List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

[Hardas]

Serious question guys:
How would you rank in order Ah Chee, Milera, Rioli and Kerbatieh and how are they different from one another.
I think we are missing some Rioli crumbing in our fwd line.

Apologies if you already know all this, but if you haven't ventured over there, you'd be better off asking that question on the Drafts,Trading and Free Agency Forum.
People like chris25 as well as our very own Knightmare and Snoopdog have phantom drafts with lots of similar questions being raised in the on-going discussions:
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/forums/phantom-drafts.284/

 

[Matt_352]

Apologies if you already know all this, but if you haven't ventured over there, you'd be better off asking that question on the Drafts,Trading and Free Agency Forum.
People like chris25 as well as our very own Knightmare and Snoopdog have phantom drafts with lots of similar questions being raised in the on-going discussions:
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/forums/phantom-drafts.284/

Ok cheers

 

[ChubbyGallon]

FROM THE AGE

Meantime St Kilda have spoken with Collingwood about Nathan Freeman. The Pies want two second-round picks – this year's and next year's - for Freeman and the Magpies' third-round pick. So the effect would be St Kilda gets Freeman and they slide in the draft this year and give up next year's second round. The Saints are not excited by that offer.

The Magpies though are waiting on GWS deciding on their offer on Treloar. The Magpies have offered their first-round picks this year and next for Treloar and want a second-round pick back.

So Collingwood is waiting to know what they have to give up for Treloar, what they get for Freeman and for Paul Seedsman, who is likely to go the Suns but could also yet end up at North … or Adelaide … or Sydney (yes there's a few in the mix and he hasn't said where he wants to go yet). If they get second-round picks for Freeman and Seedsman, as well as one for the Treloar exchange, then in addition to their own second round they will have four second-round picks this year.

Two of those they would probably offer to Brisbane for James Aish but the Lions have said they don't want to trade him at any price and will let him go in the pre-season to Carlton if he insists on leaving.

That then creates tension in other possible deals. Brisbane want to trade in David Astbury from Richmond and Tom Bell from Carlton. One possibility is Bell could be done for a future pick, probably a second round.

AND THERE IS MORE


Meanwhile back to Collingwood. The Magpies will probably decide on Thursday if they want to pursue Jeremy Howe. Once they make a decision, Howe will decide whether he wants to go to North, Gold Coast or Collingwood.

If it is North it would probably be for a second-round pick; if it is Gold Coast there might be a shuffle of early picks. If it is Collingwood it could be Ben Kennedy and a third-round pick.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/tradin...big-domino-20151014-gk8v79.html#ixzz3oZ3IFcjR

 

[CasuallyDressed]

lol, my mum barracks for Collingwood. Don't say I didn't warn you, has a heart the size of a pea.

Being forced to play for Brisbane will do that to you.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

I got banned from the draft forum Aish thread for having a crack at the desperate blues supporters who are revelling in the glee they may get Aish in pSD.

Put that pick up and basically told them all they will be getting in 2016 is another spoon to add to the collection 1 for the whole family!

Love it - well done

 

[MooreTreloar]

So do we think today is the day we'll see our first trade done?

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Ok cheers

I find knightmare really good in this area, he has info on riolli there to to almanac thread

 

[Pedro]

lol, my mum barracks for Collingwood. Don't say I didn't warn you, has a heart the size of a pea.

He had a pretty good debut year. How much of this apparent pea-heartedness is due to the fact that he checked out mentally a long time ago do you think? He's been under the pump all year really about his future. Must have had some effect on him.

 

[BPikkers]

James Aish is Jack Watts Mark II, carefull what you wish for. Not sure if it is out of spite or you are serious.

Ok so a 3rd rounder should do it then?

 

[76woodenspooners]

I have never and will never be one of those "I have a source" bs artists. BUT, I heard this so I'm telling you guys just to pass the time. I was informed last week that there was some seriously funny business going on at Adelaide in an attempt to get Danger to stay. Geelong got wind of this (as they would of course, as Danger wanted to go there), and got up to even funnier business in order to keep him happy.

It'd be pretty shocking if Adelaide got up to those sort of shenanigans after what went down over the Kirt Tippett affair.

 

[MagpieJoel]

There is some news! He entered the world just before 9am! Woohoo!

I am so delirious!

