Rumour The Thread formerly known as the rumour file, now with zero rumours

[Sublime]

Should really just walk away. Pick#7 is worth more than kj+19+40

It all depends on how good Jaksch turns out to be for us.

If he bombs, then any trade for him will be a failure. If he turns out great then any of the trades put forward so far would be a bargain.

 

[RiCHii]

It all depends on how good Jaksch turns out to be for us.

If he bombs, then any trade for him will be a failure. If he turns out great then any of the trades put forward so far would be a bargain.

With what he has shown so far then he isn't worth the proposed trades, simple as that. GWS want pick 7 based on hope and promise, I hope Carlton do the right thing, walk away, we'll be much better off!

 

[Sublime]

With what he has shown so far then he isn't worth the proposed trades, simple as that. GWS want pick 7 based on hope and promise, I hope Carlton do the right thing, walk away, we'll be much better off!

So if we walk away now and becomes a gun elsewhere, you'd be happy that we did that still? Its a difficult situation and obviously we're backing him in to be very good for us.

 

[SafeAsMilk]

With what he has shown so far then he isn't worth the proposed trades, simple as that. GWS want pick 7 based on hope and promise, I hope Carlton do the right thing, walk away, we'll be much better off!

I don't think we'll walk away at this point but I'd say we'll get something else. I wouldn't listen too much to what Nathan Brown has to say.

 

[JamisonRun40]

I love Groundhog Day..

or
the wheels on the bus go round and round, round and round, just keep repeating until the end of the week.

 

[serenityNow]

You can only go on the here and now, and imo pick 7 is not worth KJ (even packaged with the picks) he's full of hope and promise atm.......... just like many others are.


Would rather go to the draft with #7

 

[BlueMaster1]

I found I scocial media rumour (I don't believe it's true but here it is what it says)


News coming in that josh Kennedy is unhappy being in Sydney with some players in the coming season may have to take a pay cut to fit into Sydney's salary cap.

Could we see the big time midfielder move home to Vitoria? Kennedy manger said that he has spoken with a few melbounre clubs about a possible move.

Melbounre hawthorn and CARLTON have all spoken with his manager about a possible trade.

I don't think it's true but it is a good discussion

 

[BluesRule]

I found I scocial media rumour (I don't believe it's true but here it is what it says)


News coming in that josh Kennedy is unhappy being in Sydney with some players in the coming season may have to take a pay cut to fit into Sydney's salary cap.

Could we see the big time midfielder move home to Vitoria? Kennedy manger said that he has spoken with a few melbounre clubs about a possible move.

Melbounre hawthorn and CARLTON have all spoken with his manager about a possible trade.

I don't think it's true but it is a good discussion

That would be a big fish!!

 

[BlueMaster1]

That would be a big fish!!

Question is how do we get him here

 

[BluesRule]

That would be a big fish!!

Happy to pay pick #7 for Kennedy!!!

 

[BluesRule]

Happy to pay pick #7 for Kennedy!!!

Even throw in Robbo, Garlett and Lucas

 

[BluesRule]

Even throw in Robbo, Garlett and Lucas

Plus Warnock, Ellard and White

 

[serenityNow]

Essendon denied Paddy Rider FA scam.....Essendon now preparing the legal team...

 

[JamisonRun40]

What is all this crap about trading White. Keep White.

 

[BluesRule]

What is all this crap about trading White. Keep White.

Sorry got carried away ... like White but would swap in the very unlikely event it got us Kennedy. Still do not believe this is true!

 

[Sublime]

Ryan Griffin wants out of the Dogs to get to GWS.

How will this affect anything we're trying to do with them do you think?

 

[BlueMaster1]

Ryan Griffin wants out of the Dogs to get to GWS.

How will this affect anything we're trying to do with them do you think?

Jaksch mite be involved in the deal

 

[slashin_velvet]

It will mean GWS will want out pick 7 desperately now.

 

[smashbox gill]

TWR just said Pick 7 for Jaksch + 19 + Whiley.

Dont like it at all. I want that pick 20

 

[etsal1]

It will mean GWS will want out pick 7 desperately now.

Yep - play hardball.

 

[BluesRule]

TWR just said Pick 7 for Jaksch + 19 + Whiley.

Dont like it at all. I want that pick 20

Prefer Laverde and KJ for our first two selections, rather than KJ, Whiley and ?pick 19???

 

[BluesRule]

TWR just said Pick 7 for Jaksch + 19 + Whiley.

Dont like it at all. I want that pick 20

At best saying #7 = KJ, Whiley, #19 and #21 and even if we get two good players at those picks it will not be as good as Laverde becoming a gun.

 

[blues4flag]

At best saying #7 = KJ, Whiley, #19 and #21 and even if we get two good players at those picks it will not be as good as Laverde becoming a gun.

That's not true at all.

 

[choo]

GWS want #7 give us Shiel

 

[TheRedPill]

It will mean GWS will want out pick 7 desperately now.

Agreed. Should be Jaksch, 19 and 21. If we forsake 21 for a tagger who can't make the GWS side, I will spew! And Whiley being young is irrelevant - their whole side is composed of young players, so if he can't make it regularly, then they clearly don't rate him that highly.