Your Best Side...

[Stegelator]

What's your best side with the current list? exclude injuries and all that stuff, If you were Plough and you were in the match comittee deciding the line up, how would it go?
I've had a go at it....
B: Hudghton---------Gehrig----------------Lawrence
HB: Voss------------Koschitzke------------Black
C: Cripps------------Thompson-------------Jones
HF: Hayes-------------Loewe---------------Riewoldt
F: Milne-----------------Hamill----------------Plapp
R: Everitt---------------Harvey---------------Burke
Inter: Beetham, Moyle, Dal Santo, Blake,

Emg: Knobel Callaghan Wulf
Only has one ruckman, but Everitt can take the ruck on his own and if any trouble has Koschitzke and Loewe . Also couldn't fit Peckett in the side.

 

[Savatage]

Originally posted by Stegelator
What's your best side with the current list? exclude injuries and all that stuff, If you were Plough and you were in the match comittee deciding the line up, how would it go?
I've had a go at it....
B: Hudghton---------Gehrig----------------Lawrence
HB: Voss------------Koschitzke------------Black
C: Cripps------------Thompson-------------Jones
HF: Hayes-------------Loewe---------------Riewoldt
F: Milne-----------------Hamill----------------Plapp
R: Everitt---------------Harvey---------------Burke
Inter: Beetham, Moyle, Dal Santo, Blake,

Emg: Knobel Callaghan Wulf
Only has one ruckman, but Everitt can take the ruck on his own and if any trouble has Koschitzke and Loewe . Also couldn't fit Peckett in the side.

Not bad, but how the hell did Plapp get in there? He hasn't played a game this year for a reason!

Wulf & Callaghan would be starters in my side. Capuano would be my emergency instead of Knobel. Beetham wouldn't find a spot in the side or my emergencies. Clarke would be on my interchange. Begley as an emergency. Stevie Baker really deserves a spot on the bench as well.

Tough job though & a fair effort Steg.

Also why would Plough select a St.Kilda side ?

 

[StrengthThroughLoyalty]

Originally posted by Stegelator
What's your best side with the current list? exclude injuries and all that stuff, If you were Plough and you were in the match comittee deciding the line up, how would it go?
I've had a go at it....
B: Hudghton---------Gehrig----------------Lawrence
HB: Voss------------Koschitzke------------Black
C: Cripps------------Thompson-------------Jones
HF: Hayes-------------Loewe---------------Riewoldt
F: Milne-----------------Hamill----------------Plapp
R: Everitt---------------Harvey---------------Burke
Inter: Beetham, Moyle, Dal Santo, Blake,

Emg: Knobel Callaghan Wulf
Only has one ruckman, but Everitt can take the ruck on his own and if any trouble has Koschitzke and Loewe . Also couldn't fit Peckett in the side.

if i was plough i'd sack brian taylor as kicking coach and get stewie loewe down to the club to teach chris grant how to get over the kicking yips.

good effort steggie, my side would be:

plapp out.
voss out.
blake out.
beetham out.

callahan, clarke, baker and peckett in.

B: hudghton---------gehrig----------------lawrence
HB: jones------------koschitzke------------black
C: cripps------------thompson-------------clarke
HF: hayes-------------loewe---------------riewoldt
F: milne-----------------hamill----------------dal santo
R: everitt---------------harvey---------------moyle

Inter: callahan, burke, peckett, baker (all in midfield rotation)

Emg: knobel beetham wulf maguire

wouldn't it be nice if we could actually get a full side out onto the field. 2nd 1/2 of the year will be better than the first if we have a better run with injuries.

 

[Falchoon]

Best Team
B Lawrence Hudghton Cripps
Hb Black Gehrig Capuano
C Jones Hayes Riewoldt
HF KoschitztkeHamill Moyle
F Milne Loewe Burke
R Everitt Harvey Thompson
I Callaghan Ball Dal Santo Baker

E Clarke Peckett Schwarze Voss

Everitt takes centre bounces and then goes forward
with Capuano doing the around the ground following
Riewoldt to third tall back and Moyle to wing.

Those that missed

Beetham- ---struggling needs full games with Springy
Begley--------doesn't hold tackles, always a step behind
Blake----------Great determination, needs work on peripheral vision
Clarke---------huge talent with the ball, needs more work without it
Davis----------good backup, needs forward pocket role
Houlihan------young, to develop
Knobel--------Third string ruckman,needs to learn to kick
Maguire-------needs developing. Looks the goods
Montagna-----more Springy time required, not yet ready
Oliver-----------Needs bulk
Peckett-------Slot straight in to running half back role
Plapp----------I thought he did well last year, surprised he hasn't played yet
Schwarze----Most improved player this year, back up tall
Voss----------1st choice emergency, in form at present
Wulf-----------Athletic 188cm, good mark, handy replacement

 

[samm]

Originally posted by Stegelator
What's your best side with the current list? exclude injuries and all that stuff, If you were Plough and you were in the match comittee deciding the line up, how would it go?
I've had a go at it....
B: Hudghton---------Gehrig----------------Lawrence
HB: Voss------------Koschitzke------------Black
C: Cripps------------Thompson-------------Jones
HF: Hayes-------------Loewe---------------Riewoldt
F: Milne-----------------Hamill----------------Plapp
R: Everitt---------------Harvey---------------Burke
Inter: Beetham, Moyle, Dal Santo, Blake,

Emg: Knobel Callaghan Wulf
Only has one ruckman, but Everitt can take the ruck on his own and if any trouble has Koschitzke and Loewe . Also couldn't fit Peckett in the side.

what about Clarke?? he just won the rising star nomination this week

 

[Stegelator]

Re: Re: Your Best Side...

Originally posted by Savatage


Not bad, but how the hell did Plapp get in there? He hasn't played a game this year for a reason!

Wulf & Callaghan would be starters in my side. Capuano would be my emergency instead of Knobel. Beetham wouldn't find a spot in the side or my emergencies. Clarke would be on my interchange. Begley as an emergency. Stevie Baker really deserves a spot on the bench as well.

Tough job though & a fair effort Steg.

Also why would Plough select a St.Kilda side ?

ahh, I put Plapp in there because when he was playing with Richmond, he was kicking goals, And I say put him in ther for a whole game and watch him do his stuff. Just tell him to go back to basics.

The reason Plough is coaching is because I copy +pasted it from the bullies board and forgot to change the coaches name, plus I was in a hurry.