Why are Port more hated than the Crows?

[Kane McGoodwin]

Every club has idiot fans.

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/crows-member-fined-and-banned-for-racially-vilifying-geelong-player/news-story/a46df94a2f27f02921981451dd87b49f

Only one club (not just in SA, but in the league) has a player who has made racist remarks on the field running around for them though. A player who they praise as a hero. That's the Crows and the Crows alone. Congratulations on that.

What a pathetic attempt at deflection this is.

Suggest you read the OP again as this is on topic!

Port supporters have a reputation of having a higher proportion of feral behaviour, including racism & booing their own players & coaches.

Sometimes you have tried to blame it on Cats supporters...

Punch thrown as tensions boil over in ugly scene during AFL final

A frightening altercation in the crowd was only broken up when one man was restrained by a number of others.

7news.com.au

Video emerges of brawl inside Adelaide Oval between fans late during Port Adelaide’s loss to Geelong

Video emerges of fan brawl inside Adelaide Oval

www.foxsports.com.au

Geelong coach Chris Scott explains incident with Port Adelaide fan during Adelaide Oval clash | Sporting News Australia

Geelong coach Chris Scott has explained his brief exchange with a Port Adelaide fan at three-quarter time of the Cats’ 21-point victory at the Adelaide Oval on Thursday night.

www.sportingnews.com

 

[JimmyBC]

Suggest you read the OP again as this is on topic!

Port supporters have a reputation of having a higher proportion of feral behaviour, including racism & booing their own players & coaches.

Sometimes you have tried to blame it on Cats supporters...

Punch thrown as tensions boil over in ugly scene during AFL final

A frightening altercation in the crowd was only broken up when one man was restrained by a number of others.

7news.com.au

Video emerges of brawl inside Adelaide Oval between fans late during Port Adelaide’s loss to Geelong

Video emerges of fan brawl inside Adelaide Oval

www.foxsports.com.au

Geelong coach Chris Scott explains incident with Port Adelaide fan during Adelaide Oval clash | Sporting News Australia

Geelong coach Chris Scott has explained his brief exchange with a Port Adelaide fan at three-quarter time of the Cats’ 21-point victory at the Adelaide Oval on Thursday night.

www.sportingnews.com

Pretty sure I'd get three crows crowd incidents if I googled champ, there's d1ckheads in every large gathering & your sh1t stinks as much as anyone else.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Pretty sure I'd get three crows crowd incidents if I googled champ, there's d1ckheads in every large gathering & your sh1t stinks as much as anyone else.

No where near the number of unsavoury incidents that Port supporters have been involved in!

Go & find 3 incidents against the 1 opposition club...

 

[greatwhiteshark]

Because Port are the most successful football club at tier 1 level in the history of the sport.

 

[JimmyBC]

No where near the number of unsavoury incidents that Port supporters have been involved in!

Go & find 3 incidents against the 1 opposition club...

Well post them all & give me a yearly breakdown of all crowd incidents across the league.

I've never understood this 'We are the high moral arbiters of upstanding behaviour' crap you lot drone on with it's bizarre, you all have roots at the former SANFL clubs you once supported & you booed, spat & swore as much as anyone else. The only time I've ever genuinely felt fear at a football match was at Elizabeth ffs.

 

[Schulzenfest]

Suggest you read the OP again as this is on topic!

Port supporters have a reputation of having a higher proportion of feral behaviour, including racism & booing their own players & coaches.

Sometimes you have tried to blame it on Cats supporters...

Punch thrown as tensions boil over in ugly scene during AFL final

A frightening altercation in the crowd was only broken up when one man was restrained by a number of others.

7news.com.au

Video emerges of brawl inside Adelaide Oval between fans late during Port Adelaide’s loss to Geelong

Video emerges of fan brawl inside Adelaide Oval

www.foxsports.com.au

Geelong coach Chris Scott explains incident with Port Adelaide fan during Adelaide Oval clash | Sporting News Australia

Geelong coach Chris Scott has explained his brief exchange with a Port Adelaide fan at three-quarter time of the Cats’ 21-point victory at the Adelaide Oval on Thursday night.

www.sportingnews.com

Post as many fan incidents as you like, there's still no comparison between some fans being dickheads and a Crows player being a known racist.

 

[Duckimus Prime]

Port supporters have a far worse record when it comes to crowd behaviour, including towards your own coach this year!

See the thing is, this is just factually incorrect. The Adelaide Crows have a far worse record for attendees being ejected from Adelaide Oval.

There are also far more racial vilification incidents after Crows games, than the two very highly publicised ones from Port fans. Its almost like clockwork the the Adelaide Football Club has to come out and condemn racism after an Adelaide Oval game where an inidigenous opponent plays well.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

See the thing is, this is just factually incorrect. The Adelaide Crows have a far worse record for attendees being ejected from Adelaide Oval.

