Wirrapunda Trade

[alstar562]

Melbourne fans would agree you need pace in the midfield and thats what wirra would bring to your club and much more. Rumors are he wants to return to Melbourne to be close to his sick Mother, so considering all this how about this trade:

CARLTON GET : Wirrapunda and haynes OR a 2nd or 3rd round draft pick

WESTCOAST GET: pick no.3

What to you think?

 

[Deestroy]

Originally posted by alstar562
Melbourne fans would agree you need pace in the midfield and thats what wirra would bring to your club and much more. Rumors are he wants to return to Melbourne to be close to his sick Mother, so considering all this how about this trade:

CARLTON GET : Wirrapunda and haynes OR a 2nd or 3rd round draft pick

WESTCOAST GET: pick no.3

What to you think?

And what do Melbourne get out of this trade? I assume you mean we get Wirra and Haynes rather than Carlton.

There is no way Wirrpunda is worth pick 3, not even close.

 

[BT]

Re: Re: Wirrapunda Trade

Originally posted by Deestroy
And what do Melbourne get out of this trade? I assume you mean we get Wirra and Haynes rather than Carlton.

Either you are right or alstar562 thinks he's on the Blues board?

Wirrapunda is not worth pick #5 let alone #3!

 

[alstar562]

Re: Re: Re: Wirrapunda Trade

Originally posted by BT
Either you are right or alstar562 thinks he's on the Blues board?

Wirrapunda is not worth pick #5 let alone #3!

I was in hurry so I just copied and pasted the same thing . Also wirrapunda is not worth pick #5 or #3 he is worth pick #1
and if this is not the case what do you reckon hes worth?

 

[Broadbridge_20]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Wirrapunda Trade

Originally posted by alstar562
I was in hurry so I just copied and pasted the same thing . Also wirrapunda is not worth pick #5 or #3 he is worth pick #1
and if this is not the case what do you reckon hes worth?

I wouldve given you Woewodin for him last year before we traded him to Collingwood.

In terms of draft picks you'd be lucky to get a pick higher than 10.

 

[BT]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Wirrapunda Trade

Originally posted by Broadbridge_20
I wouldve given you Woewodin for him last year before we traded him to Collingwood.

In terms of draft picks you'd be lucky to get a pick higher than 10.

So yeah Melbourne's best offer would be pick 20 & a player.

 

[alstar562]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Wirrapunda Trade

Originally posted by BT
So yeah Melbourne's best offer would be pick 20 & a player.

We will keep him then

 

[BT]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Wirrapunda Trade

Originally posted by alstar562
We will keep him then

You won't but, we won't get him either!