do need Cuz due to we have lost alot of experience.

 

[Kipz]

Option 3. I think we do need Cuz due to we have lost alot of experience.

Okay, PM me your bank account details etc.

 

[Optimax]

Hypothetical...

Option 1: Cousins to Collingwood, Didak gone.
Option 2: Cousins at St Kilda, Didak stays.
Option 3: Both at Collingwood, but your car and all your money has been stolen (never to return), if you are still in school and have a lack of these, you fail this year and have to repeat.

How about all optiosn are mutually exclusive events.

Cousins coming doesnt mean we lose didak (although id hazard a guess and say it means we'll keep him)

Cousins at st,kilda while fathomble doesnt mean we'll keep didak if we refuse cousins it means we are in real rebuild mode and we want draft picks so we'll probably trade him. Or it could mean we are unlucky or smart and keep didak and dont take the risk on cousins.

Option 3 well none of that has anything to with each other and given the odds of that last part of option three id spend more money of saying the sun wont rise tomorrow than that occuring.

Most likely occurence is didak stays cousins chooses us and i keep my car and money as does everybody else.


Finally stupid thread

 

[targett]

How about all optiosn are mutually exclusive events.

Cousins coming doesnt mean we lose didak (although id hazard a guess and say it means we'll keep him)

Cousins at st,kilda while fathomble doesnt mean we'll keep didak if we refuse cousins it means we are in real rebuild mode and we want draft picks so we'll probably trade him. Or it could mean we are unlucky or smart and keep didak and dont take the risk on cousins.

Option 3 well none of that has anything to with each other and given the odds of that last part of option three id spend more money of saying the sun wont rise tomorrow than that occuring.

Most likely occurence is didak stays cousins chooses us and i keep my car and money as does everybody else.


Finally stupid thread

didak to stay would of been all australian and winner of copeland easily !!!!!! so didak and cousins together in our midfield next year...... this will happen.

 

[Kipz]

How about all optiosn are mutually exclusive events.

Cousins coming doesnt mean we lose didak (although id hazard a guess and say it means we'll keep him)

Cousins at st,kilda while fathomble doesnt mean we'll keep didak if we refuse cousins it means we are in real rebuild mode and we want draft picks so we'll probably trade him. Or it could mean we are unlucky or smart and keep didak and dont take the risk on cousins.

Option 3 well none of that has anything to with each other and given the odds of that last part of option three id spend more money of saying the sun wont rise tomorrow than that occuring.

Most likely occurence is didak stays cousins chooses us and i keep my car and money as does everybody else.


Finally stupid thread

I'm guessing you missed the 'hypothetical' part, go have a look, it was the first word on the OP.

 

[Brahma Bull]

Ok I believe Didak is staying and Port will never give up pick 4 so with those caveats in place which is the better deal for Didak hypothetically

1: Boak and pick 22

2: Knights and pick 10

3: Rosa and pick 18

4: Crowley and pick 21

5: Rischitelli and pick 25

6: O'Keefe and pick 30

7: Farren Ray and pick 32

Boak and pick 22 would be the best, but Port will never trade Boak. I have recently learnt how high they rate him.

 

[Snag Breac]

Option 4 = Didak stays, Cousins arrives and together they lead Collingwood to a premiership. Posters continue to flourish, financially and in every other way, because our star is on the rise.

 

[Kipz]

Option 4 = Didak stays, Cousins arrives and together they lead Collingwood to a premiership. Posters continue to flourish, financially and in every other way, because our star is on the rise.

A fairytale wasn't an option

 

[HugeRack]

Ok I believe Didak is staying and Port will never give up pick 4 so with those caveats in place which is the better deal for Didak hypothetically

1: Boak and pick 22

2: Knights and pick 10

3: Rosa and pick 18

4: Crowley and pick 21

5: Rischitelli and pick 25

6: O'Keefe and pick 30

7: Farren Ray and pick 14

8: Dal Santo and pick 47

 

[MagpieGirl_13]

Option 4 = Didak stays, Cousins arrives and together they lead Collingwood to a premiership. Posters continue to flourish, financially and in every other way, because our star is on the rise.

^ I like this option....

 

[Pie eyed]

Hypothetical...

Option 1: Cousins to Collingwood, Didak gone.
Option 2: Cousins at St Kilda, Didak stays.
Option 3: Both at Collingwood, but your car and all your money has been stolen (never to return), if you are still in school and have a lack of these, you fail this year and have to repeat.

How about;
Option 1: Cousins to Collingwood, Didak stays.
Option 2: Cousins and Kerr to Collingwood, Didak stays and all three tie for the Norm Smith.
Option 3: Collingwood gets first pick of the best 15 players to be traded and the first 10 picks in both drafts, Didak stays and Nathan Buckley makes a come back. Collingwood, with an outstanding list and only allowed to keep 44 splits into "shirts" and "skins". They play of in the Grand Final and draw, even after 4 periods of time on, the same thing happens in the next weeks rematch. The AFL finally gives in and awards two Premiership Cups and Flags. Carlton and Essendon fans riot and both clubs are kicked out of the AFL and relagated to the VFL, where Collingwood VFL side makes them our bitches.


I vote Option 3. but then I'm a hopeless optimist.

 

[Pendles!]

How about;
Option 1: Cousins to Collingwood, Didak stays.
Option 2: Cousins and Kerr to Collingwood, Didak stays and all three tie for the Norm Smith.
Option 3: Collingwood gets first pick of the best 15 players to be traded and the first 10 picks in both drafts, Didak stays and Nathan Buckley makes a come back. Collingwood, with an outstanding list and only allowed to keep 44 splits into "shirts" and "skins". They play of in the Grand Final and draw, even after 4 periods of time on, the same thing happens in the next weeks rematch. The AFL finally gives in and awards two Premiership Cups and Flags. Carlton and Essendon fans riot and both clubs are kicked out of the AFL and relagated to the VFL, where Collingwood VFL side makes them our bitches.


I vote Option 3. but then I'm a hopeless optimist.

Greatest thing ive ever read