Why Walker!!!!

[Magpies2005]

i cant believe that he is back in the side!!!! he struggles even for williamstown how can they justify picking him? unless there going to finally delist him at the end of the year but why please someone help me out here???

WALKER HALF BACK FLANK????????? and cloke on the bench hmm what a joke this is now what do the rest of the die hard members think?

the rest of the changes i agree with but i wouldnt have put walker in for hall his a dud.
His worse then mathew Lokan my god why???????????

im wrapped that we get to see H.Shaw in the side see what his worth and what he can do after bludging on the list for nearly 2 seasons but yes i want to see harry o'brien in the collingwood side soon i think hopefully late change for the side walker out o'brien in.

 

[Jabso]

Yeah ok, whatever. What do you mean by bludging.

 

[dogga16]

i cant believe that he is back in the side!!!! he struggles even for williamstown how can they justify picking him? unless there going to finally delist him at the end of the year but why please someone help me out here???

WALKER HALF BACK FLANK????????? and cloke on the bench hmm what a joke this is now what do the rest of the die hard members think?

the rest of the changes i agree with but i wouldnt have put walker in for hall his a dud.

I wouldn't be surprised if Walker's in to match up on Koszitchke, set him a big task to see if he's worth persevering with. More likely scenario to be back-up ruckman however for Fanning.

Been quite disappointing this year. He signed a 2yr deal last year, so he ain't gonna be delisted (included in the salary cap) unless he's traded !

 

[magpies42]

we are down talls, its an obvious selection!

 

[Magpies2005]

we are down talls, its an obvious selection!

if thats the case wouldnt u play Hall for a second game instead? we know what walker can do (not much) we have jason cloke there on the bench i would rather him in the backline then walker.

Yeah ok, whatever. What do you mean by bludging

Well there were huge wraps on him and he has under achieve he has not played a game for the 1's as yet maybe bludging is the wrong word to use.
I have seen williamstown nearly every week i can unless im at a collingwood game and i have done that for years now and its only been mostly this year his started to step up alittle bit. as i said earliar im wrapped to see him in the side i hope he really does cement his spot and start playing like his brother was playing like b4 he got injured. I also think that his cousin might be in a little strife aswell if he cant make it in the collingwood side and show his true talent.

 

[bradrowe#32]

Who knows?

Walker hasn't had the best of form, but you kind of think MM is looking towards next year by naming him, J.Cloke and Woey. Maybe he wants to see if they can still contribute and be a part of Collingwood 2006.

The season is over, so we have nothing to lose.

 

[The Majestic]

Give him a go, he couldn't be any worse then some.

 

[derro]

walker getting his last chance before delist time

 

[MarkT]

Walker was the obvious in. Would you rather Hall stayed or Bill Morrison was selected? We have a ruckman who at least at this stage is no good and no backup and we have 4 of our 5 first (and only) choice tall forwards injured and the remaining one is either physically or mentally shot. Surely Walker has to play. Whether he has much upside now is debatable and I'd be happy to trade him this coming trade week but realistically he is the only viable option.

 

[Murray]

Walker or Hall

Hard decision I know, but at least one of them can get more than 3 kicks (just)

 

[eddiesmith]

I would rather give Billy a go or Hall a 2nd game than bring in the Saints bitch Walker

Last year after the game v the Saints at the dome people around me were calling for him to be delisted, nothings changed.

If he plays back on Kosi then I suggest avoiding the main board for the next few days as Saints supporters say how great Kosi is with his 20 touches, 15 marks and 10 goals

 

[Magpies2005]

I wouldn't be surprised if Walker's in to match up on Koszitchke, set him a big task to see if he's worth persevering with. More likely scenario to be back-up ruckman however for Fanning

told u he is so useless show him the door now he goes in plays crap when he gets it turns it over then goes off with a injury he is the worse player on out list

 

[FIGJAM]

...as Saints supporters say how great Kosi is with his 20 touches, 15 marks and 10 goals

Your tarot cards don't work to bad!

 

[sealer]

Hard decisions have to be made - davis woey lonie c.morrison obree WALKER ... and this is just the start - davis played ok last night but can he give us a full game consistently - you have to play the kids from now on - brayden shaw must play before the end of the year -