List Mgmt. Trade/Draft SuperMegaUltraThread - 2016 edition?

[Godfather32]

You missed the step where he came to the club with what he was being offered and he was told in the nicest terms possible we wouldn't go close to matching the offer.

And rightly so, you don't pay a third ruckman what he's making at Sydney

 

[new breed]

And rightly so, you don't pay a third ruckman what he's making at Sydney

Sincair is only getting 250k at Sydney double then his WCE contract .......wasn't on much after being elevated from the rookie list which was less then $100k

 

[Dark Sharks]

Bit painful watching Duggan struggle through this year arguably getting wose and worse whilst other rookies are eclipsing his output.

Averaging 13 touches a game, Blakely is averaging 20, Weller 14 plus 9 goals.

Meanwhile Partington is playing WAFL reserves

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

Blakley and Weller are playing key midfield roles on ball in freo pathetic team . Both have also padded their stats nicely against Essendon and Brisbane.
Weller looks good but nice pick up . Blakley is a hard nose ball winner but disposal is meh .

 

[Godfather32]

Sincair is only getting 250k at Sydney double then his WCE contract .......wasn't on much after being elevated from the rookie list which was less then $100k

Are you sure, I was under the impression he was on 1.5 Million over 4 years

 

[frenchconnection]

You don't have to be a big body if you have great intent. Libba jr is a great clearance player and hes tiny. Similarly Hawks midfield doesn't have too many tall players either.

I think the main thing is to have the mix right - West Coast have too many of the same.

 

[new breed]

Are you sure, I was under the impression he was on 1.5 Million over 4 years

Thats what was reported but Sinclair was saying he wishes he was getting that when asked , he's actually getting double what he was at WCE which is pretty good . I contacted West Coast after that trade and the loss of Rosa ... West Coast replied and acknowledged they couldn't stand in the way of Sinclair going .

Sinclair on radio a few days later was saying he asked WCE to extend his contract beyond 2016 but West Coast couldn't guarrentee a contract so Sinkers had no choice but he has doubled his income but the $ 400k Sinkers was saying was greatly exagerated and he would be living with a couple of other players in a share house ...

 

[Godfather32]

Thats what was reported but Sinclair was saying he wishes he was getting that when asked , he's actually getting double what he was at WCE which is pretty good . I contacted West Coast after that trade and the loss of Rosa ... West Coast replied and acknowledged they couldn't stand in the way of Sinclair going .

Sinclair on radio a few days later was saying he asked WCE to extend his contract beyond 2016 but West Coast couldn't guarrentee a contract so Sinkers had no choice but he has doubled his income but the $ 400k Sinkers was saying was greatly exagerated and he would be living with a couple of other players in a share house ...

Still, when you take into account what the salary cap is and what our top players are likely making paying $250K for someone to sit in the WAFL is a lot of money.

 

[kane249]

Was thinking today just how much we've missed Embley since he retired. Line breaking wingman, good over head, loved a goal and a booming long kick.

Had an unfair reputation as a downhill skier but some of his best performances were in close wins on the road.

 

[SpaceClef]

Bit painful watching Duggan struggle through this year arguably getting wose and worse whilst other rookies are eclipsing his output.

Averaging 13 touches a game, Blakely is averaging 20, Weller 14 plus 9 goals.

Meanwhile Partington is playing WAFL reserves

Though to be fair if Duggan had converted his shots on goal he'd suddenly be 13 plus 8 goals

 

[Godfather32]

Was thinking today just how much we've missed Embley since he retired. Line breaking wingman, good over head, loved a goal and a booming long kick.

Had an unfair reputation as a downhill skier but some of his best performances were in close wins on the road.

That bloody dribble kick though....

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Cam Ellis Yolmen anyone?
Not the best disposal but a big body and would be cheap. Hasn't had a game for the Crows all year and looks unlikely anytime soon.

 

[kane249]

That bloody dribble kick though....

O Noez, lets judge a player on one moment from his career

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Cam Ellis Yolmen anyone?
Not the best disposal but a big body and would be cheap. Hasn't had a game for the Crows all year and looks unlikely anytime soon.

Have enough B-C graders in the middle, pass.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Have enough B-C graders in the middle, pass.

We're ****ed aren't we

 

[avishka5]

O Noez, lets judge a player on one moment from his career

more like that 70m bomb for goal in the 2012 EF

 

[avishka5]

the lack of quality inside mids from WA in recent years is also working against us. Swallow and O'Meara have massive question marks over them, leaving Mitchell and coniglio as the only gun mids from WA out of contract in the next few years.

 

[kane249]

more like that 70m bomb for goal in the 2012 EF

 

[avishka5]

that was J*zz in ma pants worthy.

 

[WCE_phil]

Am i the only one who doesn't rate tom mitchell? As far as im concerned his disposal is shithouse.

 

[kane249]

Am i the only one who doesn't rate tom mitchell? As far as im concerned his disposal is shithouse.

You aren't alone

Good extractor, but like you said disposal isn't flash.

 

[Dark Sharks]

Blakley and Weller are playing key midfield roles on ball in freo pathetic team . Both have also padded their stats nicely against Essendon and Brisbane.
Weller looks good but nice pick up . Blakley is a hard nose ball winner but disposal is meh .

And? You'd think if anything, Duggan has had it easier, playing in every game from last years grand final team. Compared to a basket case that is fremantle.

He's had plenty of opportunities to "pad his stats" against shit teams every time we flat track it up.

Agreed Weller looks good. Played forward last week and dominated. We could use his zip right about now.

 

[avishka5]

And? You'd think if anything, Duggan has had it easier, playing in every game from last years grand final team. Compared to a basket case that is fremantle.

He's had plenty of opportunities to "pad his stats" against shit teams every time we flat track it up.

Agreed Weller looks good. Played forward last week and dominated. We could use his zip right about now.

duggan has inside capabilities and has looked better when pushed on ball. However, simmo hasnt pushed him on ball that frequently. I prefer the duggan pick over weller. we already have too many wingers.

 

[AsterixTheGaul]

Was thinking today just how much we've missed Embley since he retired. Line breaking wingman, good over head, loved a goal and a booming long kick.

Had an unfair reputation as a downhill skier but some of his best performances were in close wins on the road.

Correction - we missed Embley before he retired. He was well short of his best in his last season. Just ask Dale Thomas.

 

[wraglesweb]

And? You'd think if anything, Duggan has had it easier, playing in every game from last years grand final team. Compared to a basket case that is fremantle.

He's had plenty of opportunities to "pad his stats" against shit teams every time we flat track it up.

Agreed Weller looks good. Played forward last week and dominated. We could use his zip right about now.

Duggan is nearly a year younger than Weller too. Weller looks the goods though