Wingers - Round 1

["The Roar Is Back"]

You are picking 2 players. Houli and Morton ended up on the same votes for the remaining spot as a forward , have added Morton, due to having already played at club.

Team so far.
Backs - Newman McGuanne Moore
Half Back - Lids Astbury Connors
Centre- Cotchin
Half Forward - Morton Griffiths Taylor
Forward -Post Riewoldt King

Ruck -
R/Rover - Martin
Rover - Foley

Interchange - Jackson Grigg Tuck

 

[middy]

Went for Edwards and Conca as I believe that is Edwards best spot where he can do the most damage. As for Conca I feel it will allow him more time to use the sublime skills of his. Can already see him hitting Jack lace out on the chest.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Went for Edwards and Conca as I believe that is Edwards best spot where he can do the most damage. As for Conca I feel it will allow him more time to use the sublime skills of his. Can already see him hitting Jack lace out on the chest.

Hey middy you appear to have voted for Houli and Edwards, you drinking ?

 

[Danog]

Houli and Batchelor

 

[Bazzar]

I want to vote Grigg. Silly he isnt included as an option. Keep interchange till last.

 

[sante]

Houli and Edwards.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

I want to vote Grigg. Silly he isnt included as an option. Keep interchange till last.

He was voted as a rotating mid within first poll ?

 

[El Tigre]

Getting harder....
Had trouble deciding between Edwards, Conca, Houli and Batchelor

Edwards didn't do himself any favors on Sat night, but i think he plays a game that needs team mates to know his playing style, which is unique. Will perform better thru the year.
Conca because he's cool and got good skills.
Bad luck to Houli, will have his chance tho.
Batchelor should be in the HB line in place of Connors.

 

[TigerTime88]

Where the hell is Morton? He is my first choice.

Morton and Houli or Edwards.

 

[santa claws]

none of the above. for me grigg and newman are the wings they should also be part of rotations.
sean grigg is a big old fashioned marking wingman.if people think hes anything else they are kidding themselves.

newman the skipper have always wanted him played in the midfield with so many hb types on the list and the need for us to see if farmer can hold down a spot i reckon its time to make the move. to me morton and conca are two who we should rotate of the wings.

of those on the list.
edwards - yep he needs a position where he can run all day unfortunately hes not as good as those i mentioned.i struggle to place him in the 22.

conca - hopefully he is played on the wing or across hb.but a dearth of quality small forwards could see him thrown forward.
batchelor - hb is his position but hes got a lot of competition. could get some development games on a wing though.
nason - see edwards.
white - there just is no spot for such a deficient player.
houli - an onballer will wrongly be played forward.could play wing certainly has the delivery skills.would like to see him and foley rotating on ball.
webberley - if anything a hb. has neat skills his size and lack of any redeeming feature means depth player. could play wing but again in front of who.
rance - you have to be kidding not with his delivery and decision making.
hicks - just to small atm hes a crumbing goal sneak fror the moment he should be played as such.
contin - hes an inside player why would you give him an outside role.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

In the OP it has a list of players already selected within spots that reflect previous poll results , given they're already selected within the side I'd suggest it common sense that they no longer an option in further polls ?

 

[El Tigre]

Where's Riewoldt? I reckon Riewoldt should be given as an option on the wing. Why didn't they list Riewoldt? I WANT TO CHOSE RIEWOLDT!

 

[Bazzar]

I want to vote Grigg. Silly he isnt included as an option. Keep interchange till last.

Where the hell is Morton? He is my first choice.

Morton and Houli or Edwards.

none of the above. for me grigg and newman are the wings they should also be part of rotations.

Good concept, but poorly thought out. For mine Grigg and Edwards/Morton are the two suited and will probably start on the wings.

My smokey, would be Rance. Wouldnt mind seeing him in a trial match on the wing.

 

[santa claws]

Good concept, but poorly thought out. For mine Grigg and Edwards/Morton are the two suited and will probably start on the wings.

My smokey, would be Rance. Wouldnt mind seeing him in a trial match on the wing.

do you want to elaborate what is poorly thought out and why.

 

[Bazzar]

do you want to elaborate what is poorly thought out and why.

Because a few want players in a certain spots and cannot because they already have a place. I want Grigg on a wing just like you do. amcre wants Morton but carnt. So whilst being a great thread and lots of appreciated work gone into it, i dont see it as the definitive team thread, thats all

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Because a few want players in a certain spots and cannot because they already have a place. I want Grigg on a wing just like you do. amcre wants Morton but carnt. So whilst being a great thread and lots of appreciated work gone into it, i dont see it as the definitive team thread, thats all

Hey Bazzar it was explained within the first poll of how it was going to work , majority rules .
I'd dare say that if the majority wanted Morton , and / or Grigg, upon a wing then they wouldn't have voted for them to be elsewhere and they would now be still available ?

 

[Blackhawk03]

Went Houli and Conca for 2 reasons. Sat night's game, there seemed to be an obsession with switching and bringing the ball back into the corridor. For mine Conca and Houli have much better disposal than Edwards (who I'd like to see in the sub position as an impact player) so it makes sense to have them on the outside bringing it in or delivering directly into the 50.

 

[bigstyletiger]

It's a bit strange picking the interchange before the starting 18?

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

** In this poll , you are picking centre, r/rover and rover , and 3 players that will change off the bench ( for purpose of the exercise ) into those positions ***
Round 1 side with all considered available.
Will start a new poll each week :
In this order
Onballers - 6
3 starting and 3 on bench ( aware its not the norm, but will be for this exercise )
Backs - 6
Forwards - 6
Wingman - 2
Ruckman - 1
Sub - 1

Will update as based on most popular and as side comes together will post in opening post of next poll .
Will attempt to add all those likely to play in these spots, if someone is missing in poll, please contact mods.

The backs and forwards were split into to groups of 3 , to try to avoid a huge in balance of smalls or shorts

 

[Marcel Proust]

Apparently ward can play wing and seems to have the tools.

Andrew could be plonked on a wing and hope he is Adam Goode's if he has some tank.

Johnson not sure but sounds a fun option?

Rachelle not sure would be great option forward.

Big year for Pickett. Macca.

Caddy?

Ralphsmith looks interesting prospect ditto Dow.

Wing might be weakest area?

 

[tugga]

This thread is 10 years old.