MVP BigFooty West Coast Player of the Year 2016 - Results Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Shuey - 2016 Brownlow winner?


Using the highly scientific formulae of...

Win by 60 or more - All votes to the winning team
Win by 30 to 60 - Votes 3 and 2 to the winning team
Win by 1 to 30 - Votes 3 and 1 to the winning team

Shuey will finish with 21 votes in the Brownlow if the umpires agree with our board. Probably not enough to win?
 
fidstar said:
Shuey - 2016 Brownlow winner?


Using the highly scientific formulae of...

Win by 60 or more - All votes to the winning team
Win by 30 to 60 - Votes 3 and 2 to the winning team
Win by 1 to 30 - Votes 3 and 1 to the winning team

Shuey will finish with 21 votes in the Brownlow if the umpires agree with our board. Probably not enough to win?
Click to expand...
Probably not. Dangerfield will be like Fyfe last year and have 30+ votes by round 20.
 
Nic Naitanui

462820.jpg


Total Votes - 24.79

Ranking - 5th

Games played - 15

Votes per game ranking - 3rd

I'll remember Nic Nat season for two things and they happened within a week of each other. Firstly making me believe that maybe we could win a premiership (kicking the winning goal against GWS) and secondly ending any chance of us winning a premiership (when he did his knee against the Hawks).

He started the season well, but caught fire between Round 5 and 12. This hot streak included his best performance of the season in Round 6 against Collingwood which was highlighted by his 8 clearances. By Round 12 his Achilles injury had flared up to a point where he needed to get surgery. At that point of the season he was only 0.70 votes behind first on the leaderboard.

After missing 6 games and having a "warm up game" against Freo he exploded against GWS. Only an 374 possession game from Super Shuey kept him from BOG in the game. And for my only Youtube clip in this countdown...



Round....Votes
1........3.91 (2nd best)
2........0.18
3........0.51
4........0.16
5........2.34 (3rd best)
6........4.47 (BOG)
7........1.17 (5th best)
8........2.67 (2nd best)
9........2.47 (3rd best)
10......1.61 (5th best)
11......No votes
12......1.32 (5th best)
13.......DNP
15.......DNP
16.......DNP
17.......DNP
18.......DNP
19.......DNP
20.......No votes
21.......3.92 (2nd best)
22.......0.07
23.......DNP
EF........DNP

Total.......24.79

Big Footy Users with the biggest crush - eaglespremiers (43 votes) Avalor (39 votes) bUCKET__ (31 votes) Jandamarra (31 votes) Adzam (28 votes) Bleedblueandgold (28 votes) Here2tellyouwhy (28 votes) squashface (28 votes)
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

I'll never forget that GWS goal. I was sitting pretty close to it all on the outer wing and have never been surrounded by that many west coast fans. I knew he had kicked it but had no idea the siren had gone over all the noise and excitement. Such a great night
 
Pretty astonishing effort from Nic to place fifth when he missed that many games. Hard to argue against him being our most important player
 
fidstar said:
Shuey - 2016 Brownlow winner?


Using the highly scientific formulae of...

Win by 60 or more - All votes to the winning team
Win by 30 to 60 - Votes 3 and 2 to the winning team
Win by 1 to 30 - Votes 3 and 1 to the winning team

Shuey will finish with 21 votes in the Brownlow if the umpires agree with our board. Probably not enough to win?
Click to expand...

Round by round voting...

Round....Votes
3............2
4............3
6............1
8............3
10..........2
14..........1
15..........1
16..........3
18..........1
20..........1
21..........3
Total......21
 
Matt Priddis


469123.jpg


Total Votes - 25.95

Ranking - 4th

Games played - 22

Votes per game ranking - 6th

Priddis started the season well picking up 2 Top 3 votes in the first 3 rounds before missing a game due to injury. The week off didn't do him much good as he struggled over the next several weeks. Really found his mojo between rounds 11 and 22 where he constantly polled votes week after week. This stretch included his two BOGs for the season. A 27 possession, 12 tackle, 9 clearance effort against the Western Bulldogs in Round 11 and a 24 possession, 1 goal, 15 tackle, 7 clearance effort against Melbourne in Round 18.



Round....Votes
1........3.35 (3rd best)
2........No votes
3........2.88 (3rd best)
4........DNP
5........0.19
6........No votes
7........No votes
8........0.06
9........1.50 (4th best)
10......No votes
11......3.53 (BOG)
12......2.32 (3rd best)
13.......No votes
15.......0.24
16.......0.74 (6th best)
17.......No votes
18.......4.10 (BOG)
19.......0.54
20.......1.87 (4th best)
21.......0.92 (5th best)
22.......2.98 (3rd best)
23.......0.52
EF........0.21

Total.......25.95

Big Footy Users with the biggest crush - donpyke92 (45 votes) RookiePick (38 votes) DickDunn (33 votes) FiveStrings (30 votes) Sw3Et (30 votes) Avalor (29 votes)
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Jeremy McGovern

457156.jpg


Total Votes - 32.63

Ranking - 3rd

Games played - 22

Votes per game ranking - 4th

It's hard to believe that at the start of the season McGovern had played a grand total of 33 games. By the end of the game he had just past 50 games. Is it the best 50 games by a WCE key defender? Probably...

