Senior 9. Patrick Cripps

[Aphrodite]

 

[Moe B]

Crippa, he might win the rising star but can he even come close to a brownlow, you got absolutely robbed mate, seems like nothing going right for us right now but we will have the last laugh...

 

[Blue__Balls]

Tend to agree with this, Cripps was great but would of enhanced his chances more by hitting the scoreboard more and converting at a better ratio.

Anyway something to work on and look out when he does improve this aspect of his game.

Yep, no way an inside mid could possibly win unless they kicked a stack of goals too

 

[Jamie007]

So that means out of the 10 voters only one of them gave the 5 votes to Cripps and 9 of them rated Hogan the 5 votes.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

The scoring is ridiculous, 9 judges gave Hogan the maximum... Reckon Sheehan was the Cripps man.

The only one I would listen to.

 

[Faz 2000]

Cripps for Witts and a third-rounder?

 

[BringBackSimmo]

This says it all.

 

[ImBlue]

Congrats to both of them. Both hugely talented and important players for their clubs.

Stop being so sensible and join us with pitch forks in hand to AFL headquarters.

 

[LanceRomance]

This says it all.

what does it say?

 

[PuffDragon89]

Oh well, know Hogan would win it, was fun for a moment hoping Crippa'd be given a fair go with the 'tie' talk and 2 chairs.

Wonder how much Paddy's 186mins in 2014 weighed into the votes and how little this being Hogan's third year in the system...

 

[BringBackSimmo]

what does it say?

I'm not sure, but all of it!

 

[Carl Tone]

Welcome to Carlton Cripps.
This is the AFL way. #stilldirtyonDiesels9weeks

 

[james Dean]

I guess a B&F will have to do for Crippa.

Hogan had a great year, can't begrudge him winning, but I wouldn't trade Cripps for him so I'm quite content with what we have

 

[kingkingston]

The scoring is ridiculous, 9 judges gave Hogan the maximum... Reckon Sheehan was the Cripps man.

Cameron Ling gave him the nod i'm sure of it because he said Cripps should win it

 

[zeeCFC]

Farmers should be treated as royalty......

Nice to have you on our forum, Pol Pot

 

[Faz 2000]

Sorry, does this result change in any way what Patrick Cripps did for Carlton this year? Or what he's GOING to do for the next decade? Nosirree.

Hulk is awesome, and had a beastly first year (on field) in the AFL by any standard, and certainly for a KPF. Love him, he's great.

The Rising Star trinket is completely meaningless in the story that is Patrick Cripps being the centrepiece of the re-birth of Carlton!

 

[TBellicious]

Oh well, know Hogan would win it, was fun for a moment hoping Crippa'd be given a fair go with the 'tie' talk and 2 chairs.

Wonder how much Paddy's 186mins in 2014 weighed into the votes and how little this being Hogan's third year in the system...

Its Hogan's second is it not?

 

[PuffDragon89]

So, 41 votes...

Who was the lone judge who gave him 5 votes?

Sheehan I guess

 

[Blue__Balls]

Have had a think about it - maybe we should move any negative comments on this result to another thread?

This one is here for us to celebrate Patty, not condemn the AFL.

I want to be able to come here to be happy!!!

 

[BringBackSimmo]

Sorry, does this result change in any way what Patrick Cripps did for Carlton this year? Or what he's GOING to do for the next decade? Nosirree.

Hulk is awesome, and had a beastly first year (on field) in the AFL by any standard, and certainly for a KPF. Love him, he's great.

The Rising Star trinket is completely meaningless in the story that is Patrick Cripps being the centrepiece of the re-birth of Carlton!

It doesn't, but it would of been nice (and deserved)

 

[__Bobcat__]

Well Done Crippa,,,

Patty was paid the ultimate complement against the Pies,,
Pendles, an A grader, tried to tag Crippa in the Final Hallf!!!

 

[PuffDragon89]

Its Hogan's second is it not?

2012 Mini draft, 2013 played VFL against AFL listed players at 17.

 

[kingkingston]

Sorry, does this result change in any way what Patrick Cripps did for Carlton this year? Or what he's GOING to do for the next decade? Nosirree.

Hulk is awesome, and had a beastly first year (on field) in the AFL by any standard, and certainly for a KPF. Love him, he's great.

The Rising Star trinket is completely meaningless in the story that is Patrick Cripps being the centrepiece of the re-birth of Carlton!

yes he is but Hogan went quiet in the second half and 44 goals isn't that good for a key forward

Cripps didn't go quiet

 

[Faz 2000]

It doesn't, but it would of been nice (and deserved)

Nobody is owed an individual award. Was Jesse Hogan undeserving?

Did Patrick Cripps have a GREAT year in 2015? Absolutely.

 

[Aphrodite]

Sheehan the only one that gave Cripps 5 votes.

Surprised NOT!

 

[mickelboy182]

Cameron Ling gave him the nod i'm sure of it because he said Cripps should win it

You sure? I remember the Melbourne game Lingy was about Hogan, after the game he tongue in cheek said he might need to change his vote but I don't think he was all too serious in that.