There are also far more racial vilification incidents after Crows games, than the two very highly publicised ones from Port fans. Its almost like clockwork the the Adelaide Football Club has to come out and condemn racism after an Adelaide Oval game where an inidigenous opponent plays well.

Can you post the link on ejections as didn't believe they were readily available.

 

[Macca180]

That's a fact, Port supporters are way more feral than Crows. But Port supporters are more passionate and make more noise. Can't have your cake and eat it too.

There is an element of nanna and librarian about Camry supporters.

Just the way it is.

 

[ElectricG]

Post as many fan incidents as you like, there's still no comparison between some fans being dickheads and a Crows player being a known racist.

Lol I was gonna say they save their racism for on the field.

But even that aside, there is basically zero chance that Port fans are on average more racist than crows fans given the difference in age demographic.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Lol I was gonna say they save their racism for on the field.

But even that aside, there is basically zero chance that Port fans are on average more racist than crows fans given the difference in age demographic.

Reported incidents would suggest otherwise.

Anyone who has attended Port & Crows games knows the Port supporters get angrier, even booing their own coach.

Nothing to do with age demographic as racism has nothing to do with age!

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

See the thing is, this is just factually incorrect. The Adelaide Crows have a far worse record for attendees being ejected from Adelaide Oval.

There are also far more racial vilification incidents after Crows games, than the two very highly publicised ones from Port fans. Its almost like clockwork the the Adelaide Football Club has to come out and condemn racism after an Adelaide Oval game where an inidigenous opponent plays well.

Still waiting on that link proving I'm factually incorrect.

It's almost like you just made it up!

Must be a conspiracy where Port incidents are reported more than Crows ones...

 

[ElectricG]

Reported incidents would suggest otherwise.

Anyone who has attended Port & Crows games knows the Port supporters get angrier, even booing their own coach.

Nothing to do with age demographic as racism has nothing to do with age!

"Even booing their own coach." why do you think this is such an indicator of us being uncouth/unruly? Because your mob would instead go whining to 5AA if you were in the same situation?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

"Even booing their own coach." why do you think this is such an indicator of us being uncouth/unruly? Because your mob would instead go whining to 5AA if you were in the same situation?

There have been so many unsavoury incidents towards your own coach, opposition coaches (like Scott) & towards players.

All clubs have shit supporters, but Port have a far higher proportion compared to the Crows

The number of incidents speak for itself.

 

[ElectricG]

There have been so many unsavoury incidents towards your own coach, opposition coaches (like Scott) & towards players.

All clubs have shit supporters, but Port have a far higher proportion compared to the Crows

The number of incidents speak for itself.

I really just don't think it's true. How can you sidestep the significance of one of your players racially abusing an aboriginal player, and remaining a cult favourite among your supporters.

That aside, the Advertiser Sport (which I assume is colouring your judgement) does a good job at controlling the narrative. Take the last showdown for instance. One of your fan punches our mascot in the face and one of your players lashes out at a fan. Yet all of the dialogue is about the alleged booing off of Rankine (which didn't even happen).

I think on every metric, crows supporters would be worse people.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

I really just don't think it's true. How can you sidestep the significance of one of your players racially abusing an aboriginal player, and remaining a cult favourite among your supporters.

That aside, the Advertiser Sport (which I assume is colouring your judgement) does a good job at controlling the narrative. Take the last showdown for instance. One of your fan punches our mascot in the face and one of your players lashes out at a fan. Yet all of the dialogue is about the alleged booing off of Rankine (which didn't even happen).

I think on every metric, crows supporters would be worse people.

Feel free to post a poll as to what opposition supporters think.

It's not even close.

https://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl/teams/port-adelaide/video-captured-of-port-adelaide-fan-assault-at-saturday-nights-football-match/news-story/772a25d1da1425a898dfe2aeddd1cdf3

Banana-throwing football fan fined by police over Betts incident

A 27-year-old woman is fined $543 and issued with a police barring order after she threw a banana in the direction of Eddie Betts at Adelaide Oval.

www.abc.net.au

Statement: Saturday night incident

Port Adelaide has released a statement clarifying its position in regard to an incident in Adelaide on Saturday night.

www.portadelaidefc.com.au

'Blight on the game': Uproar over 'terrible' act while Izak Rankine was leaving field

Izak Rankine was taken from the ground on a medicab after the heavy hit. Read more here.

au.sports.yahoo.com

https://www.adelaidenow.com.au/news/south-australia/port-fans-head-to-adelaide-oval-in-droves-to-battle-the-cats/news-story/be3c06ff539be22c8400bfa81279c999

 

[ElectricG]

Feel free to post a poll as to what opposition supporters think.

