The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Moderator
- #8,376
hmmm. In what way do we know that Waite had made up his mind then ? I seriously doubt he had.
I however suspect AFTER his meeting with Mick that he did not feel overly valued and on top of that with only a one year contract put on table after that he decided North valued him more to do something with his last two seasons. I think that is when he made his mind up. He did say even after he went to North he wanted to remain a one club player but the one year contract offer is why he decided to leave. He felt he could play two more at Carlton.
I don't buy Mick's warped version of events for one moment. If he and Carlton had made him feel like he was a big part of plans for forward line for next two seasons and how him , Hendo and Casboult could work together in that time to give us best chance of success, I have little doubt he would have stayed. I suspect Mick just did not overly impress Waitey in the last meeting that he was truly valued to be part of the plans.
I agree that Mick should not have said anything publicly after Waite left. It was poor form. My entire point is that you can't point to the McLean situation and use the Waite situation to highlight hypocrisy because the timeframes are so different.
Given the speculation, given the uncertainty of teammates, given reports from the B&F, I find it more likely than not that Waite had made up his mind to leave more than a week before he signed with North. At the very least he was looking for a second year to change his mind. He was always gone unless Carlton upped their offer and he could have told them that.
I'm not bagging Waite here. He was one of my top two favourite Carlton players. However, the timeline makes sense here and I don't see the point in slagging off at anybody still at the club, when not in possession with the facts. Support the club and those at the club until you have a genuine reason not to.