Which player has the most trade value in the AFL?

[Pannalstaroz]

Which player would command the most if all players were available?

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Tom lynch Gold Coast
Jesse Hogan
Marcus Bontempelli

Edit

Maybe Fyfe

 

[Melksham2Siposs]

Heeney
Bont
Shiel

 

[Roo Beauty]

Bont
Fyfe
Lynch

 

[Abomination]

Bontempelli and Hogan.

 

[Super Hans]

Lynch, Bontempelli, Cameron.

 

[LP7_]

#TheSpecialOne

MB.

 

[mezaire]

NicNat, Fyfe or Bont, assuming fully fit

 

[DanA]

Has to be a KPF IMO. Hogan stands out as others have mentioned.

 

[nurries]

Has to be a KPF IMO. Hogan stands out as others have mentioned.

Currently you would get more for Fyfe than Hogan

 

[Gumby2Hurley]

Fyfe Lyf

 

[Cobbler]

Which player would command the most if all players were available?

Solid question. Lot's of unknowns like who is chasing who etc.

Gold Coast could chase Fyfe for 3 picks inside the top 10 for example, but if Essendon chased him we'd get pick 1 and a future first.

All variables aside.

I'd go as my top 5 in order:

Fyfe - His best is scary good. Still young and could easily play another 150+ games.

Bontempelli - Just a jet and is only second because I'm one eyed and just have to put Fyfe first. COuld still give a team 200+ games and the upside is scarier then Fyfe.

Hogan - Young power forward. Really disappointed to hear him stay with Melbourne, but would still give a team 200+ games and should easily average over 50 goals a season for the next decade.

Josh Kelly - Not an overly recognisable name, but a former pick 2 and about to hit the next level. If he was selling stock I'd be buying up everything I could. Absolute gun and IMO will easily take over Coniglio as GWS's best midfielder.

Peter Wright - Just a tall gun who is also about to enter the next level. Could still give a team 200+ games and will feature heavily in coming years.

I could've played it safe with blokes like Dangerfield, Martin, Franklin, but these are the guys who are about to go next level and if they were on the open market would cost a bundle to remove.

 

[teddies]

Sam Mitchell

 

[Thetrader15]

Anyone who plays for carlton. Gibbs probably at the top of the heap

 

[Milk Steak]

Levi Greenwood

 

[HairyO]

Sam Mitchell

Maybe if he had the Brownlow...

 

[doona]

Would say O'Meara with what the Hawks are giving up.

 

[teddies]

Maybe if he had the Brownlow...

might take him up to pick 60ish

 

[RedWhite&Blue]

Callan Ward

 

[BLERN]

Can't believe nobody has mentioned cyril yet.

I heard he is the best thing ever? Don't tell me bruce was lying at me??

 

[Slick]

Depends who you ask, if you're asking Tony Cochrane, clearly it's O'Meara.

 

[Suma Magic]

Fyfe
Bont
Danger
Lynch
Hogan

No idea in order, but Bont at his age could be the most desirable for the Eagles right now.

 

[Thetrader15]

Fyfe
Bont
Danger
Lynch
Hogan

No idea in order, but Bont at his age could be the most desirable for the Eagles right now.

Danger is worth less than Treloar

 

[Suma Magic]

Danger is worth less than Treloar

I still think you guys got a raw deal (and/or should have held out for better).

 

[Thetrader15]

I still think you guys got a raw deal (and/or should have held out for better).

That's because we were trying to get the deal done in day 1 to move onto the seedsman deal