Traded Chris Yarran [to Richmond for Pick 19]

[Moshie The Mook]

Looks like Sausage is going to trade Menzel who wants to stay at carlton, and keep Yarran who doesn't want to stay at carlton.

 

[Heisenberg_]

examples of him being incompetent besides not doing a trade that you like in the Yarran trade?

Troy Menzel

 

[Tiger71]

Even better when he leaves as FA and they don't get close to pick 19 for him.

And with that pick 19 its a dead set gun and in 2017 both yarran and that player are ripping it up, winning games while the blues still struggle to kick more then 4 goals a game.

 

[SexyBlueGirl]

Even better when he leaves as FA and they don't get close to pick 19 for him.

Losing a few draft slots in the 20s and 30s on the backend is nothing, at least a strong precedent would have been set.

 

[SexyBlueGirl]

And with that pick 19 its a dead set gun and in 2017 both yarran and that player are ripping it up, winning games while the blues still struggle to kick more then 4 goals a game.

Look at all the past pick 19s. would you take them or Yarran?

 

[Bobblefighter]

Look at all the past pick 19s. would you take them or Yarran?

Probably take 19 if we didn't want an experienced player. That's the funny thing, pick 19 is better for you than for us, and Yarran is better for us than you. I'm loving that all clubs get to see you blockheaded flogs as you truly are.

 

[Tiger71]

Look at all the past pick 19s. would you take them or Yarran?

Again you show how little you know about the value of pick 19. With the bidding on academy kids, 4 of them will be used in the first round. So pick 19 will give us a pick 15 quality kid, thats another Vlaustin another Ellis etc.

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Look at all the past pick 19s. would you take them or Yarran?

The only one he has meaningfully more value of in the past 5 years is Boekhurst...


Acres and Kennedy are still young and developing

Smith is so far in front it isn't funny.

 

[hench]

yes is andy collins? or what about jacobs? josh kennedy? eddie betts? mitch robinson? garlett? have i missed anyone?

Bell?

 

[TiggerMan22]

Look at all the past pick 19s. would you take them or Yarran?

Fyfe went at #20.

 

[SexyBlueGirl]

Again you show how little you know about the value of pick 19. With the bidding on academy kids, 4 of them will be used in the first round. So pick 19 will give us a pick 15 quality kid, thats another Vlaustin another Ellis etc.

If it's so valuable, you keep it and give us 12. Yarran AND a valuable pick. You should be grateful.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

You say as you trade Menzel to Adelaide, Bell to Brisbane, Henderson to Geelong. Nice drawn line. Lmao.

On one hand we are okay with getting rid of players that won't play for the jumper, but circumstances matter.

Menzel was a little half hearted at times but hasn't actively sought a trade and that trade still may not get done.

Henderson checked out half way through the season but he was out of contract and Geelong bent over backwards to accommodate our asking price immediately. Very respectful transaction between the two clubs and as annoyed as we were that Hendo checked out early, at least he was diplomatic towards his own form and the club in general. No announcing a departure on social media while contracted. No threats of sitting out the year.

Bell goes with our blessing because he has already lost his mother and his dad is gravely ill. People should just stop using him to win internet arguments. It's disrespectful and Lions and Carlton struck a very respectful deal to help the guy out.

Yarran however, was approached with a season and a half left on his contract and turned off as a result, effectively lowering his value and then nominated only one club. Who knows how he plays out the season if he didn't have Richmond on his mind. He played it out last year so it's not as though this is a long festering thing. Different circumstances to all of the others.

 

[SexyBlueGirl]

Fyfe went at #20.

Then at 19 I'm sure you'll find an even better player. Happy Dayz.

 

[Bobblefighter]

If it's so valuable, you keep it and give us 12. Yarran AND a valuable pick. You should be grateful.

oh wow, delete this before people find out how stupid you really are.

 

[TiggerMan22]

On one hand we are okay with getting rid of players that won't play for the jumper, but circumstances matter.

Menzel was a little half hearted at times but hasn't actively sought a trade and that trade still may not get done.

Henderson checked out half way through the season but he was out of contract and Geelong bent over backwards to accommodate our asking price immediately. Very respectful transaction between the two clubs and as annoyed as we were that Hendo checked out early, at least he was diplomatic towards his own form and the club in general. No announcing a departure on social media while contracted. No threats of sitting out the year.

Bell goes with our blessing because he has already lost his mother and his dad is gravely ill. People should just stop using him to win internet arguments. It's disrespectful and Lions and Carlton struck a very respectful deal to help the guy out.

Yarran however, was approached with a season and a half left on his contract and turned off as a result, effectively lowering his value and then nominated only one club. Who knows how he plays out the season if he didn't have Richmond on his mind. He played it out last year so it's not as though this is a long festering thing. Different circumstances to all of the others.

