Wiggins or hodge

[Neville Bartos]

Wiggins is older than Hodge, so he's got my vote

 

[floki]

Mark my words Wiggins has the skill , poise and decision making of a mexican drug lord , pencil it in Wiggins , football demigod and future AFL commissioner , the boy will go far.

 

[hodge2wiggins]

Disgrace, not even real poll

 

[matty_hawk]

i think some people are failing to see the humor in some posts, and are taking things a bit too serious

 

[Deb_Girl]

Thanks ben

 

[Chodders]

Look Hodge is a very serviceable player but you seriously couldn't go past the Chief if you had to start a team afresh. The first player picked everytime.

Judd would be a distant second.

 

[gaz15]

i think some people are failing to see the humor in some posts, and are taking things a bit too serious

Thats what bay 13 is for!

 

[King Elvis]

At State Level, Hodge, but outside of that, Wiggins has him covered.

As good as he is domestically, unfortunately, Hodge just doesn't seem to have the technique or temperate to translate his domestic dominance into International dominance.

Having his Mum whinge for him doesn't help either.

 

[crackers57]

Thats what bay 13 is for!

Pffffft! When was the last time anything humourous was posted in Bay 13?

 

[RoosterLad]

Pffffft! When was the last time anything humourous was posted in Bay 13?

shut up u flog

 

[jonoman89]

careers so far
Hodge
Debut: AFL 2002
Recruited from: Colac/Geelong U18
AFL Awards:Norm Smith Medal 2008; All-Australian 2005, 2008; International Rules Series 2005; NAB AFL Rising Star nominee 2002; premiership side 2008
Club Awards: best and fairest 2005; 2nd best and fairest 2006; 3rd best and fairest 2007, 2008
Brownlow Votes 46
wiggins
Debut: Rd 5 2001
Recruited from: Tas U18
AFL Awards:
Club Awards:
Brownlow Votes:
got them off club websites not sure if carltons has been updated but i would say hodge has had a better career so far

Stats are incorrect. You should amend them to this:

Wiggins brownlow votes in 2008: 2
Wiggins nickname: THE CHIEF

Hodge brownlow votes in 2008: 2
Hodge nickname: N/A

Wiggins is clearly superior in statistical analysis.

 

[Desmodromico]

It has got to be Wiggins. Afterall he has won ...........

Has he ever won anything? A raffle maybe? Nope?

Ah well, at least he has a hot wife

 

[LondonCalling]

I think Carlton should bottle his sperm

Well ahead of you.

And FWIW, Wiggins would be the first picked by me in any team.

 

[Bingle_21]

Statistics can be used to prove anything. 94% of people know that

Great minds think alike Deb. Great quote from the great man H. Simpson

“Oh, people can come up with statistics to prove anything, Kent. 14% of people know that.”

 

[kreuze_missile]

I think this poll is an accuate reflection of where both players are at. Its only round 1 and the Wiggler's already won mark of the year and is in good shape to do the Brownlow Coleman Norm Smith trifecta. Go Wiggler!!!

 

[cooper6]

Some of these polls are absolutely ridiculous.

I don't know why people think it's funny to rubbish champions and hold spuds up in such high regard.

Here we have two players that are clearly not even in the same league.

One an absolute gun. The personification of courage and skill, he is revered by AFL fans throughout the country.

The other an honest trier. He gives his best but he just doesn't really cut the mustard against the big boys of the competition. Outside his own club, supporters think of him as a kind of joke.

Wiggins by the length of the Flemington straight.

great post. wiggins is truly revolutionising football. loving the intelligence of some disgruntled posters!

 

[pickman]

Hodge is a hack that got lucky on GF day last year, Wiggins on the other hand is the greatest player our great game has ever known.

THe AFL has the Hall of fame and the legends status but once his career is finished, the AFL will instigate "deity" status and it's first & only inductee will be one S.Wiggins (Carlton)

 

[KnaveyBlue]

Ridiculous to even put these two players in the same poll.

Insult to Wiggins.

 

[gandaal]

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_compare?tid1=4&pid1=415&tid2=11&pid2=469

Says it all. Wiggins is the man

 

[Rack Watts]

Just traded Motlop for Wiggins because I am the least gullible person on BF.
Oh well, at least Wiggins is a fellow Glenorchy bogan.

 

[Weiterbot23]

Ridiculous to even put these two players in the same poll.

Insult to Wiggins.

Hang on, I was pretty sure Wiggins would comfortably win but, Hodge is a decent player and if he improves his fitness and ball finding skills he may be moved from his soft loose man position and get a chance in the middle.

 

[XXX KINGS]

It is official:

[YOUTUBE]2ySzPYZw8MU[/YOUTUBE]

 

[anubis]

I think we can all finally agree the little known trade when Carlton offered up Wiggins and Plunkett for Hodge in 2003 was a huge mistake that has now bitten the hawks on the ass.With those two guys in the hawks team would be no brainers for back to back flags maybe even three or four in a row.

Hahaha i love laughing at the stupid hawks.How could you not have seen the superstar that they were trying to give you.

 

[mess]

Hahaha, I just voted to see the score, 60 to 40!!
Proof most people aren't even paying the thread the respect of opening it...

 

[Deb_Girl]

IMO the poll represents where each player is at right now. If hodge can show the same heart and dedication as wiggins has throughout his fantastic career he may become one of the elite also. Still has a long way to catch up to THE CHIEF though!