5 Rounds in Pick your AA side

[Mayneman]

FB: Harbrow Frawley Grundy
HB: Gilbert Macpharlin Griffen
C : Goodes Wellingham Barlow
HF: Pavlich Brown O'keefe
FF: Bradshaw Hall Ballantyne

RR: Sandilands Ablett Hayes

I/C : Cooney Swan Seaby Mundy

If you dont like it you can go and get stuffed.

 

[B-Rock]

Chapman >> Ballantyne.

Seaby has gone backwards the last few weeks.

No Goddard?

 

[The_Eagles]

Harbrow Frawley Grundy
O'Brien McPharlin Drummond
Swan Bartel O'Keefe
Goddard Brown Chapman
Milne Pavlich LeCras

Sandilands Ablett Hayes

Barlow Gilbert Sylvia Naitanui

 

[Mayneman]

Chapman >> Ballantyne.

Seaby has gone backwards the last few weeks.

No Goddard?

Im picking the best performed players in the position they play.

Goddard was appalling vs Port, very close though.

To TheEagles, to not include Griffen and Goodes is to demonstrate how little you know about the game.

 

[Crash]

FB: Harbrow Frawley Grundy
HB: Gilbert Macpharlin Goodes
C : Griffen Wellingham Barlow
HF: Pavlich Brown O'keefe
FF: Bradshaw Hall Ballantyne

RR: Sandilands Ablett Hayes

I/C : Cooney Swan Seaby Mundy

If you dont like it you can go and get stuffed.

Goodes shouldn't be near the backline, is playing as CHF / Mid and hasnt been playing that good, would replace with Taylor, Goddard or Malceski

Ballantyne to be replaced by Mcglynn who was in great touch

Seaby to be replaced by Jamar

Mundy to be replaced by one of either Taylor Goddard or Malceski

 

[Sidebottom2Beams]

How is Swan making it into peoples teams he played 1 good game against the doggies the rest have been average.


Gilbert - Lake - Enright
Shaw - Taylor - Malceski
Simpson - Boyd - Goddard
O'keefe - Brown - Chapman
Pavlich - Fev - Mcglynn
Sandilands - Ablett - Hodge
Green - Montagna - Grundy - Barlow

 

[Mayneman]

Goodes shouldn't be near the backline, is playing as CHF / Mid and hasnt been playing that good, would replace with Taylor, Goddard or Malceski

Ballantyne to be replaced by Mcglynn who was in great touch

Seaby to be replaced by Jamar

Mundy to be replaced by one of either Taylor Goddard or Malceski

My bad, should have had Goodes on a wing, Griffen HBF.

Im comfortable with the rest though.

Ballantyne is doing what you want from a small forward, kicking goals and laying tackles. He's doing that better than any other small forward presently.

 

[The Chiefton]

B: Harry O'Brien Brian Lake Heath Grundy
HB: Sam Gilbert Harry Taylor Luke Hodge
C: Ryan O'Keefe Jim Bartel Michael Rischitelli
HF: Brendon Goddard Jonothan Brown Paul Chapman
F: Ricky Petterd Barry Hall Eddie Betts
R: Aaron Sandilands Ryan Griffen Gary Ablett Jnr
I: James Frawley Michael Barlow Mark Jamar Sharrod Wellingham

 

[BONG RIPS MKII]

Grundy - Lake - Gilbert
Malceski - Taylor - O'Brien
Bartel - Boyd - Wellingham
Goddard - Pavlich - Chapman
Hall - Brown - McGlynn
Sandilands - Ablett - Barlow
Kreuzer - Griffen - Hodge - Cooney

 

[Danog]

You would have to fit Petterd in somewhere, BRMKII

 

[buddyruff]

Typical Geelong team above.

Hodge has dominated every game he's played, yet you start him on the bench???

 

[buddyruff]

Goodes shouldn't be near the backline, is playing as CHF / Mid and hasnt been playing that good, would replace with Taylor, Goddard or Malceski

Ballantyne to be replaced by Mcglynn who was in great touch

Seaby to be replaced by Jamar

Mundy to be replaced by one of either Taylor Goddard or Malceski

Do you watch any games that Sydney isn't involved in???

Seriously, every comment above is related to a Sydney player...take your head out of the sand

 

[BONG RIPS MKII]

Typical Geelong team above.

Hodge has dominated every game he's played, yet you start him on the bench???

he's dominated and yet you've won just one game

 

[Brad Roo]

Anyone that doesn't have Brady Rawlings in a back pocket simply doesn't have a clue.

Thank god, Healy and Sheahan are finally taking notice.

 

[The Chiefton]

Anybody agree with my side?

 

[Brad Roo]

Your back line is way too tall.

Where's Brady?

 

[The Chiefton]

Anyone that doesn't have Brady Rawlings in a back pocket simply doesn't have a clue.

Thank god, Healy and Sheahan are finally taking notice.

Disagree strongly. Whilst he was arguably BOG on sunday, that does not mean he is AA defender quality just yet. Take the bias away and you will see that people who don't have him in there aren't stupid.

 

[Brad Roo]

No bias mate, here are the numbers:

Rawlings v Drummond

http://www.pro-stats.com.au/psw/web/compare_players?tid1=110&pid1=785&tid2=102&pid2=2004011

Rawlings v Harbrow

http://www.pro-stats.com.au/psw/web/compare_players?tid1=110&pid1=785&tid2=115&pid2=2007150

Rawlings v Malceski

http://www.pro-stats.com.au/psw/web/compare_players?tid1=110&pid1=785&tid2=114&pid2=2003062

Slightly less rebound, but he does actually slaughter an opponent every week. It's about time this bloke started getting some credit.

 

[The Chiefton]

Your back line is way too tall.

Where's Brady?

Mate Harry O and Gilbert get small forwards all the time, and more often than not they beat them. Luke Hodge is 184cm.... hardly a giant, and Taylor, Lake and possibly Grundy have been the in form talls in the comp.

 

[QuietB]

he's dominated and yet you've won just one game

Thats because 20 other blokes are doing SFA!

 

[SweetLeftFoot]

Anyone that doesn't have Brady Rawlings in a back pocket simply doesn't have a clue.

Thank god, Healy and Sheahan are finally taking notice.

Glad you got into before me.

Rawlings is the form small backman of the comp by so far its not funny.

Owned Rioli on the weekend and ran the length of the ground in the dying minutes to kick the decisive goal.

 

[Koutafidamedis]

Any love for Jordan Russell??

 

[blueborl]

Harbrow Frawley Grundy
O'Brien McPharlin Drummond
Swan Bartel O'Keefe
Goddard Brown Chapman
Milne Pavlich LeCras

Sandilands Ablett Hayes

Barlow Gilbert Sylvia Naitanui

How the hell did you manage to find a spot for Lecras.Brown and Natanui?
Brown 8 posessions and 1 goal and ineffective all day obviously injured.
Lecras 10 posessions no goals 30%DE.
And Natanui? you are kidding 5 posessions did nothing exept make a few tackles.

I am glad you are not a AA selector you have no idea

 

[The Big League]

Good to see some Wellingham love, he has been our best player thus far.

 

[AsianWithAFro]

Good to see some Wellingham love, he has been our best player thus far.

it would be amazing if he made it this year but to me it seems unlikely