He finished third this season in the votes, well clear of 4th (almost 7 votes clear).

After a slow start in the first 3 rounds, just took off. His run from Round 12 to 17 was his peak finishing in our top 2 players in 4 of the 5 games. And it's not like he slowed down after that, finishing in our top 4 players in 3 of the next 5 games.

His best performance of the season came in Round 17 against Carlton where he had 18 possessions and 8 marks in a best on ground performance. His other BOG came in Round 5 where he had 23 possessions and 9 marks against Sydney.

Unfortunately he was one of guys that killed it in the regular season and then didn't turn up in our final. It's hard to pick on a guy with only 50 games experience, but he just seems so dependable that it was weird for him to be a non-factor.

Round....Votes
1........No votes
2........0.35
3........No votes
4........0.27 (6th best)
5........4.32 (BOG)
6........0.84 (5th best)
7........3.03 (2nd best)
8........0.75
9........No votes
10......No votes
11......DNP
12......2.93 (2nd best)
13.......0.31
15.......3.27 (2nd best)
16.......3.95 (2nd best)
17.......4.92 (BOG)
18.......2.15 (4th best)
19.......0.40
20.......2.20 (3rd best)
21.......No votes
22.......2.80 (4th best)
23.......0.16
EF........No votes

Total.......32.63

Big Footy Users with the biggest crush - Bleedblueandgold (44 votes) Godfather32 (41 votes) MrKK (38 votes) donpyke92 (36 votes) Dark Sharks (35 votes)
 
Last edited:
fidstar said:
Unfortunately he was one of guys that killed it in the regular season and then didn't turn up in our final. It's hard to pick on a guy with only 50 games experience, but he just seems so dependable that it was weird for him to be a non-factor.
Click to expand...
That's a bit rough, credit to the Doggies who didn't allow him to play loose and cleanup wayward passes.
 
Agent93 said:
That's a bit rough, credit to the Doggies who didn't allow him to play loose and cleanup wayward passes.
Click to expand...

maybe a bit rough. Doggies did well to limit his influence, but every team tried to do the same thing during the year and he still had a big influence in most of those games.
 
Last edited:
fidstar said:
Jeremy McGovern

457156.jpg


Total Votes - 32.63

Ranking - 3rd

Games played - 22

Votes per game ranking - 4th

It's hard to believe that at the start of the season McGovern had played a grand total of 33 games. By the end of the game he had just past 50 games. Is it the best 50 games by a WCE key defender? Probably...

He finished third this season in the votes, well clear of 4th (almost 7 votes clear).

After a slow start in the first 3 rounds, just took off. His run from Round 12 to 17 was his peak finishing in our top 2 players in 4 of the 5 games. And it's not like he slowed down after that, finishing in our top 4 players in each of the next 3 games.

His best performance of the season came in Round 17 against Carlton where he had 18 possessions and 8 marks in a best on ground performance. His other BOG came in Round 5 where he had 23 possessions and 9 marks against Sydney.

Unfortunately he was one of guys that killed it in the regular season and then didn't turn up in our final. It's hard to pick on a guy with only 50 games experience, but he just seems so dependable that it was weird for him to be a non-factor.

Round....Votes
1........No votes
2........0.35
3........No votes
4........0.27 (6th best)
5........4.32 (BOG)
6........0.84 (5th best)
7........3.03 (2nd best)
8........0.75
9........No votes
10......No votes
11......DNP
12......2.93 (2nd best)
13.......0.31
15.......3.27 (2nd best)
16.......3.95 (2nd best)
17.......4.92 (BOG)
18.......2.15 (4th best)
19.......0.40 (3rd best)
20.......2.20 (4th best)
21.......No votes
22.......2.80 (4th best)
23.......0.16
EF........No votes

Total.......32.63

Big Footy Users with the biggest crush - Bleedblueandgold (44 votes) Godfather32 (41 votes) MrKK (38 votes) donpyke92 (36 votes) Dark Sharks (35 votes)
Click to expand...

Round 19... 0.40 votes as 3rd best? That for real?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

squashface
MVP BigFooty West Coast Eagles Player of the Year 2023 - Results Thread
5 6 7 8 9
Replies
209
Views
10K
squashface
squashface
Into The Black
West Coast
2
Replies
28
Views
2K
woosha24
woosha24
squashface
  • Poll
MVP BigFooty West Coast Eagles Player of the Year 2022 - Results Thread
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
173
Views
11K
LittleFires
LittleFires
Reminiscence
  • Locked
Game Day Round 7, 2024: West Coast vs Gold Coast
48 49 50 51 52
Replies
1K
Views
19K
HoneyBadger35
HoneyBadger35
Keys
  • Locked
Game Day Round 6, 2024: West Coast vs Fremantle
40 41 42 43 44
Replies
1K
Views
20K
Keys
Keys
HoneyBadger35
  • Locked
Game Day Round 5, 2024: West Coast vs Richmond
34 35 36 37 38
Replies
941
Views
16K
Wosh
Wosh
TY24
  • Locked
Game Day Round 3, 2024: West Coast vs Western Bulldogs
51 52 53 54 55
Replies
1K
Views
30K
Keys
Keys

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top