would you be happy

[thanks_juddy]

richmond
get : mckinley , mcmahon , pick 5 , bentick + 36
lose : pick 2 tuck hughes 18 + 19 , tambling

wce
lose : judd morton mckinley spangher 13 36 + rosa
get : pick 2,3,4 + 19 ray

carlton
lose : pick 3 kennedy bentick scotland
get judd + morton + frawley + sylvia 13

melbourne
lose : pick 4 frawley rivers syliva moloney
get : wb 2nd round + Hughes + tambling + scotland + rosa

Bulldogs
lose : pick 5 ray macmahon 2nd round
get : moloney , spangher , kennedy , rivers + 18


please change to what is best
this is suggestion

 

[feelyngood]

melbourne
lose : pick 4 frawley rivers syliva moloney
get : wb 2nd round + Hughes + tambling + scotland + rosa

NO way! mate.

Tambling's no good. Scotland is a decent player but we want young guns. Rosa is an OK player and a 2 round pick

for

Pick 4: could be anything
Frawley: exciting young prospect. hasn't played enough yet to be judged but has all the attributes.
Rivers: Young, Gun key position
Sylvia: Improving every game. One pre season and he's on the way. young
Moloney: same category as Rosa I guess, happy to trade but prob no appeal to other clubs at the moment after tough run with injuries.

We want low picks and young players like everyone else. Unless it's for a gun player why trade away 3 young guys pick 4.

 

[thanks_juddy]

richmond
get : mckinley , mcmahon , bentick fletcher
lose : pick 2 tuck hughes 18 + 19 ,

wce
lose : judd morton mckinley spangher 13 fletcher
get : pick 2,4,5 + 19 ray

carlton
lose : pick 3 kennedy bentick scotland walker
get judd + morton + frawley + sylvia 13

melbourne
lose : pick 4 frawley rivers syliva moloney
get : wb 2nd round + Hughes + pick 3 + walker + scotland

Bulldogs
lose : pick 5 ray macmahon 2nd round
get : moloney , spangher , kennedy , rivers + 18


please change to what is best
this is suggestion

 

[dee-molishon]

looks like u have put alot of thought into this VERY complicated trade idea...............shame it is absolutley s*ithouse

 

[cannons]

No, I don't want to trade away our future

 

[Manginable Claw]

What are you on? Rivers by far best defender when fit, Frawley looks like he could be a gun. How do people come up with this sor of thing, way too much time on their hands.

 

[Marns]

Gotta wonder sometimes...

 

[melbournemartin]

I wouldn't touch that with a 10 foot pole and even then I'd be aprehensive.

You'd honestly have to add in Judd to make that fair from a Melbourne point of view (yes I know that'd **** up the whole trade thing)

Pick 4 is now staying with us most likely.

 

[Bingo]

So you want us to trade away our whole backline???!!!

 

[saj_21]

richmond
get : mckinley , mcmahon , bentick fletcher
lose : pick 2 tuck hughes 18 + 19 ,

wce
lose : judd morton mckinley spangher 13 fletcher
get : pick 2,4,5 + 19 ray

carlton
lose : pick 3 kennedy bentick scotland walker
get judd + morton + frawley + sylvia 13

melbourne
lose : pick 4 frawley rivers syliva moloney
get : wb 2nd round + Hughes + pick 3 + walker + scotland

Bulldogs
lose : pick 5 ray macmahon 2nd round
get : moloney , spangher , kennedy , rivers + 18


please change to what is best
this is suggestion

That is the worst most stupid trade ever, scotland good player but to old
I wud rather have sylvia who is only 21 and on the up, Scotland good player but 28

Walker shown glimpses but Rivers is better wen fully fit

Pick 3 or 4 who cares

Who the **** is hughes???

And 2nd round pick to compensate for the lose of more players

You are an idiot and must be on the same stigs as benny cousins

 

[dee-stroyers]

That is the worst most stupid trade ever, scotland good player but to old
I wud rather have sylvia who is only 21 and on the up, Scotland good player but 28

Walker shown glimpses but Rivers is better wen fully fit

Pick 3 or 4 who cares

Who the **** is hughes???

And 2nd round pick to compensate for the lose of more players

You are an idiot and must be on the same stigs as benny cousins

Hahaha spot on saj 21

 

[Number32]

an unrealistic over the top complicated deal that would never go through, why are we even bothering with this

 

[eliasd82]

thats ridiculous..... can we get some realism in this threads...

 

[Deestroy]

One of the worst made up trades ever. This thread will now be locked so no one else has to put up with it.