List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

[Baltimore Jack]

I wouldn't want the club to do that deal even if possible, we are the worst off out of the three clubs. Long term I think Matt scharenberg is worth more than motlop

It isn't possible, players cannot be on-traded

 

[Old Spice]

Grundy, a 28 year old insurance ruck, Cox and maybe some project 18 year old. It would be absolutely bananas to bring in Gawn or Leueneberger which would waste money, picks and stall Grundy's development.

 

[Rusty Beam]

Grundy, a 28 year old insurance ruck, Cox and a maybe some project 18 year old. It would be absolutely bananas to bring in Gawn or Leueneberger which would waste money, picks and stall Grundy's development.

Absolutely correct spice.

You don't waste money on having a first choice ruck as an insurance policy for injury.

I don't get why people keep saying it.

 

[Bay Pie]

I believe Dion Prestia was the mid spoken about yesterday, as us having interest. Very good player but a bit midgety.

 

[Jasper84]

I believe Dion Prestia was the mid spoken about yesterday, as us having interest. Very good player but a bit midgety.

He publicly stated that he will see out his contract with gc the other day.

 

[Big Bryza]

Look at Ceglar. Hawks have a talent for picking up fringe talent.

Ceglar is overrated by many. He's not that good.

 

[ThePhantom777]

Would you swap trade PK for Jonathan Simpkin?

 

[Big Bryza]

TBH if we get Treloar and nothing else this trade period I'm fine with that. If we add another good player then that would be icing.

Agreed. Treloar is priority number 1. Other than that getting full pre seasons into our current young talent and fingers crossed keeping guys like Reid and Freeman injury free is the main concern.

 

[danielnajdek]

I want Treloar.

GUN!!

 

[Big Bryza]

Aish is criminally underrated on this board

If he was a Collingwood player he would be the next Pendlebury

The kid will be a star, just playing for a team he hates at the moment and having some 2nd year blues.

What has Aish done to show that he's anywhere near being the next Pendlebury?!

 

[Big Bryza]

Cox has a long way to go. Shown great improvement of bits and pieces of doing stuff, rucking or kicking but had very little Idea about reading the play still. Being bloody tall with long arms he's good at getting his hand on the ball in the ruck.

But would give us almost nothing as second ruck forward. And it would hurt his development,

When are you guys going to mark White on a level playing field?

Whites been in the system for 10 years.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

It isn't possible, players cannot be on-traded

No but you can send them somewhere else in a three-way trade. It's just semantics to say you can't on-trade players.

 

[Baltimore Jack]

No but you can send them somewhere else in a three-way trade. It's just semantics to say you can't on-trade players.

No, its a rule....but you already knew that
Semantics, you say?

 

[unplugged]

I'm one of Treloar's biggest fans... but has anyone else noticed how much he walks during a game?

 

[ThePhantom777]

I'm one of Treloar's biggest fans... but has anyone else noticed how much he walks during a game?

Well it is tiring work making 9 tackles like his game on the weekend. Or his 27 disposal average for the past two seasons

 

[Apex36]

No, its a rule....but you already knew that
Semantics, you say?

A rule which can be worked around with 3 way trades. So yeah, it's semantics.

 

[Old Spice]

I believe Dion Prestia was the mid spoken about yesterday, as us having interest. Very good player but a bit midgety.

He's quality too, let's not forget that. We're quick to forget in the footy world quality in low-ranking teams. You pay a premium to dislodge a gun mid from a decent team at full pelt but GC have been without Ablett, O'Meara, Swallow, Bennell for most of this year so Prestia has become a massive shut-down target.

I still rate Treloar higher but it's worth thinking about if GWS want to squeeze our nuts on the deal. We have some type of relationship with Eade, have some possible Queensland trade bait this year and next and if we got Prestia cheaper we might get access still to two of Carlisle/Motlop/Aish.

 

[spartan-magpie]

If we are to trade witts, what about Jong? Haven't seen a lot of him but what I have seen has been pretty good. 1st rounder and Jong?

 

[Matt_352]

If we are to trade witts, what about Jong? Haven't seen a lot of him but what I have seen has been pretty good. 1st rounder and Jong?

straight swap for the bont would do me fine

 

[danielnajdek]

straight swap for the bont would do me fine

Throw in Stringer.

 

[Matt_352]

Throw in Stringer.

nah Boyd

 

[spartan-magpie]

straight swap for the bont would do me fine

For the bont I'd give them scharanberg, witts and our first rounder.

 

[danielnajdek]

nah Boyd

Million dollar kid!!

 

[Matt_352]

For the bont I'd give them scharanberg, witts and our first rounder.

better chuck in Pendles as the steak knives

 

[TheWing121]

Ceglar is overrated by many. He's not that good.

Also we didn't get rid of Ceglar due to his on field performance, it was his attitude / too much partying