Congrats! My second is now overdue by a couple of days, a girl this time.

 

[Babylove]

FROM THE AGE

Meantime St Kilda have spoken with Collingwood about Nathan Freeman. The Pies want two second-round picks – this year's and next year's - for Freeman and the Magpies' third-round pick. So the effect would be St Kilda gets Freeman and they slide in the draft this year and give up next year's second round. The Saints are not excited by that offer.

The Magpies though are waiting on GWS deciding on their offer on Treloar. The Magpies have offered their first-round picks this year and next for Treloar and want a second-round pick back.

So Collingwood is waiting to know what they have to give up for Treloar, what they get for Freeman and for Paul Seedsman, who is likely to go the Suns but could also yet end up at North … or Adelaide … or Sydney (yes there's a few in the mix and he hasn't said where he wants to go yet). If they get second-round picks for Freeman and Seedsman, as well as one for the Treloar exchange, then in addition to their own second round they will have four second-round picks this year.

Two of those they would probably offer to Brisbane for James Aish but the Lions have said they don't want to trade him at any price and will let him go in the pre-season to Carlton if he insists on leaving.

That then creates tension in other possible deals. Brisbane want to trade in David Astbury from Richmond and Tom Bell from Carlton. One possibility is Bell could be done for a future pick, probably a second round.

AND THERE IS MORE


Meanwhile back to Collingwood. The Magpies will probably decide on Thursday if they want to pursue Jeremy Howe. Once they make a decision, Howe will decide whether he wants to go to North, Gold Coast or Collingwood.

If it is North it would probably be for a second-round pick; if it is Gold Coast there might be a shuffle of early picks. If it is Collingwood it could be Ben Kennedy and a third-round pick.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/tradin...big-domino-20151014-gk8v79.html#ixzz3oZ3IFcjR

Thanks for posting. So according to The Age we are going to use our second round pick twice ( the Freeman and Howe deals?)

 

[MagpieJoel]

What's the go with Crows and Seedsman, plenty of clubs into him so surely we'll get a good deal for him.

Seed + Pick 26 to Crows for Pick 13

Then 13 to Lions for Aish

Think they would prefer a player in the deal.

 

[76woodenspooners]

Thanks for posting. So according to The Age we are going to use our second round pick twice ( the Freeman and Howe deals?)

The Freeman deal would use our third round pick

 

[Babylove]

The Freeman deal would use our third round pick

Whoops I meant to say third round (I'm tired sorry) as the article also says BenKen and our third round for Howe.

 

[76woodenspooners]

We must have had a bit of a war chest ...

Looking at the players who have left / are leaving: Dwyer, Young, Karnezis, Freeman, Seedsman, Kennedy. Thomas and Keeffe going onto rookie contracts.

None of those players word have been on big coin ... Maybe Young would have been on a bit.

Then we're talking about replacing them with Treloar, Aish, Howe ... A new contract for Scharenberg

 

[Schraderbrau]

There is some news! He entered the world just before 9am! Woohoo!

I am so delirious!

offtopic ban imo

 

[Matt_352]

Kenno and 44 for Howe

 

[Unknown Identity]

Has Howe actually chosen the pies or LIKELY to choose pies?

Chose us last night

 

[joff]

There is some news! He entered the world just before 9am! Woohoo!

I am so delirious!

Excellent news congrats to your family unplugged

 

[Matt_352]

Chose us last night

Yeah i thought so conflicting media meatheads

 

[Matt_352]

There is some news! He entered the world just before 9am! Woohoo!

I am so delirious!

Congratulations

 

[ottoman]

Congrats unplugged. Hopefully in future years you can tell your son that he entered into the world amidst the famous trade period which netted Collingwood multiple premierships.

 

[loki04]

We must have had a bit of a war chest ...

Looking at the players who have left / are leaving: Dwyer, Young, Karnezis, Freeman, Seedsman, Kennedy. Thomas and Keeffe going onto rookie contracts.

None of those players word have been on big coin ... Maybe Young would have been on a bit.

Then we're talking about replacing them with Treloar, Aish, Howe ... A new contract for Scharenberg

Also extended Pendles contract by 4 years, fair chance it was a decent offer to him.

 

[MAGPIE2013]

So how many pages are we gonna smash out today lads? I am putting it at 70 if the treloar trade gets done