Which 1 would u take

[barmyarmy]

Which player would u take here

 

[barmyarmy]

Which player would u take here

for me it would have to be the little jet murph but kruze could well over take if the knee stands up

 

[BrownPearHookers]

Murphy by a very long way, He is a star, the other 2 I dont think ever will be.
maybe if Gibbs had Kreuzer's heart, then he would be up there.

 

[Jonno_]

For Collingwood, I would take Kruezer. We need a long term ruck option, and I rate him very highly.

For Carlton, if I had to keep only one, it would be Murphy, for obvious reasons. Granted Kreuzer hasn't had as long to impact, and has had injuries, but to date Murphy has them easily covered.

That said, Gibbs is the most talented footballer... but also likely to impact the game the least due to his willingness to hang 20 metres behind a pack, and receive the second handball for the penetrating kick forward.

It seems a pointless role to play, especially when you already have Scotland who does exactly that.