Traded Jake Carlisle [traded w/ #23 and #44 for #5, #24 and Craig Bird]

[foj1]

So what you gonna do when no one is going to give it?..because he has already quit the club

Come on passion pop.
First you said you will only take Carlisle from psd now you are saying no 10-15 pick.
We screwed our club because of supplements your club is just screwed.

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Dreams are nice because they are free.

So is getting Carlilse via the psd.

 

[foj1]

Carlisle has rejected them get with the times.

Ok all knowing one

 

[pinot]

Ok all knowing one

Its widely known that Carlisle has rejected North Melbourne "because they have too many tall defenders"

 

[pinot]

So is getting Carlilse via the psd.

Could be, we shall see. You guys are in a tough spot. Take Matty Watson and 2nd round pick 2016 will be between 19-23 whats wrong with that?

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Its widely known that Carlisle has rejected North Melbourne "because they have too many tall defenders"

I find that bull.

Ferrito is no spring chicken any more they'll be mad to pass up Carlilse they'll find a spot.

 

[pinot]

I find that bull.

Ferrito is no spring chicken any more they'll be mad to pass up Carlilse they'll find a spot.

Don't think its bull both parties have walked away also reported on AFL.com

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Stupid suggestion Watson and 2nd, will never happen

I've said it before and still stand by it
Kristian Jaksch for Jake Carlise
Win win for both clubs, Bombers get a player in 21-23 age range who was drafted at pick 12, similar to Carlise that can play both ends

Jaksch is not going anywhere. Where do you come up this? We traded for him because we want him. Not to throw him away a year later.

 

[Fear Boner]

Its widely known that Carlisle has rejected North Melbourne "because they have too many tall defenders"

Your the kinda guy that drinks his own bath water and would get a rib removed to service himself with his own mouth aren't you ....

 

[gillo94]

Jaksch is not going anywhere. Where do you come up this? We traded for him because we want him. Not to throw him away a year later.

Just a suggestion that they should persue mature age talls rather than picks. Jaksch I agree will stay at Blues but more so the idea on types that should target

 

[foj1]

Could be, we shall see. You guys are in a tough spot. Take Matty Watson and 2nd round pick 2016 will be between 19-23 whats wrong with that?

You really are a tool passion pop.
Marty Watson will most likely be delisted. Why would we take a 2016 second round pick?

 

[pinot]

You really are a tool passion pop.
Marty Watson will most likely be delisted. Why would we take a 2016 second round pick?

Because its the best pick you would get for him?

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

I really do not care what pinot has to say. We will get more than he is saying. Simple. All find and dandy for you to talk the talk, but this wont change much until draft period. Few deals need to be sorted before this deal.

 

[Pat_Footy]

Henderson pick will do.

Carlisle is going to Carlton via the PSD. Shocking trading from Essendon previously has made this straight forward.

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

Can I ask the Essendon posters why they seem to ignore the whole WADA thing when discussing trades?

How do you expect to demand a top 20 pick for Carlisle when hes staring down the barrel of a 2 year ban?

Please answer, it is truly fascinating

Simple fact, hes not going to get a 2 year ban, and you be sure the club picking him up will find that out.

Are you still fascinated, or just drunk after last nights smashing?

 

[Pat_Footy]

Simple fact, hes not going to get a 2 year ban, and you be sure the club picking him up will find that out.

Are you still fascinated, or just drunk after last nights smashing?

You have no idea whether he will be banned. WADA have their appeal later this year. No club is going to pay a top pick for a player that may get banned for 2 years. This is all nonsense though as Carlisle is going to Carlton via the PSD. Carlton aren't going to engage in ridiculous trades with Dohodoro.

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

You have no idea whether he will be banned. WADA have their appeal later this year. No club is going to pay a top pick for a player that may get banned for 2 years. This is all nonsense though as Carlisle is going to Carlton via the PSD. Carlton aren't going to engage in ridiculous trades with Dohodoro.

Nah, hes not. We've been through this.

Its halarious tho. Every man and his dog is clinging onto 2 planks words this thread, but hes been the one saying carlton will trade for him.

Just keep sprouting that psd bullshit, will make it all the more sweeter when it doesnt happen and I can quote you.

 

[Pat_Footy]

Nah, hes not. We've been through this.

Its halarious tho. Every man and his dog is clinging onto 2 planks words this thread, but hes been the one saying carlton will trade for him.

Just keep sprouting that psd bullshit, will make it all the more sweeter when it doesnt happen and I can quote you.

Why would Carlton engage in trade talk with the notoriously difficult and delusional Dodohoro? This is business, not a charity.

Carlton i'm sure will go through the Trade Week motions for the PR but as soon as the talks get underway - they will renege. Carlton will take him via the PSD and all will be forgotten in 2 years time. They are fully aware of that. Calrton wouldn't be doing the best thing by the club giving away picks and players for a player awaiting a possible 2 year ban who they can get for free.

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

Why would Carlton engage in trade talk with the notoriously difficult and delusional Dodohoro? This is business, not a charity.

Carlton i'm sure will go through the Trade Week motions for the PR but as soon as the talks get underway - they will renege. Carlton will take him via the PSD and all will be forgotten in 2 years time. They are fully aware of that. Calrton wouldn't be doing the best thing by the club giving away picks and players for a player awaiting a possible 2 year ban who they can get for free.

Ok m8

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Carlisle is going to Carlton via the PSD. Shocking trading from Essendon previously has made this straight forward.

It's been mentioned that Carlilse will not low ball Essendon by walking to the psd.

 

[Bostonian]

It's been mentioned that Carlilse will not low ball Essendon by walking to the psd.

It's been mentioned it really has nothing to do with what the player says as to what the deal is.

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

It's been mentioned it really has nothing to do with what the player says as to what the deal is.

Technically it does.
Because the player has to nominate the draft. But I agree, I don't really care what he's said, means little, saving face until he's at new club. But... still won't go through PSD.

 

[Vindicater]

Can I ask the Essendon posters why they seem to ignore the whole WADA thing when discussing trades?

How do you expect to demand a top 20 pick for Carlisle when hes staring down the barrel of a 2 year ban?

Please answer, it is truly fascinating

We ignore it because it is what it is.

Any club looking to pick Carlisle up will do their homework about what is likely to come in terms of punishment.

If it is going to be a 2 year ban those teams will pull out of trade talks pretty quickly.
If it is going to be no bans or little bans (up to 4 weeks) then that is not an issue and teams will be happy to trade for him.

Like every trade, the thing that will really affect how much Essendon gets is who Carlisle ends up nominating to play for.

 

[Pat_Footy]

We ignore it because it is what it is.

Any club looking to pick Carlisle up will do their homework about what is likely to come in terms of punishment.

If it is going to be a 2 year ban those teams will pull out of trade talks pretty quickly.
If it is going to be no bans or little bans (up to 4 weeks) then that is not an issue and teams will be happy to trade for him.

Like every trade, the thing that will really affect how much Essendon gets is who Carlisle ends up nominating to play for.

Well other clubs aren't ignoring it at all. They are completely aware and will not be trading anything of high value as a result. Carlisle is 100% going as we all know. Carlton via PSD is likely. Disappointing for EFC but they only have themselves to blame. Carlisle hates the club as has been well documented.

 

[hollywood23]

This thread needs to be blown up. Flog central