scott_the_man
Club Legend
- Feb 25, 2014
- 2,304
- 2,936
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Thread starter
- #226
Surprised to see a lot of people leaving lewy taylor out. Hasn't missed a game in his first two years & is averaging 22 touches a game
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Really like St.Kildas picks, obviously Billings has elite talent.... but Acres and Dunstan @ 19 and 20 will look very good in a couple of years i reckon.
Happy with Sheed @ 11, has a much better outside game than i thought.
Exactly, compared to only about 30% of the thinner and/or more outside types, which is certainly what kelly is. Think Kelly will be more like a Gaff though and succeed.
You could be right but Acres really hasn't done much, Dunstan is solid but doesn't have 'star quality' for mine, and Billings has elite talent yes but a bit too inconsistent atm...early days of course.
Exactly, you can pretty much rely on him to have 20 possies and kick a goal every week, which you'd take from someone of any age in that role, especially when those possessions are usually of such high quality.Interested to hear your definition of inconsistent. He's been fairly consistent for mine given he's a second year player.
great little player. If Orazio comes on as well, despite the sanctions, we'd have had a decent pass mark for that draft.Merrett should be top 3
Who would you have up with Cripps and billings?great little player. If Orazio comes on as well, despite the sanctions, we'd have had a decent pass mark for that draft.
Classy onballer and a speedy forward/winger.
I'd have him up there with Cripps and Billings, just a touch behind the class of Bont. Pesky sanctions, we could have landed both that year.
quotes essendon fan with a comment re: Hird = opposition fans = tired old records. new material please.Who would you have up with Cripps and billings?
Essendon fans = sir James = delusional.
Who would you have up with Cripps and billings?
Essendon fans = sir James = delusional.
whats so ridiculous about it? Seems their output is very similarMerrett has Menzel covered. But Cripps...please!
he's been a rare hit for our drafting.whats so ridiculous about it? Seems their output is very similar
I would say merrett has been more consistent
Nah. The Dogs were red hot on Bont for as long as anyone. There wasn't a chance in hell they were parting with pick 4.great little player. If Orazio comes on as well, despite the sanctions, we'd have had a decent pass mark for that draft.
Classy onballer and a speedy forward/winger.
I'd have him up there with Cripps and Billings, just a touch behind the class of Bont. Pesky sanctions, we could have landed both that year.
Double the games? I hope you arent interpreting that as a negative for Cripps, because 1) he had a broken leg in his first year and 2) he has more room for growth as he has barely stepped foot on his afl career path.quotes essendon fan with a comment re: Hird = opposition fans = tired old records. new material please.
Zach Merrett - same draft as Cripps. double the games, similar stats. Cripps more handballs, Merrett more kicks. About the only stats that aren't close.
Scharenberg hasnt played a game, yet he rates better than McDonald (and any other player who HAS actually played).Not to upset North fans and of course things can (and probably will) change, but sometimes having a F/S can be an impost on a club.
McDonald deserved his selection at 8 but did to a large degree tie Norths hands, with having to to 'the right thing'
Hard to say who will be best and but that top 20 all look like solid long-term contributors.
I'd have Bontempelli, Billings, Boyd , Scharenberg and Cripps in my top 5, though.
Give me Kelly over Salem anyday.How you could have the likes of Kelly and Aish ahead of Salem is beyond a joke.
BF seems to have no clue about Salem.
Dom Sheed has been terrific too. Much better than Aish.
You are going to have a hard time finding people that would agree with having Salem over Kelly.How you could have the likes of Kelly and Aish ahead of Salem is beyond a joke.
BF seems to have no clue about Salem.
You are going to have a hard time finding people that would agree with having Salem over Kelly.