Worst player to ever play AFL

[Bloods]

Robert Pyman, Craig Nettlebeck, Tony Begovich or Richard Ambrose for me.

 

[McAlmanac]

Brenton Klaebe (Fitzroy)
Robert Briedis (North Melbourne)
Ron Page (South Melbourne)

 

[thunder39]

Adrian Barich, Phil Gilbert, Mark Zanotti.

 

[Stig O'Hara]

Dominic Fotia Carlton
Mick Hosbrough Collingwood 1980
Dale Woodhall
Andy Bennett
Gary Shaw
Ben Doolan and he cost Essendon a squillion
Ryan Oconnor

 

[DonAce]

Andrew Ukovic was a fair spud.

 

[marcuz]

A few from bomberland:

Danny Morgan
Daniel McAlister
Shawn Lewfatt
Russell williams
Robert Stevenson

 

[Adrian Shelton]

Paul Starbuck
Matthew Ahmat

 

[Yianni]

Originally posted by brentoncowell
Simon Minton Conell, this guy was the complete dud.

Are you joking?

He was leading the league's goalkicking at some point and kicked over 200 goals. He can't have been the WORSE PLAYER EVER TO PLAY AFL.

 

[SkARkS_69]

the 5 worst players that i have ever seen are
not in any order.
1: Randall Bone
2: Simon Crawshay
3: Andrew Cavedon
4: Warwick Angus
5: Paul Geister

 

[chicky17]

What about Austin McCrabb??????
he played a handful of games for Geelong and Hawthorn late 80's and early 90's.
He was never going to be any good with that name!

Barry Young?
Martin Leslie?
Phil Narlke? only becasue of his helmet!

 

[tribey]

Originally posted by chicky17
Barry Young?
Martin Leslie?

Both were good at various stages of their careers...

Read the title of the thread again.

 

[Minkus_Swan]

wayne weiderman's (sp?) only service to the crows was to bring back the biff..... it didn't work. Another Robert Shaw masterpiece.

 

[pinkus maximus]

darren bolton brad bootsma jay burton matthew clucas brendon feddema chris groom(traded andrew mcleod to get him) brendon Retzlaf daniel schell dwayne simpson martin whitelaw keren ugle

1. 
   [/list=1]

 

[Oliver Slabovic]

Fatui Ataata

 

[twist]

Originally posted by yikes
Who do you guys reckon.

For me Jason Daniels played a few games for St Kilda about 5 or 6 years ago.

He was so ****e.......I watched him play for Noble Park a few years ago, he couldnt even get a kick there.

 

[Ted]

Originally posted by Minkus_Swan
wayne weiderman's (sp?) only service to the crows was to bring back the biff..... it didn't work. Another Robert Shaw masterpiece.

He lives in NSW, you'd better hope this doesn't get back to him...

 

[Generalissimo]

Daniel Lowther
the "Lost" Cocatoo-Collinses
Sedat Sir

 

[MoffOnTou]

Michael Voss

 

[Cuba]

Frankie Raso was a good average player, remember in the dark days at collingwood a few years ago we couldn't win a game, we in fact had lost around 10 games straight, we came up against geelong at the MCG in wet and windy conditions, in the last quarter, after leading most of the game, we were trailling by a couple of points with only minutes left, when grabbing the ball from under the pack and bouncing to his feet and snapping a great goal over his head was Frankie Raso to take the pies to a great victory.

 

[Thunderstruck]

LOL @ Voss

David Antonowicz
Randall Bone
Tom Gilligan
Linden Stevens
Nick laidlaw
Martin Whitelaw
Daniel Parker
Todd Holmes
Mark Viska
Nick Bruton
Trent Hentchell (i spos he deserves anothert go)
Ben Doolan
Wade Chapman
Chris Macri
Paul Dooley

This list goes on.

 

[tige19]

Simon Crawshay and Greg Dear were shockers!!!

 

[GOALden Hawk]

Greg Dear! The same Greg Dear that was first ruckman in perhaps the greatest side of all time? He was a bloody good player at Hawthorn until he did his knee - not our fault Richmond were silly enough to pick him up.

From Hawthorn:
Simon Crawshay
Glenn Nugent
Matthew Young
Hayden Kilmartin
Kane Fraser
Randall Bone
Paul Sharkey
Tim "The Toolman" Allen
Domenic Berry
Austinn McCrabb
Greg Whittlesea
Michael Johnston
Greg "Mad-Dog" Madigan


Other clubs:
Donald and the other Cockatoo-Collins twin.
James Wild
Luke Godden
Daniel McAlister
Adam Chatfield
Lindsey Smith
Sedat Sir

 

[Fall Out Boy]

Originally posted by GOALden Hawk
From Hawthorn:
Simon Crawshay
Glenn Nugent
Matthew Young
Hayden Kilmartin
Kane Fraser
Randall Bone
Paul Sharkey
Tim "The Toolman" Allen
Domenic Berry
Austinn McCrabb
Greg Whittlesea
Michael Johnston
Greg "Mad-Dog" Madigan

Tim Hargreaves is stiff. Talented, but an ordinary footballer who isn't worthy of carrying Austin McCrabb's jockstrap.

 

[Nikita Blue]

How could Earl Spalding be on this list?

Adam Chatfield still gives me nightmares.

 

[Oliver Slabovic]

you can throw in....

Mario Bortolotto
Ramsey Bogunovich
Bruce Duperozel

actually those three are also right up there with McCrabb as having the weirdest AFL player names