5 Rounds in Pick your AA side

[StringyDog]

There's a vast difference between scraping into the 8 and finishing bottom 4.

You really think Hawks will finish in bottom 4.....get serious, and also in 2008 AA captain was from side that finished 11th.

 

[CrimsonRaven]

B: Carlile, Fletcher, Enright
HB: Goddard, Hodge, Malceski http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=researchmini&pid=625
C: Brennen, Barlow, Montagna
HF: O'Keefe, J. Brown, Chapman
F: Hall, Pavlich, Bradshaw
R: Sandilands, Riscitelli, Ablett
Int: Jamar, Harvey, Chaplin, Griffen

Anything wrong with this? I might be favoring the two port players more than their reality, but otherwise....

 

[robertg22]

You really think Hawks will finish in bottom 4.....get serious, and also in 2008 AA captain was from side that finished 11th.

They will go VERY close.

 

[Sttew]

Macpharlin has been superb, no one in the competition comes close.

Try Harry Taylor who according to AA selector Gerard Healey, is on track for AA selection.

 

[AG]

And Grundy. It seems not many rate him so far.

 

[CHIEF SMACKAHOE]

B: Harbrow - Lake - Shaw
HB: O'Brien - Taylor - Malceski
C: Cooney - Boyd - O'Keefe
HF: Goddard - Brown - Chapman
F: Pavlich - Hall - Petterd
FOL: Sandilands - Griffen - Ablett
INT: Barlow - McGlynn - Bartel - Grundy

 

[stormee]

B: Gilbert, Frawley, Lake
HB: Hodge, Taylor, Malceski
C: Ablett, Watson, Wellingham
HF: S. Johnson, J. Brown (c), O'Keefe
F: Goddard, Hall, LeCras
R: Sandilands, Hayes, Dal Santo
Int: Jamar, Aaron Davey, O'Brien, Harvey
Unlucky: Barlow, Bartel, Pears, Bradshaw, H. Shaw

Stevie J on a HFF? Hasn't he done precisely nothing this year to date?

 

[#14Ward]

Grundy Lake Goddard
Gilbert Taylor Griffen
Barlow Bartel Murphy
O'Keefe Brown Pavlich
Mcglynn Hall Chapman
Sandilands Ablett Hodge
Jamar Rischitelli Simpson Jamison

 

[melbournemartin]

Not seeing much Grimes love but good to see a bit of Frawley love.

Jamar would have to be on the bench of any team. He's easily been the second best ruckman in the league. From Melbourne, I'd have him in my team as well as Grimes. Green would be close to making the bench, as would Frawley.

I cbf doing an entire team though largely because I haven't seen enough of every team.

 

[melbournemartin]

B: Carlile, Fletcher, Enright
HB: Goddard, Hodge, Malceski http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=researchmini&pid=625
C: Brennen, Barlow, Montagna
HF: O'Keefe, J. Brown, Chapman
F: Hall, Pavlich, Bradshaw
R: Sandilands, Riscitelli, Ablett
Int: Jamar, Harvey, Chaplin, Griffen

Anything wrong with this? I might be favoring the two port players more than their reality, but otherwise....

I wouldn't pick Fletcher at full back. I can't recall games this year when he's actually played full back. You'd probably want a tall at HB, perhaps Taylor?

 

[Coobk001]

Stevie J on a HFF? Hasn't he done precisely nothing this year to date?

Highest scoring small forward in the comp whilst running at half pace, I would say he's probably on track for AA.