Who goes first :)

[Truetiger]

A post by myself and madtiger this one :S lol


If Kane Johnson was at the top of a staircase who would like the first chance to push him down the bottom and out of Tigerland Can we please show Kane the door as well as possible 10 others.

 

[Wally Matera]

Johnson wouldnt be the first, but he's not far off it.

Ray Hall (anyone begs to differ on this is deluded)
Kent Kingsley (only works if we're winning)
Andrew Krakeour (had his chance)
Darren Gasper (obvious reasons)
Kelvin Moore (rubbish)
Daniel Jackson (rubbish)
Trent Knobel (wasting everyone's time)
Patrick Bowden (lazy and soft)

These are my delistings... wouldnt get a copy of The Big Issue for any of them.

 

[Madtiger2006]

Johnson wouldnt be the first, but he's not far off it.

Ray Hall (anyone begs to differ on this is deluded)
Kent Kingsley (only works if we're winning)
Andrew Krakeour (had his chance)
Darren Gasper (obvious reasons)
Kelvin Moore (rubbish)
Daniel Jackson (rubbish)
Trent Knobel (wasting everyone's time)
Patrick Bowden (lazy and soft)

These are my delistings... wouldnt get a copy of The Big Issue for any of them.

wally matera (rubbish)

 

[reliable source]

wally matera (rubbish)

well said

 

[jarr]

u really are a d***head!!!​

 

[Madtiger2006]

Johnson wouldnt be the first, but he's not far off it.

Ray Hall (anyone begs to differ on this is deluded)-agree
Kent Kingsley (only works if we're winning)-agree
Andrew Krakeour (had his chance)-agree
Darren Gasper (obvious reasons)-gone
Kelvin Moore (rubbish)-showed signs(maybe keep)
Daniel Jackson (rubbish)-been obvious he has talent for 3 years(keep)
Trent Knobel (wasting everyone's time)-may have no choice but to keep
Patrick Bowden (lazy and soft)-good for depth, give one more season maybe

These are my delistings... wouldnt get a copy of The Big Issue for any of them.

I'd delist Johnson on top of Hall, Kingsley and Krakouer. With Gaspar gone that will be 4 spaces freed up on the list because Cogs will be off the long term injury list. Terry will have to make up his mind on Tivva, P Bowden, Knobel and Moore while he has to work out whether King, Edwards and Howat stay on the senior list or back to the rookie list. Tivva, P Bowden and Knobel may go if we want to pick up more than 6 new players

 

[Madtiger2006]

wally matera u really are a d***head!!!​

spot on

 

[jezza]

A post by myself and madtiger this one :S lol

It doesn't surprise me that it took the two of you together to actually be able to construct a sentence.

 

[kendo]

It doesn't surprise me that it took the two of you together to actually be able to construct a sentence.

classic!!!

 

[Wally Matera]

So l'm a d ickhead because l dont rate Jackson and you're a fcuking legend because you want to keep Patrick Bowden for depth when he cant get a game in seniors whilst we're sitting last on the ladder with not a win in 10 games and have an injury list that consists of:

- Simmonds
- Brown
- Coughlan

we have 2 rookies (King and Edwards) who are being picked ahead of him and two blokes, Newman and Thursfield, who are coming back from car crash injuries and would not be 100% fit being picked ahead of him.

And finally... finally...

Gasper has already been told to fcuk off.

Yep... that's right keep Patrick Bowden you ****wit... good depth player. ****!!!

 

[polakthetiger]

you want to keep Patrick Bowden for depth when he cant get a game in seniors whilst we're sitting last on the ladder with not a win in 10 games and have an injury list that consists of:

- Simmonds
- Brown
- Coughlan

Bowden is injured himself, isn't he?

 

[Wally Matera]

Bowden is injured himself, isn't he?

Only after he was dropped for shit form

 

[PLSC]

wally is spot on with his list

if moore cant break into this side then he's ****ed but id maybe give jackson 1 more year even though i still dont rate him

 

[polakthetiger]

Not saying he will be a 'keep' at the end of the season....but a little tough to fight your way back into the side when you are out injured.

And, although not dominating the 3 games he played, 15, 15 and 12 possies and a goal showed more in this 'last on the ladder' team than a few others and likely if had not gotten injured would have come back soon IMO.

But he will get game time in the 2nd half and we will see if he wants to play in 08.

