Werewolf Work it out Werewolf

[Nothing]

Why not: JOAT.

That means I think Gralin is night immune.

Because there isn't one

 

[Shueygod]

What are you talking about?

None of the 3 that have claimed to have the ability to stop you getting a successful target on the second night after achieving one on the first targeted you or Gralin.

JOAT doesn’t exist.

 

[cats_09]

Why not: JOAT.

That means I think Gralin is night immune.

Because there's no JOAT...

Crimson Azure

Thanks Cadsky - looks like we've got someone with a killing role here who's trying to think of excuses on the run

 

[ZergMinion]

Why not: JOAT.

That means I think Gralin is night immune.

I'm travelling today so bear with me.

Did you target Jhye night 1 and Gralin night 2, get a success night 1 with no info and a failure night 2?

 

[Shueygod]

We should still vote ClarkeM so we work out how to approach tonight, but yeah Crimson can go tomorrow for sure.

 

[ZergMinion]

Because there's no JOAT...

Crimson Azure

Thanks Cadsky - looks like we've got someone with a killing role here who's trying to think of excuses on the run

CA mighr be the new favourite for Arsonist.

 

[Crimson Azure]

Because there's no JOAT...

Crimson Azure

Thanks Cadsky - looks like we've got someone with a killing role here who's trying to think of excuses on the run

Ok, looking forward to you being wrong.

 

[ClarkeM]

There’s probably an obvious answer that I haven’t sussed, but what did ClarkeM mean by this:



Originally 2 successful actions, what does “my action” (note singular) mean?

It means that both of my actions were successful so far in this game.

 

[Crimson Azure]

Cadsky was there at some point a Jack of all trades in the roles? I swear I saw it there when I looked at the roles before the game started.

 

[ZergMinion]

Cadsky was there at some point a Jack of all trades in the roles? I swear I saw it there when I looked at the roles before the game started.

It was there before the game started as a possible role. Roles were then trimmed to roles in game only.

 

[Crimson Azure]

I'm travelling today so bear with me.

Did you target Jhye night 1 and Gralin night 2, get a success night 1 with no info and a failure night 2?

Yes, night one saw jhye as a flog.

Night my action was unsuccessful.

 

[cats_09]

Ok, looking forward to you being wrong.

You said you targeted Jhye Clark on night 1 - did you get a successful or unsuccessful response from the boss?

Last night you targeted Gralin but got an unsuccessful message

You've then said you've worked out your role based on that - are you happy to share what role you think you have?

 

[Nothing]

Cadsky was there at some point a Jack of all trades in the roles? I swear I saw it there when I looked at the roles before the game started.

There was. IT was reduced down to the actual roles at the start.

 

[ZergMinion]

It would be sweet if there was a role that got incorrectly trimmed though.

 

[Nothing]

Yes, night one saw jhye as a flog.

Night my action was unsuccessful.

Ok. So 2/3 chance at night immune

 

[cats_09]

So Crimson is claiming a seer role - could be the village seer, or could also be the Alpha or Godfather

Anyone else curious to take a look?

 

[MC Bad Genius]

I know, I didn’t exactly want to let everyone know I’m the doc did I.

How were you so certain that you were the doctor though?

I didn’t read the arsonist role properly until you mentioned this.

That’s a weird arsonist - basically the same as SK?

I missed the "even day" stipulation, so it's kind of a mix between a SK and a Poisoner, where there is a delay for some of their kills. It'd be interesting to confirm from Cadsky a couple of things:

1. If someone is doused on Night X and are lynched or killed Night Y (before the even day), will they show up as doused?
2. If someone is doused on Night X and then the Arsonist is lynched or killed Night Y (before the even day), will the doused player still ignite?

An answer to the first question might give us some extra info to work with. But an answer to the second is just to satisfy my curiosity, really.

What about MC Bad Genius and ZergMinion ? Have you had successful/unsuccessful actions?

Two unsuccessful actions now, which means I'm a Villager, a luckless Arsonist (or maybe not, depending on the answer to my question above) or one of the 2ICs.

Night 1 - myblueroan and MC Bad Genius
Night 2 - shueygod and MC Bad Genius (although I did suggest in my PM that the second target is redundant)

Those are my chosen heads!

How am I a head?

So given i was succesful on porps I cant be Arsonist. Mayor died. I literally have no other roles to claim

This could be helped by an answer to my question to Cadsky above.

If this is the case ClarkeM would be the vote today,Headless can’t kill anyone tonight.

Aahhh, my second question above could potentially change your thinking there. It depends if the doused players still ignite if the Arsonist dies.

You could all be telling the truth. Clarke as Mafiosa or Beta would get successful results without getting any obvious result. Without a faction, those roles don't have a place or a direct action so technically he has a role, but they aren't actionable as such.

I think others have covered this, but I'd say they get an unsuccessful result like Villagers do.

Perhaps we start at MCBG then

Cadsky

But you're discounting the joy of lynching MCBG

What have I ever done to you?

All vibes baby.

I've hardly posted to give any vibes at all haha!

 

[Nothing]

So Crimson is claiming a seer role - could be the village seer, or could also be the Alpha or Godfather

Anyone else curious to take a look?

67% is pretty good. Unfortunately, it will only result in Beta/Mafioso taking over. Perhaps as a multi with ?

 

[MC Bad Genius]

It was there before the game started as a possible role. Roles were then trimmed to roles in game only.

Yeah, I'm guessing he thought it was too chaotic to not have the exact role list in the OP. I personally would've much rathered the extra level of chaos, but I doubt that would come as a surprise to anyone.

 

[The Half Back]

Who needs to be lynched?

For anyone taking notes, my night 0 targets were MCBC and Gralin followed by DP and bouncer last night.

 

[cats_09]

67% is pretty good. Unfortunately, it will only result in Beta/Mafioso taking over. Perhaps as a multi with ?

CA & Clarke?

 

[cats_09]

Have we had any notifications of an evil faction forming?

 

[Nothing]

Have we had any notifications of an evil faction forming?

No.

 

[Crimson Azure]

So Crimson is claiming a seer role - could be the village seer, or could also be the Alpha or Godfather

Anyone else curious to take a look?

But why would I be unsuccessful last night unless I was role blocked if I am in fact a seer.

 

[Proper Gander]

How were you so certain that you were the doctor though?


I missed the "even day" stipulation, so it's kind of a mix between a SK and a Poisoner, where there is a delay for some of their kills. It'd be interesting to confirm from Cadsky a couple of things:

1. If someone is doused on Night X and are lynched or killed Night Y (before the even day), will they show up as doused?
2. If someone is doused on Night X and then the Arsonist is lynched or killed Night Y (before the even day), will the doused player still ignite?

An answer to the first question might give us some extra info to work with. But an answer to the second is just to satisfy my curiosity, really.


Two unsuccessful actions now, which means I'm a Villager, a luckless Arsonist (or maybe not, depending on the answer to my question above) or one of the 2ICs.

Night 1 - myblueroan and MC Bad Genius
Night 2 - shueygod and MC Bad Genius (although I did suggest in my PM that the second target is redundant)


How am I a head?


This could be helped by an answer to my question to Cadsky above.


Aahhh, my second question above could potentially change your thinking there. It depends if the doused players still ignite if the Arsonist dies.


I think others have covered this, but I'd say they get an unsuccessful result like Villagers do.



What have I ever done to you?


I've hardly posted to give any vibes at all haha!

To answer your question “how am I a head” - no reason.

You’re pretty good at this and I tend to the glass half full side of the spectrum. Two boss types both v good tends to mean the village is knackered