Thats not a drawn line then. Hahaha.

 

[TiggerMan22]

Then at 19 I'm sure you'll find an even better player. Happy Dayz.

But we wont have #19.
I'm sure you guys will be able to pick up the next Bootsma with your elite drafting.

 

[Saint]

They probably just want it done so they want to move on to other targets while the trade period is still open.

They'd be better off going and working on those trades and let Carlton come back when they're ready to take the offer. You could probably do better than Yarran with pick 19, Carlton just think Richmond will fold.

 

[Capitano_Cotch]

Are they seriously considering trading Menzel?

That's ridiculous...

 

[Theo23]

There's no way this ends well for Carlton. They either take pick 19 and draft another Boekhorst or he quits footy for a year because he refuses to play for that rabble.

 

[TiggerMan22]

Are they seriously considering trading Menzel?

That's ridiculous...

An interesting strategy to trade anyone who can kick a goal in the team.
They will revolutionize the game by being the first club to play without a forward line.

 

[Capitano_Cotch]

An interesting strategy to trade anyone who can kick a goal in the team.
They will revolutionize the game by being the first club to play without a forward line.

What a joke.
I rate Menzel, he's only young too.
Pick 11 wasn't he?

What are they thinking?

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Okay so this is my understanding right.

Richmond convince Yarran at the start of the year they love him and want him at Richmond.
Yarran proceeds to not give a ****, not try, put in a shit effort all year, because hey, i'm going to Richmond.
Richmond confirm - "yep Yarran we love you, we think you're worth a late first round pick" (This is quoted by Richmond personnel)
Suddenly Richmond can't get a deal done, try to offer pick 19 (not a first round).
Richmond - still love ya yaz, you're amazing.
Richmond - you should leak to the media that you wont play in 2016 if you don't get traded.
Yarran - won't play in 2016 because i'm a sook.
Richmond - Lobbe is worth pick 12, hold on here, is Yarran really as good as you've told him all year?

You're obviously fine with parting with #12. You've said he's worth a pick in the late first round. You've told Yarran you want him. Why is Carlton the bad guy for not trading a contracted player for below his worth.

If Yarran sits out next year, hello suing Yarran for his contract, hello investigating Richmond for draft/trade tampering, approaching players before Trade Period, hello Yarran becoming incredibly unfit on his year off. And if he tries to train with Richmond - hello suing Richmond for breaching his contract.

 

[SickQwon]

Richmond just tried to offload pick 12 for Lobbe and got rejected suggesting they are open to trading pick 12. Richmond really hurt themselves in this scenario.
It's looking more & more likely they will fold and trade pick 12 for Yarran, given they were going to trade that pick anyway.

Also, trade value =/= player value, you dipshits.

 

[Tiger71]

Okay so this is my understanding right.

Richmond convince Yarran at the start of the year they love him and want him at Richmond.
Yarran proceeds to not give a ****, not try, put in a shit effort all year, because hey, i'm going to Richmond.
Richmond confirm - "yep Yarran we love you, we think you're worth a late first round pick" (This is quoted by Richmond personnel)
Suddenly Richmond can't get a deal done, try to offer pick 19 (not a first round).
Richmond - still love ya yaz, you're amazing.
Richmond - you should leak to the media that you wont play in 2016 if you don't get traded.
Yarran - won't play in 2016 because i'm a sook.
Richmond - Lobbe is worth pick 12, hold on here, is Yarran really as good as you've told him all year?

You're obviously fine with parting with #12. You've said he's worth a pick in the late first round. You've told Yarran you want him. Why is Carlton the bad guy for not trading a contracted player for below his worth.

If Yarran sits out next year, hello suing Yarran for his contract, hello investigating Richmond for draft/trade tampering, approaching players before Trade Period, hello Yarran becoming incredibly unfit on his year off. And if he tries to train with Richmond - hello suing Richmond for breaching his contract.

ONLY problem with your melt is that Pick 19 is a ROUND ONE pick. Its a round one compo pick.

Nice fantasy though. I have to admit the veal was poor but the comedy was B plus.

 

[Tiger71]

Richmond just tried to offload pick 12 for Lobbe and got rejected suggesting they are open to trading pick 12. Richmond really hurt themselves in this scenario.
It's looking more & more likely they will fold and trade pick 12 for Yarran, given they were going to trade that pick anyway.

Also, trade value =/= player value, you dipshits.

Can you link any proof that we offered 12 from either club, or even a statement from either club ? Hold on, your a blue, you probably believe what you read o a tweet or nathan browns word on trade raido is spot on lol