Rumour Bluemour Discussion thread - The sequel - I know what SOS did last Sumner

[FlowersByIrene]

If we settle for Gibbs & 24 for Lyons & 13 could this mean that we are any chance to get the GWS group for pick 13 alone ??

If we "settle" for that, Carlton better "settle" for me burning Ikon park down to the ground.

 

[2SOS]

If we "settle" for that, Carlton better "settle" for me burning Ikon park down to the ground.

Wow thats an overreaction

 

[Cripps Nubake]

 

[reg_lower91]

Just a thought:
Barlow to Suns
22 from Suns to us
Tuohy from us to Cats
Kersten from Cats to Freo

 

[Prem17]

That would be an absolute dream of an outcome.

If SOS could pull that off and keep pick #5, he's a miracle man.

I have a feeling that either or both of Kruezer and Rowe could be shipped out now.
With Gibbs gone, it's critical that we keep pick 5. I still think that 13 is too high for the GWS clearance sale, so we need something else.
Now that Mitchell is on the move, maybe we could tempt Sydney into giving us pick 17 but I think we would need to get some 20-odd pics in because we don't have many (if any) players that would interest them.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Only if we can get overs in the other deal, need to look at the whole equation or nett profit in this scenario.

In- GWS 5 (Marchbank, Stewart, Corr, Pickett, Kennedy) & Lyons

Out- Gibbs & pick 13

*Importantly keep pick 5 for a future Gibbs midfield type replacement.

That's an absolutely garbage trade

Would you trade #13, #18 and #13 for those six players? Because that's effectively what you're doing. Worst trade proposal in history. Way to kill the club.

 

[The Facepainter]

So, where are all the people saying Gibbs will never leave and we should stop even mentioning it?

Walking out half way through a contract. Good thing we hold all the cards.

Cannot give up Gibbs + #24 for Lyons + #13. I think we've developed a reputation over the last decade of being idiots and now everyone thinks they can low ball us and get away with it.

Has to be a top 10 pick. If they don't have one, then #13 + a better player than Lyons while we keep #24.

If we trade pick #5 as well our midfield is going to be ****ed for years, but I've already said that quite a few times yesterday.

We'll be getting top 5 picks for the next 3-4 years.

I did, and will admit I was wrong.
Where is the firing squad that I stand in front of?

 

[Faz 2000]

I did, and will admit I was wrong.
Where is the firing squad that I stand in front of?

They requested a trade to Hawthorn.

 

[jd2010]

After 1 day into the trade period? Bit of an overreaction no?

13 and Lyons for Gibbs and our second round pick. That's as embarrassing as it comes.

And don't get me started on handing over McGrath/Ainsworth/Brodie for another KPD

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

I have a feeling that either or both of Kruezer and Rowe could be shipped out now.
With Gibbs gone, it's critical that we keep pick 5. I still think that 13 is too high for the GWS clearance sale, so we need something else.
Now that Mitchell is on the move, maybe we could tempt Sydney into giving us pick 17 but I think we would need to get some 20-odd pics in because we don't have many (if any) players that would interest them.

I don't think its critical at all TBH.

 

[Athomas]

Apparently SOS has laughed at initial trade proposals. Good work SOS.

If we are gonna lose Gibbs, get McGovern into discussions!

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Wow thats an overreaction

A plodder and an 11 pick upgrade for our 2nd best player.

Overreaction? ... God i'm so sick of some of the posters on this board.

 

[Prem17]

I don't think its critical at all TBH.

You also think our midfield for next year is fine.
Enough said......

 

[blueboy25]

Just a thought:
Barlow to Suns
22 from Suns to us
Tuohy from us to Cats
Kersten from Cats to Freo

Suns have already ruled out picking up barlow

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Apparently SOS has laughed at initial trade proposals. Good work SOS.

If we are gonna lose Gibbs, get McGovern into discussions!

Where is that coming from?

 

[bigdog43]

A plodder and an 11 pick upgrade for our 2nd best player.

Overreaction? ... God i'm so sick of some of the posters on this board.

You need a snickers

 

[SolGoodman]

13 and Lyons for Gibbs and our second round pick. That's as embarrassing as it comes.

And don't get me started on handing over McGrath/Ainsworth/Brodie for another KPD

The benefit of losing Gibbs for that pick is that it now looks unlikely we lose pick 5 for the GWS players, so it's not so bad IMO.

 

[Toddski]

Everyone keeps forgetting we have have the upper hand here.

How do these morons get paid to discuss trades?

13 and Lyons? I'd rather Tyrone on 800k a year and piss pick 5 down the sink.

 

[Cripps Nubake]

I have no idea how reliable this twitter account it, so take this as a grain of salt. Says he is employed at Icon Park, so who knows.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

You need a snickers

It's honestly like some people WANT us to finish bottom of the ladder for the next half a decade.

 

[TBellicious]

Are these 5 GWS players that have been rumoured for pick 5 alone?

 

[jd2010]

The benefit of losing Gibbs for that pick is that it now looks unlikely we lose pick 5 for the GWS players, so it's not so bad IMO.

Won't be so bad if that pick doesn't go. But apparently that's as good as gone.

The rejects x4 or x5 from the Giants for the top 5 pick

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

A plodder and an 11 pick upgrade for our 2nd best player.

Overreaction? ... God i'm so sick of some of the posters on this board.

TBF, some of your posts are going way over the top too. People are allowed to disagree with your point of view. If your so frustrated with other posters, then maybe its best you take a few days off to calm yourself down a little instead of throwing such highlighted comments around.

 

[Blue_Fusion]

I did, and will admit I was wrong.
Where is the firing squad that I stand in front of?

That's all good. I'm not interested in calling all those people out and say they know nothing about footy like what was thrown at us for suggesting he may want to leave.

It's just a reminder that anything can happen and when a trade is suggested, people need to be more open minded.

 

[smashbox gill]

Going to be interesting as cats are linked with Delidio & now Tuohy.

and they dont have a 1st rounder to play with.

Have strong info Deledio to cats is in the works as well. Deledio wants a trade there.