It's not even close.

Well the "most hated club" poll and thread already exists and it is 62-40 your way so it's at least ballpark. That said:
1. The poll is from 2021-now and it's easier to NOT hate a shit club like Adelaide.
2. I have already explained that perception is not always reality.

 

[Duckimus Prime]

There have been so many unsavoury incidents towards your own coach, opposition coaches (like Scott) & towards players.

Chris Scott bumped into a guy who had his back turned to him...

'Blight on the game': Uproar over 'terrible' act while Izak Rankine was leaving field

Izak Rankine was taken from the ground on a medicab after the heavy hit. Read more here.

au.sports.yahoo.com

Imagine having to bring up Crows fans who were booing when they realised that play was restarting with JHF taking a kick from his mark.

 

[terrybull]

Port have had much more success than Sunshine. Crows just a memory now…

 

[randyzany]

This thread has devolved into Port and Crow supporters bickering between themselves about which of their fanbase is more feral. I thought that the point of this thread was supporters of other clubs to chime in about their views on these 2 clubs, not the views of fans of the clubs being discussed.

 

[GC2015]

The hate from Crows fans obviously makes sense and I can understand Collingwood fans not liking the whole jumper situation, but I'm surprised to see teams like West Coast, Geelong and Richmond having over 20% hatred for Port. 55% hatred towards Port for North makes zero sense to me. I'm sure there are individual matches/incidents that explain each of those percentage but it does seem odd to me. I have heard some footy followers say Port are just generally perceived as a bit arrogant.

AFL Rivalries - Who your team loves to hate

Which teams love to hate each other? Learn more about the recent popular Twitter poll from @thebackpocketau

www.thebackpocketau.com

Interesting to see Port above the Crows when it comes to being hated by opposition fans.

Side note. Funny to see the two Queensland teams are the least hated in the league according to that survey. I get the Suns because they would probably be seen as irrelevant in a lot of people's eyes, but Brisbane... who went on to win the premiership and had been a top 4 teams for several years before 2024. That's surprising.

Port have had much more success than Sunshine. Crows just a memory now…

Port have played finals 14 times in 28 AFL seasons (50%) and the Crows have played finals 15 times in 34 AFL seasons (44%).

 

[terrybull]

The hate from Crows fans obviously makes sense and I can understand Collingwood fans not liking the whole jumper situation, but I'm surprised to see teams like West Coast, Geelong and Richmond having over 20% hatred for Port. 55% hatred towards Port for North makes zero sense to me. I'm sure there are individual matches/incidents that explain each of those percentage but it does seem odd to me. I have heard some footy followers say Port are just generally perceived as a bit arrogant.


Side note. Funny to see the two Queensland teams are the least hated in the league according to that survey. I get the Suns because they would probably be seen as irrelevant in a lot of people's eyes, but Brisbane... who went on to win the premiership and had been a top 4 teams for several years before 2024. That's surprising.


Port have played finals 14 times in 28 AFL seasons (50%) and the Crows have played finals 15 times in 34 AFL seasons (44%).

The Crows have only played division 2 Finals in their 30 years in the VFA, while Port’s 138 years and counting in the VFA/VFL have played so many finals series that I don’t have enough hands in my family to count…

 

[manureid]

If you think Hinkley cops it from Port supporters, should maybe see what some former Crows coaches think of the fair old Adelaide crowd. Robert Shaw, Gary Ayres to name 2.

 

[Taper]

As a SA born and bred follower of a VIC team I don’t actually like either of the SA teams but I do respect Port more than the Crows which may seem strange as a lifelong Norwood man with family links to the club for generations but I do know plenty of other Norwood supporters who feel the same.

Crows are widely respected by Victorians while Port are laughed at for having tarps on their seats and losing a grand final by 119 points.
Similar to the WA teams with West Coast being widely respected by Victorians while Fremantle are seen as a joke.

However,
West Coast are more hated than Fremantle while Port are more hated than the Crows, hence why I asked the question in this thread.

 

[greatwhiteshark]

Crows are widely respected by Victorians while Port are laughed at for having tarps on their seats and losing a grand final by 119 points.
Similar to the WA teams with West Coast being widely respected by Victorians while Fremantle are seen as a joke.

However,
West Coast are more hated than Fremantle while Port are more hated than the Crows, hence why I asked the question in this thread.

Nah Victorians don't like Port because they are the most succesfull tier 1 football club in the history of the sport and Vics can't handle that the top 3 are from outside of the Vic heartland. Nothing more to it than that.