Who for for Shaw

[catsdynasty]

I'm guessing a lot of people are in the same boat as me having to get rid of Shaw and are going to have to use a trade for some (me ) have to use it now. Right now I'm tossing between Craig Bolton or Andrew McLeod probably will go with McLeod but not sure.

Thoughts????? And what will others do

 

[caza27]

S.Fisher or Mackie for me

 

[James23]

mcleod to star in his 300th

 

[TheBurningReD]

Bowden or Fisher for me

 

[OO74812]

S.Fisher or Mackie for me

Haha not bad.

I can't get either of them so for me it is McLeod or Guerra.

I would have thought Guerra in other people's choices???

 

[bobmurphy2]

guerra for me

 

[Athomas]

Probably Mackie... but seeing as I have no trades....

N Brown off the bench for his magical 20-40

 

[William C]

A.Welsh for me atm ..

still not convinced about guerra's consistency

 

[footyfan_25]

Haha not bad.

I can't get either of them so for me it is McLeod or Guerra.

I would have thought Guerra in other people's choices???

guerra for me

What role has Guerra been playing?

I recall he was used as a tagger a couple of weeks ago?

 

[NewBabyBombaz]

Andrew Welsh for me, he isn't really that much more expensive than Shaw yet in my opinion is grossly undervalued, the Welsh stocks are about to boom. Early on in the season his position was unclear, he struggled everywhere he was placed, however over about the last 5 weeks he has excelled in a tagging role (3 hundreds in past 4 weeks, the one week he didnt get 100 he got injured). Plays a lot of time in the midfield and reads Hille's ruckwork very well, IMO he is the best bet as a replacement for Shaw if you are looking at a sideways trade, other options are Birchall or maybe as a roughie B.Lake, both have capacity to score well, if you have the trades to upgrade then Mackie Fisher or J-Bo.

 

[SkankDanker]

Andrew Welsh for me, he isn't really that much more expensive than Shaw yet in my opinion is grossly undervalued, the Welsh stocks are about to boom. Early on in the season his position was unclear, he struggled everywhere he was placed, however over about the last 5 weeks he has excelled in a tagging role (3 hundreds in past 4 weeks, the one week he didnt get 100 he got injured). Plays a lot of time in the midfield and reads Hille's ruckwork very well, IMO he is the best bet as a replacement for Shaw if you are looking at a sideways trade, other options are Birchall or maybe as a roughie B.Lake, both have capacity to score well, if you have the trades to upgrade then Mackie Fisher or J-Bo.

Great call. Nice post.

 

[Saint KFC]

Guerra, Welsh or Drummond for me.

 

[Waite_30]

A. Welsh for me too. Thank god he got that 8.

 

[aaronm46]

im thinking about tradiing shaw for dalziell and then trading didak for riewoldt, sound good?

 

[Cruiser23]

im thinking about tradiing shaw for dalziell and then trading didak for riewoldt, sound good?

That's R.Shaw isn't it?

 

[catsdynasty]

im thinking about tradiing shaw for dalziell and then trading didak for riewoldt, sound good?

Do you mean Rhyce Shaw??? If so then probabbly yes because Dalziell isnt a backman

 

[kingyubbo]

If I got Guerra, that would make 3 Hawks defenders! Can't have that. Will probably go with Welsh for his amazing price.

Dalziell is mid, so he's obviously talking R Shaw.

Don't dis N Brown! He's the only back i've had bar Birchall that has played every game this year!

 

[The Dice Man]

Whoever the hell I want. Got 11 trades left(lmao) and finished my league on top with only a single loss... but shouldve traded Shaw 8 weeks ago really.

Might just pick Danny Jacobs to make it interesting.

 

[Ferg720]

I'll probably just go welsh.

 

[seanmorr]

Whoever the hell I want. Got 11 trades left(lmao) and finished my league on top with only a single loss... but shouldve traded Shaw 8 weeks ago really.

Might just pick Danny Jacobs to make it interesting.

you must be a pretty crap DTer if you have 11 trades left this time of the season

 

[The Dice Man]

you must be a pretty crap DTer if you have 11 trades left this time of the season

Or it could mean Ive got very lucky re injuries. In the top 10%. I just dont spend all week fussing over my DT like a sad little fanboy.

 

[Cruiser23]

Or it could mean Ive got very lucky re injuries. In the top 10%. I just dont spend all week fussing over my DT like a sad little fanboy.

11 trades with 4 rounds left? Geez, can I have the three trades you aren't going to use?

 

[FandangoDingo]

Or it could mean Ive got very lucky re injuries. In the top 10%. I just dont spend all week fussing over my DT like a sad little fanboy.

Do you use dice??

 

[SkankDanker]

Whoever the hell I want. Got 11 trades left(lmao) and finished my league on top with only a single loss... but shouldve traded Shaw 8 weeks ago really.

Might just pick Danny Jacobs to make it interesting.

Chad Cornes is well priced too.

 

[Tippaz]

unfortunately, for that price

Guerra or McLeod

my only affordable options, but who