Worst afl player you've seen (and why)

[DennisMarshall]

You're wrong on Hotton - was a very reliable 2nd ruck in 2000 and 2001 when we went 30-14.

This. Hotton was a very good player. And anyone who head buts the senior coach on mad Monday deserves props in my book.

 

[Roobs321]

There was a period in the early mid 00s when the Tigers had all these guys running around at the same time getting semi-regular games;

Tivendale (188 games!), Rory Hilton, Ty Zantuck, Aaron Fiora, Mark Chaffey, young David Rodan, Mark Dragicevic (48 games), Biddiscombe (78 games), Ray Hall (99 games).

Not a very inspiring lot. And then their old champions retire, Coughlan gets injured, and they go and draft Richard Tambling.

 

[Bollox]

Torture Chambers..also known as donut king, unco and sarge.
He will always be simply Torture to us though.

 

[Bell Ringer]

This. Hotton was a very good player. And anyone who head buts the senior coach on mad Monday deserves props in my book.

Took a speccy on Allan McAlister at a Pies BnF as well.

 

[Bell Ringer]

Was given #23 as well. Anyhow didn't play anywhere near 50 games.

I only remember his name cos a Hawks mate would rage on Friday mornings if Crawshay was picked in the snrs.

 

[DennisMarshall]

Took a speccy on Allan McAlister at a Pies BnF as well.

Hahahaha rumour was that Hotton got sacked from the pies for turning up to training flat out drunk, and then fell asleep in the team photo later that morning. Owned the Tunnel back in the day.

 

[Stifler's mom]

Trent was a ripping bloke. He and John Hassel were regulars at the tunnel and the Sth Yarra saloon.

 

[cartel]

Caydn Beetham was the worst I've seen from the Saints in recent times. A pick 9 with no skills, no motor and no speed.

Still remember when Tim Watson described him as the next Robert Harvey...



Sent from my D5833 using Tapatalk

 

[sonnywalters]

James Walker is the worst 150 gamer I have ever seen.

Never even heard of him.
What about the Tigers - Greg Tivendale, Mark Chaffey, Shane Tuck, the Kellaway brothers etc

Just horrendous and all played over 150 games.

Edit: Had to google James Walker. I cannot believe he played 150 games. Unbelievable.

 

[BagOfSnags]

Nick Suban absolute shit truck

Where did you pull that from? He's ok

 

[jameses]

Josh Green - Brisbane Lions

 

[BagOfSnags]

It's always been a huge JOSH HILL from me. Improved ten fold.. Still a crab

 

[dickballsack]

Mods, when these worst player threads come about can we make it a rule that after a poster replies and nominates a player they have to include their own playing stats ( senior footy games at any level). Cheers.

 

[Morris Major]

How on earth did Sam Power manage to play 123 games

 

[schnoods]

Never even heard of him.
What about the Tigers - Greg Tivendale, Mark Chaffey, Shane Tuck, the Kellaway brothers etc

Just horrendous and all played over 150 games.

Edit: Had to google James Walker. I cannot believe he played 150 games. Unbelievable.

Tuck had a couple of good years late in his career, was a pretty good clearance player and took alot of heat away from Cotchin the year where he was equal runner up in the Brownlow. Probably remember him for fracturing his shoulder blade during a game and played the rest of the game out only to be ruled out for 8 weeks afterwards. Tough as nails, the Tigers could use a big bodied mid like him.

Can throw a blanket on the rest you named, add Fiora, Bourke, etc.

James Walker, Pedestrian by name and player. If it wasn't for his leg speed he would've been lucky to notch up 20 games.

 

[schnoods]

Ty Zantuck was a fair shit-truck.

No wonder Pickett didn't pick him up.

 

[JD Tomahawk]

Interesting James Walker Fact:

He won the AFL Grand Final Sprint in 2003 and 2004 and was noted as one of the fastest players in the AFL. He is the great-grandson of Collingwood legend Gordon Coventry.

Walker was delisted by Fremantle at the end of the 2007 season and chose to participate in the 2007–08 Clipper Round the World Yacht Race on board the yacht westernaustralia2011.com for the race leg across the Southern Ocean between Durban and Fremantle.

 

[Satan]

glenn molloy?

 

[Scotland]

James Walker, Pedestrian by name and player. If it wasn't for his leg speed he would've been lucky to notch up 20 games.

Walker was pretty handy for a while. Barely missed a game in 5 years then just fell out of favour and was delisted at 28.

I nominate Shane Birss. Always looked out of his depth in his time with the Bulldogs and Saints and even had an out of his depth facial expression to go with it.

Shane Harvey also. Drafted because he was Brent Harvey's brother, then recruited to the Kangaroos because he was Brent Harvey's brother.

 

[Satan]

Walker was pretty handy for a while. Barely missed a game in 5 years then just fell out of favour and was delisted at 28.

I nominate Shane Birss. Always looked out of his depth in his time with the Bulldogs and Saints and even had an out of his depth facial expression to go with it.

Shane Harvey also. Drafted because he was Brent Harvey's brother, then recruited to the Kangaroos because he was Brent Harvey's brother.

Tom flower says hi ( greg healy too)

 

[AlDemonic]

Jack Watts will own this when he hangs up the boots.

Bahahaha you will own the years biggest flog award! Obviously haven't watched many games this year Champ? Anyone from Coll kicked 30 goals rhia year?
The Watts bashing was funny a year ago Spud.. But not relevant anymore and u really need to move on!

 

[Shaneprice97]

Alwyn Davey was as complete spud

 

[MoscowHawk]

Not sure if posted already. Worth a read. A couple of these players might fit this thread:

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...d/news-story/ba514bf48786e05f10a5974f9a97df0f

 

[Adelaide Hawk]

Thread should begin and end with Karmichael Hunt. Absolutely useless.

 

[Richoman Tigers]

Never even heard of him.
What about the Tigers - Greg Tivendale, Mark Chaffey, Shane Tuck, the Kellaway brothers etc

Just horrendous and all played over 150 games.

Edit: Had to google James Walker. I cannot believe he played 150 games. Unbelievable.

Shane tuck doesn't belong in this thread and Andrew Kellaway won an All Australian birth