- Thread starter
- #176
Same here
C Section Premier C - 2014
- Thread starter bedford
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Round 3 tips:
Hampton Rovers v Ormond
Monash Blues v Banyule
Parkdale v Marcellin
Old Camberwell v Oakleigh
Peninsula v PEGS
Hampton Rovers v Ormond
Monash Blues v Banyule
Parkdale v Marcellin
Old Camberwell v Oakleigh
Peninsula v PEGS
Same for me as well. Although I suspect Pegs might give it a shake.
Farewelling the great German Shields at the Frearson tomorrow. A sensational Ashes man.
A more than creditable performance today by the Monders against the team headed for Premier B.
- Thread starter
- #180
Best team won on the day but the ump that turned up 10m before the game was a disgrace, 2 of the softest free kicks to Hampton at the start of the last quarter didn't help
Bedford, did you say one of the two umpires actually turned up 10 min before the start of the seniors at BJR? What time do umpires normally turn up for their appointed game in the seniors (regardless of section)?
A fair second half by Monash was enough after Banyule were in front at half time.
A few blokes need to understand that courage is about going for the ball not swinging fists.
A few blokes need to understand that courage is about going for the ball not swinging fists.
Yes, Les, it was anybody's game until the first bounce between the Pirates and PEGS.
Supposed to be at the ground a minimum of 45 minutes before the start of the game I think. So the ump in question better have a very good explanation.
And it may cost him in the long run, when the umpires selectors sit down to name their appointments for the finals and especially the grand finals. Getting your decisions right and being on time for your appointed game are two of the things the umpires selectors take into account when selecting umpires to officiate at each week's games.
perspective
Team Captain
- Jun 15, 2012
- 500
- 92
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Fair dinkum criticising the umpires again..Did you ask the umpire why he was late? my very reliable mail suggests despite what he was told to tell the team managers that he was appointed very late to the game as there had been a late switch due to another game having an umpire pull out Saturday. You get 2 umpires that do the best they can ( 1 that may not have known he was umpiring there until 45 mins before the game, driving like a lunatic to get to the game, find a park run into the change rooms and then focus ) and they try and officiate blokes that drop chest marks, miss goals from less than 30 meters out, yell at spectators - and put up with team managers - officials abusing them showing the players that it is ok to yell at the umps...
Bedford as you rightly point out you lost to a better team, just leave it at that until your blokes stop making elementary mistakes and really costing the 4 points... Yes the umps get paid to do a job but this game isn't as straight forward as some sports in that this sport is very grey and is full of interpretation - who knows what the ump coaches are trying to instruct the umps to do. blaming umps is pathetic.
Bedford as you rightly point out you lost to a better team, just leave it at that until your blokes stop making elementary mistakes and really costing the 4 points... Yes the umps get paid to do a job but this game isn't as straight forward as some sports in that this sport is very grey and is full of interpretation - who knows what the ump coaches are trying to instruct the umps to do. blaming umps is pathetic.
Sorry Bedford but im with perspective on this. How many 'bad' decisions did your players and coach make during the game? Were they faultless? Did they have a ping for goal instead of sitting it 20 out, or did they try to mark instead of punching? Did they go to ground instead of keeping their feet, or miss a tackle? If not i guess they are no hope of catching Hampton as they have already reached perfection, are better people than I, and certainly better footballers than C grade VAFA . Umpires are on a hiding to nothing; We all see decisions that frustate us, but none of us are in the umpires boots seeing through his/her eyes, from his/her position on the ground, with his/her coaching directions whilst being berated by one eyed supporters and officials. And to my shock and horror they are also human and will make mistakes! You've been involved in football long enough to know better.
Last edited:
perspective
Team Captain
- Jun 15, 2012
- 500
- 92
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
We all know that the umpires are meant to get better as the standard of footy gets better, so I reckon the solution is simple, stop dropping chest marks and stop taking flying shots from the scoreboard at gunn reserve instead of hitting the goal square and stop concentrating on things outside your control and you may find yourself winning enough games to get into B Grade - and then get umpires who make less errors.
- Thread starter
- #191
ffs im not saying players didn't make mistakes, they made plenty , all I said was that there was 2 decisions in a row that stopped the momentum at that time. I also said the better team won.
Maybe the umpiring hierarchy should make it abundantly clear to the clubs how they are interpreting the Laws of the Game.
It is a very tough job involving split second calls. They are therefore bound to make their share of poor calls. Think most of us accept that providing the error rate isn't too high and there's consistency of interpretation.
I noticed at the Scotch v St Bedes game a marked difference in the way the game was umpired after quarter time. They held the whistle way too long at scrimmages and were reluctant to pay what looked from outside the fence to be far from incidental infringements in the first quarter. That changed after quarter time when they found the pea in the whistle and as a consequence the game was a better spectacle. Can only assume the duty observer had some pointed comments at quarter time.
Wouldn't be too harsh on Bedford who is a loyal hardworking Monder who carries his heart on his sleeve. And officiating officials can make howlers. Ask Kevin Muscat.
Privateye
Cancelled
Well I'm with Bedford on this one, I also have never made a mistake in my life and am never wrong even when I am.
Likening the incidents. Not the personalities.
Ormond Monash Blues
Marcellin Old Camberwell
PEGS Hampton Rovers
Peninsula Parkdale
Banyule Oakleigh
Marcellin Old Camberwell
PEGS Hampton Rovers
Peninsula Parkdale
Banyule Oakleigh
clint_mccoy
Team Captain
Looks like it's going to be another round were most experts agree on the winners.
Round 4.
Ormond v Monash Blues
Marcellin v Old Camberwell
PEGS v Hampton Rovers
Peninsula vs Parkdale
Banyule v Oakleigh
Round 4.
Ormond v Monash Blues
Marcellin v Old Camberwell
PEGS v Hampton Rovers
Peninsula vs Parkdale
Banyule v Oakleigh
I think you're right, Clint. Even with the predicted bad weather, I can't see any upsets.
Round 4 tips:
Ormond v Monash Blues
Marcellin v Old Camberwell
PEGS v Hampton Rovers
Peninsula vs Parkdale
Banyule v Oakleigh
Round 4 tips:
Ormond v Monash Blues
Marcellin v Old Camberwell
PEGS v Hampton Rovers
Peninsula vs Parkdale
Banyule v Oakleigh
Monash to beat monds. Well done Sam baring on 100 senior games, joining his dad on this milestone. Let's hope Sam can be a dual premiership player like his old man!
Wells to beat eagles.
Pegs to win just cause it's at home.
Pirates to win well. Surely they can make the finals this year??
Bears at home will just get the points.
Wells to beat eagles.
Pegs to win just cause it's at home.
Pirates to win well. Surely they can make the finals this year??
Bears at home will just get the points.
Monash Blues
Marcellin
Hampton Rovers
Peninsula
Banyule
Marcellin
Hampton Rovers
Peninsula
Banyule
- Status
