Whose had a better Carear?

[trueblue_91]

Michael Voss and James Hird 2 superstars of the AFL. Which one has had a better career?

Voss Brownlow Meddalist, 3 premierships

Hird Brownlow Meddalist 1 premiership i think (was he there in 1993)?

can't remember any other details so can someone add how many years captain and any norm smiths thanx

 

[WhyAlwaysMe]

Car Ear

+

 

[trueblue_91]

Woops! lol wasn't concentrating but would like oppinions on the question not my spelling mistakes please

 

[Dazman]

Vossy's had the better career simply because hes got more premierships.

However I believe Hird is the better player.

Get your head around that logic if you will

 

[judburyjets]

Hird Brownlow Meddalist 1 premiership i think (was he there in 1993)?

can't remember any other details so can someone add how many years captain and any norm smiths thanx

was he ever!!! He starred in the '93 p'ship... Norm Smith in 2000 p'ship, I don't believe Voss has ever won a norm smith. Both absolute stars, there is no use trying to split them, but people will.

 

[jnash196]

James Hird 236 Games 335 Goals
Player honours: Brownlow Medal 1996; best and fairest 1994, 1995, 1996, 2003 (equal); 2nd best and fairest 2000; Norm Smith Medal 2000; All-Australian 1995, 1996, 2000, 2001 (captain), 2003; International Rules Series 2000 (captain), 2004 (captain); Jim Stynes Medal 2000; leading goalkicker 1995, 1996; AFL Rising Star nominee 1993; premiership sides 1993, 2000; pre-season premiership sides 1993, 1994, 2000; captain 1998-2005.

 

[westdog54]

Both are absolute champions, I compared it on another post to separating Bec Twigley from Goodes' GF, inseparable

 

[Barnsey3150]

Both legends of the game..what a pitty that both their careers are almost over

 

[jnash196]

Isn't it amazing that if either polled one more vote in '96 the other would have never won a brownlow

 

[Belly]

Isn't it amazing that if either polled one more vote in '96 the other would have never won a brownlow

And If Corey wasn't suspended, AND polled one more vote, neither of them would have won a brownlow.

 

[Melbourne Lion]

As far as I know they all have fairly impressive ears on their cars it's really hard to seperate if your talking purely car ears.

But I will go out on a limb and say I prefer Voss's.
But I am biased

 

[Picador]

Vossy's had the better career simply because hes got more premierships.

However I believe Hird is the better player.

Get your head around that logic if you will

This logic makes sense..

I agree.

 

[Upgrayedd]

Voss' car's ear is better then hirds car's ear

 

[col44]

Car Ear

+

thanks for the laugh............ ah I needed that ta!