Which two?

[GibbsMurphJudd]

Which two would you prefer?

 

[charcoalchicken]

Cotchin and Martin

 

[GordonBlue]

Which two would you prefer?

Did you ever think the poll was gonna go any other way?

You do know "runs on board" mean jack shit when you have "potential", "hype" and "less hatred for that club" involved...

The fact that Cotchin was been rated better than Selwood and Rioli some two years ago tells you how clueless people on here are...

 

[the distributer]

Murphy and Gibbs for me, in fact, i dont think id swap murphy by himself for both tiger boys.

 

[Dazb86]

Martin and Delidio.

 

[daniel2323]

Murphy and Gibbs for me, in fact, i dont think id swap murphy by himself for both tiger boys.

Not argueing, but may i ask why?

I'd take Martin and Cotchin, not on what they've achieved but on how good they were this year.

 

[jsd09]

When gibbs and Murphy win a hard ball is when ill vote for them.

 

[the distributer]

Not argueing, but may i ask why?

I'd take Martin and Cotchin, not on what they've achieved but on how good they were this year.

both carlton boys have shown much much more to date, i dont really rate cotchin eiter.

 

[The Bomb]

in order I would have
Martin without a shadow of doubt, He is going to be a very special player for the Tigers, will become a star very quickly.

Murphy
Gibbs
Cotchin who I think is so over rated.

 

[TownleyTime]

If there is 1 player in the AFL that I could get at Collingwood, it would be Dustin Martin. I hate to think how good he will be in his mid 20's & at a side in the Top 4.

 

[Sin City]

Murphy and Gibbs.

 

[Silvagnis]

When gibbs and Murphy win a hard ball is when ill vote for them.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-ziV30TizxQ

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yDBD9J-vVOs

Do we have a deal?

Murphy and Gibbs.

Only if they were playing for Richmond.

Gibbs has one of the best pair of hands I've seen at Carlton.

Terrific overhead mark and punishing kick.

http://www.gameanalyser.afl.com.au/...Type=contestedMark&seek=158&videoQuality=high

http://www.gameanalyser.afl.com.au/...ype=contestedMark&seek=5849&videoQuality=high

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lu--O9W4L5M

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hc2FVoLbshs

 

[Bazzar]

Now I know why they call this the silly season. Gibbs, Murphy….lol.

 

[Joshen]

Murphy and Gibbs for me. North need speedy outside players.

 

[Bazzar]

Cotch & Murph

[YOUTUBE]G-Cye6RGYbM[/YOUTUBE]

 

[The Bomb]

Ashame Dangerfield and Vince are not in this, they would be better then both groups.

 

[TigerTime88]

in order I would have
Martin without a shadow of doubt, He is going to be a very special player for the Tigers, will become a star very quickly.

Murphy
Gibbs
Cotchin who I think is so over rated.

There is certainly a lot of hype around Cotchin. I think that is mainly to do with what he has shown over his first few years without being able to complete a pre season. Has had a big year this year and should show what he is about.

Personally I think he will be a better player than Martin.

 

[The Bomb]

There is certainly a lot of hype around Cotchin. I think that is mainly to do with what he has shown over his first few years without being able to complete a pre season. Has had a big year this year and should show what he is about.

Personally I think he will be a better player than Martin.

You could be right, I think Cotchin has been rated extremly high for what he has done to date, I still think he will be a wonderful player, and has the potential to become a absolute gem. I hear so much good stuff about him, I just want to see more of it, more often.
Dustin Martin is a absolute ripper, He could very well be a brownlow medalist in the making, I think he is as good a midfielder as you can get, top shelf stuff. Richmond are a very lucky club to have Cotchin and Martin.
Richmond fans wont care who is going to be better I would say, because you have both.

Murphy and Gibbs just cop so much flack from opposition supporters, because they play for Carlton, due to this I think they are hard done by, make 1 wrong move and they are put on you tube. anyway,
I think they are and will continue to be wonderful players for their club.
I think they will get greater respect from opposition supporters when they get more clearances and 1st Possessions.

toughness is where Richmond get the upper hand by quiet a margin.

 

[Sin City]

I think they will get greater respect from opposition supporters when they get more clearances and 1st Possessions.

More important for the club that these two receive more of the ball while Judd, McLean, Kreuzer etc worry about the clearances.

 

[The Bomb]

More important for the club that these two receive more of the ball while Judd, McLean, Kreuzer etc worry about the clearances.

No, Not at all, If Murphy and Gibbs get alot more 1st pos and clearances, they will cut out the oppositions amount of clearances, which in turn will allow more ball to free up for the likes of Judd, Yarren, Carazzo ect
@ Essendon we have had this problem for a while, only in 2010 did I see someone who will gets his hands dirty so to speak, with Watson, and that being Howlett.

I think Murphy and Gibbs have to improve this part of there game for Carlton to really take control of the midfield against better teams, I think Curnow will be a fantastic addition for carlton in this area.

 

[Sin City]

No, Not at all, If Murphy and Gibbs get alot more 1st pos and clearances, they will cut out the oppositions amount of clearances, which in turn will allow more ball to free up for the likes of Judd, Yarren, Carazzo ect
@ Essendon we have had this problem for a while, only in 2010 did I see someone who will gets his hands dirty so to speak, with Watson, and that being Howlett.

I think Murphy and Gibbs have to improve this part of there game for Carlton to really take control of the midfield against better teams, I think Curnow will be a fantastic addition for carlton in this area.

As I said that will be the domain of Judd, McLean, Kreuzer etc while Murphy and Gibbs will be more outside, creative players.

You're right, if Curnow steps up to AFL level he will be a very handy addition.

Why the hell would we want Carrazzo to be playing an outside role instead of Murphy or Gibbs?