 

[NQTIGER]

Not saying he will be a 'keep' at the end of the season....but a little tough to fight your way back into the side when you are out injured.

And, although not dominating the 3 games he played, 15, 15 and 12 possies and a goal showed more in this 'last on the ladder' team than a few others and likely if had not gotten injured would have come back soon IMO.

But he will get game time in the 2nd half and we will see if he wants to play in 08.

Who are u talking about? jackson or bowden?

 

[Madtiger2006]

Only after he was dropped for shit form

interrupted preseason, played one game underdone, was dropped then got injured. Can't really do much about that knob head. His form last year was enough to consider giving him another year. I also said Gas was gone as you mentioned. Good luck rating the team from your idiot box in London DlCKHEAD

 

[HBK619]

Johnson wouldnt be the first, but he's not far off it.

Ray Hall (anyone begs to differ on this is deluded)
Kent Kingsley (only works if we're winning)
Andrew Krakeour (had his chance)
Darren Gasper (obvious reasons)
Kelvin Moore (rubbish)
Daniel Jackson (rubbish)
Trent Knobel (wasting everyone's time)
Patrick Bowden (lazy and soft)

These are my delistings... wouldnt get a copy of The Big Issue for any of them.

So you haven't seen Jacko's last two games?

3 goals in the first match, then 15 disposals and a goal in the second while keeping Simon Black(Averaging more than 25 disposals per game) to 16 ineffectual disposals.

 

[polakthetiger]

Who are u talking about? jackson or bowden?

Yeah, a post slipped in between. Bowden.

 

[_RT_]

I'd delist Johnson on top of Hall, Kingsley and Krakouer. With Gaspar gone that will be 4 spaces freed up on the list because Cogs will be off the long term injury list. Terry will have to make up his mind on Tivva, P Bowden, Knobel and Moore while he has to work out whether King, Edwards and Howat stay on the senior list or back to the rookie list. Tivva, P Bowden and Knobel may go if we want to pick up more than 6 new players

Edwards is a senior listed player already so we don't have to decide whether we keep him or not. Wally's list is about spot on if we really want to make some head way into cleaning out the rest of the garbage that has managed to hang on through Wallace's first 3 years. Johnson wont go but I get the feeling he may 'step down' as Captain (read sacked) and be replaced by a younger player next year. Tivendale will again be shopped but wont attract much and will be given another year or 2 at Richmond before finally getting the flick. Depending on whether we can pick up a ready made ruckman during the off season I fear that Knobel may also get a reprieve and be kept on one more year. Apart from that not many on that list have done much to suggest they are worth keeping at present.

 

[Wally Matera]

So you haven't seen Jacko's last two games?

3 goals in the first match, then 15 disposals and a goal in the second while keeping Simon Black(Averaging more than 25 disposals per game) to 16 ineffectual disposals.

I just think he's a mediocre player. My thoughts only and forgive me, l thought that's what the thread asked for?

There are plenty of other mediocre players that havent been mentioned. We're last on the ladder, we have no trade value and we need to turn over probably 8 blokes, considering we have 3 picks inside the first 18 selections, plus one in the PSD and maybe the upgrade of one or both of Howat and King to the senior list.

There's my 8. What's wrong with putting my thoughts forward? Jackson to me is surplus for where we need to get to.

At least l provide support for my opinions, not like others who just make random bullshit up and have no basis for their decision making. Would prefer to sling shit.

Apologies HBK, l know you didnt ask for that mate .

 

[Wally Matera]

Edwards is a senior listed player already so we don't have to decide whether we keep him or not. Wally's list is about spot on if we really want to make some head way into cleaning out the rest of the garbage that has managed to hang on through Wallace's first 3 years. Johnson wont go but I get the feeling he may 'step down' as Captain (read sacked) and be replaced by a younger player next year. Tivendale will again be shopped but wont attract much and will be given another year or 2 at Richmond before finally getting the flick. Depending on whether we can pick up a ready made ruckman during the off season I fear that Knobel may also get a reprieve and be kept on one more year. Apart from that not many on that list have done much to suggest they are worth keeping at present.

Thank you...

 

[Truetiger]

It doesn't surprise me that it took the two of you together to actually be able to construct a sentence.

Whats the problem its not like we have done anything wrong. I agree with one comment though johnson goes before hall.