Toast 2022 Peter Crimmins Medal chat thread

[KermitJagger]

Adds a bit more perspective to Morrison, Day and Nash's seasons.

Coaches value players who will do what is asked of them, so Nash will always be rated ahead of where the stat sheet readers of this board think.

 

[Simon Crawshay]

Coaches really didn't rate Lynch this year

We did get absolutely smashed in the ruck this year so probably not that surprising.

The only time we were looking good in that position was the Geelong match just before Reeves did his shoulder

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

 

[KermitJagger]

Who got Dom on the mic?

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Total votes. Just for a reference from myself, really.

NAME	TOTAL
James SICILY	123
Jai NEWCOMBE	115
Dylan MOORE	113
Blake HARDWICK	82
Tom MITCHELL	79
Mitchell LEWIS	74
Jaeger O’MEARA	65
Finn MAGINNESS	61
Harry MORRISON	59
Jack SCRIMSHAW	59
Jack GUNSTON	56
Conor NASH	49
Luke BREUST	49
Changkuoth JIATH	47
Josh WARD	40
Connor MACDONALD	35
Denver GRAINGER-BARRAS	32
Sam FROST	32
Will DAY	32
Jarman IMPEY	28
Ned REEVES	27
Chad WINGARD	24
Jacob KOSCHITZKE	21
James BLANCK	18
Lachlan BRAMBLE	18
James WORPEL	16
Joshua MORRIS	15
Ben MCEVOY	12
Sam BUTLER	10
Daniel HOWE	6
Liam SHIELS	6
Tom PHILLIPS	5
Emerson JEKA	3
Jai SERONG	2
Kyle HARTIGAN	2
Jack SAUNDERS	1
Max LYNCH	1

 

[Blackhawk42]

Total votes. Just for a reference from myself, really.

NAME	TOTAL
James SICILY	123
Jai NEWCOMBE	115
Dylan MOORE	113
Blake HARDWICK	82
Tom MITCHELL	79
Mitchell LEWIS	74
Jaeger O’MEARA	65
Finn MAGINNESS	61
Harry MORRISON	59
Jack SCRIMSHAW	59
Jack GUNSTON	56
Conor NASH	49
Luke BREUST	49
Changkuoth JIATH	47
Josh WARD	40
Connor MACDONALD	35
Denver GRAINGER-BARRAS	32
Sam FROST	32
Will DAY	32
Jarman IMPEY	28
Ned REEVES	27
Chad WINGARD	24
Jacob KOSCHITZKE	21
James BLANCK	18
Lachlan BRAMBLE	18
James WORPEL	16
Joshua MORRIS	15
Ben MCEVOY	12
Sam BUTLER	10
Daniel HOWE	6
Liam SHIELS	6
Tom PHILLIPS	5
Emerson JEKA	3
Jai SERONG	2
Kyle HARTIGAN	2
Jack SAUNDERS	1
Max LYNCH	1

Every club does their B&F a little differently in regards to what scores votes, but I'm scratching my head at Serong polling more votes than Max Lynch.

Would have expected Max to poll a couple more because he had some stretches in games where he was all over his opponent. And I'm wondering what Serong did in his games to warrant the votes he got.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Every club does their B&F a little differently in regards to what scores votes, but I'm scratching my head at Serong polling more votes than Max Lynch.

Would have expected Max to poll a couple more because he had some stretches in games where he was all over his opponent. And I'm wondering what Serong did in his games to warrant the votes he got.

It could have been as simple as "we want to see you get up a contest on the wing and back to the square at least 5 times a quarter", and then he gets a vote for playing his role.

They explained the system at the start of the count. Not sure if the video is available of the count, but it would be good to revisit.

 

[Blackhawk42]

It could have been as simple as "we want to see you get up a contest on the wing and back to the square at least 5 times a quarter", and then he gets a vote for playing his role.

They explained the system at the start of the count. Not sure if the video is available of the count, but it would be good to revisit.

I'm cranky because my own club only awards votes for stand out performances while role players like myself are lucky to get Max Lynch votes .

At a previous club every player was given a score out of 5 for each game depending on how well they played their role. You could score half points too.
I really liked that model. I assume Fremantle had something similar the year Crowley won.

 

[TAITA]

Coaches value players who will do what is asked of them, so Nash will always be rated ahead of where the stat sheet readers of this board think.

Funny about that hey?

On SM-F936B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[PT Bar None]

I'm cranky because my own club only awards votes for stand out performances while role players like myself are lucky to get Max Lynch votes .

At a previous club every player was given a score out of 5 for each game depending on how well they played their role. You could score half points too.
I really liked that model. I assume Fremantle had something similar the year Crowley won.

I really like that style, but it's probably more demanding on the vote givers.

I once played at a club that for club BnF handed out 5,4,3,2,1 to the best 5 players week in week out. Meant the 6th best player the week the team played like world beaters gets 0 but had a heaps better game than the bloke who was third best the week you got smashed by a cricket score. And for that club the end of season count became starting rover 1st, starting ruck rover 2nd, and daylight to the next very quickly.

Hoping for more than 25 PCM's out of Chad next season. And big Noodle!