List Mgmt. 2015 LIST Discussion - trades, free agency etc

[Dramoth]

Gee I wish you were the Blues and I was the Tiges list manager.
My simple response would be:

Ok then, see ya !!!
We'll just have a crack next year when he is a free agent.

To the draft we go with 12 and 19.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

And if I was Carlton's list manager, before you hit the door, I would be on the phone to the AFL's integrity commission to lay a complaint against Bitchmond for tapping up a contracted player halfway through his contract. That should see you banned from the first round unless you play nicely... now... **** off!

 

[The Facepainter]

With Kerridge and the Giant 4 coming in we will need to move 206 on simply based on numbers

OUT, Judd Carrotts Ellard Henderson Bell Yarran Giles Watson
IN, Kerridge Plowman Phillips Lamb Sumner

This only leaves 3 spots so add Weitering and SOSOS and I think 206 and one other will go and I think that's why Menz has been mentioned.

Outcome is 5 picks in ND or 4 and 1 PSD.

ROOKIE JONES

 

[We want Moore]

Source?

A journo from Adelaide... But to be fair Journos often get it wrong.

I hope for your sake it's not legit.. Because that's just a terrible deal for Menzel. Yes he is inconsistent & yes he has poor work ethic but still a terrible deal.

Must be more to it if that deal goes through

 

[TheCoach16]

And if I was Carlton's list manager, before you hit the door, I would be on the phone to the AFL's integrity commission to lay a complaint against Bitchmond for tapping up a contracted player halfway through his contract. That should see you banned from the first round unless you play nicely... now... **** off!

Yeah! **** off!!!

 

[The Facepainter]

Maybe we can walk Warnock to the PSD???

Walk him anywhere

 

[TheHunterCripps]

If we are going to trade Menz, why be limited by the SA 'home' factor with a contracted player? Just cutting off our noses... 10 clubs would give us a first rounder for him. If he doesn't want to go then he stays. HE'S CONTRACTED!!!

 

[TheCoach16]

If we are going to trade Menz, why be limited by the SA 'home' factor with a contracted player? Just cutting off our noses... 10 clubs would give us a first rounder for him. If he doesn't want to go then he stays. HE'S CONTRACTED!!!

OR, We stop this madness immediately, get him right, get him motivated and watch him terrorise opposition back lines for the next 8 years.

 

[Dramoth]

OR, We stop this madness immediately, get him right, get him motivated and watch him terrorise opposition back lines for the next 8 years.

that would be my preferred option as well!

 

[Robco]

Walk him anywhere

Not sure his aerobic capacity is big enough for that

 

[rampar]

Seems to be a lot of talented players who can't handle losing and don't put in when the chips are down.

 

[blueblooded]

You watch Menz dominate in Adelaide and yarran dominate at Richmond it's the Carlton way, there better be some grand plan with this and we land Tomlinson and plowman in this trade period In the event we lose Yarran and Menzel or I will riot!! To think we shopped Levi as well! Not liking what I'm hearing here, Kerridge and 28 in a dud of a draft for Menzel is a disgrace of a trade and if we doesn't land us Tomlinson it is a disaster

 

[TheCoach16]

that would be my preferred option as well!

I know if you want a guarantee, you should buy a toaster, but it's quite possible this kid could play a part in our next premiership. Isn't that the type of player we want? He's one less we need to find...

 

[TheCoach16]

You watch Menz dominate in Adelaide and yarran dominate at Richmond it's the Carlton way, there better be some grand plan with this and we land Tomlinson and plowman in this trade period In the event we lose Yarran and Menzel or I will riot!! To think we shopped Levi as well! Not liking what I'm hearing here, Kerridge and 28 in a dud of a draft for Menzel is a disgrace of a trade and if we doesn't land us Tomlinson it is a disaster

I'm sorry I can't "like" this more than once. 1000 times like. Well said.

 

[kingkingston]

You watch Menz dominate in Adelaide and yarran dominate at Richmond it's the Carlton way, there better be some grand plan with this and we land Tomlinson and plowman in this trade period In the event we lose Yarran and Menzel or I will riot!! To think we shopped Levi as well! Not liking what I'm hearing here, Kerridge and 28 in a dud of a draft for Menzel is a disgrace of a trade and if we doesn't land us Tomlinson it is a disaster

no one knows how good the draft will be for another 5-6 years

 

[mrbluey]

The club has turned into a basket case, seriously in the last few years we have lost quality players and brought in a bunch of vfl amatures.

One really has to question the direction of the club cos clearly at the moment its going backwards 10 years.

 

[koutamarto]

This obsession with GWS players worries me a bit.
Jaksch and Whiley still unknown.


Now all the talk of trading for 4 of them this year.
I just hope its not the same bloke overrating the same blokes he overrated in their draft year.
Not saying it is, I just worry this could b the case!

 

[IronMan29]

If you think you are going to get an end of 1st round pick for him next year then you are delusional.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

If im delusional, maybe I am secretly a Richmond Supporter

 

[TeeJay Blue]

Seems to be a lot of talented players who can't handle losing and don't put in when the chips are down.

Yes.

And many Carlton supporters continuously criticise those with care, heart and passion just because they are not good enough in terms of their skill level. If only they knew where to begin.

 

[The Facepainter]

Not sure his aerobic capacity is big enough for that

Just hope the door opening isn't short

 

[The Facepainter]

You watch Menz dominate in Adelaide and yarran dominate at Richmond it's the Carlton way, there better be some grand plan with this and we land Tomlinson and plowman in this trade period In the event we lose Yarran and Menzel or I will riot!! To think we shopped Levi as well! Not liking what I'm hearing here, Kerridge and 28 in a dud of a draft for Menzel is a disgrace of a trade and if we doesn't land us Tomlinson it is a disaster

Love your passion but I think we need to wait 3 years to see how our rebuild has gone, let's face it we are with now 18th

 

[TeeJay Blue]

This obsession with GWS players worries me a bit.
Jaksch and Whiley still unknown.


Now all the talk of trading for 4 of them this year.
I just hope its not the same bloke overrating the same blokes he overrated in their draft year.
Not saying it is, I just worry this could b the case!

Who's to say that fringe player at one club can't be a best-22 player for another? While I'm skeptical about the GWS players as much as you are, I wouldn't be too quick to judge them.

 

[TheCoach16]

If im delusional, maybe I am secretly a Richmond Supporter

You have to dumb it down for them Ironman... HE'S ... SAYING... YOU... RICHMOND GUYS... ARE... DEL USION AL... It means you have a tenuous grasp on reality... Now be a lamb and run along.

 

[ShanDog]

The club has turned into a basket case, seriously in the last few years we have lost quality players and brought in a bunch of vfl amatures.

One really has to question the direction of the club cos clearly at the moment its going backwards 10 years.

This is based on.... trades that haven't happened yet?

 

[ferrisb]

IF the Menzel trade goes through as mooted, I'm expecting Macca/bioglan to update the injury list with

Carlton (pride) 1-2 weeks

 

[Stiffler's Dad]

Carlton have apparently already turned down pick 19 from Bitchmond.

I LOVE THIS!