List Mgmt. 2016 Trade/Free Agency Part 5 - THE MADNESS IS OVER!

[tigs2010]

I can see from the perspective of other clubs that he might not be, but we don't want draft picks, we want to keep our quality players.

Don't we all. Shame about that pesky salary cap though.

Sorry about Motlop deal

 

[HaroLad]

And you said straight swap wasnt enough. So by that logic Geelong think hes worth more than #15.

I can see from the perspective of other clubs that he might not be, but we don't want draft picks, we want to keep our quality players.

 

[parmy2balmey]

did bartel retire because lids?

 

[docko911]

Here's a doozy (shit, sorry) of a post from our favourite mod:



I literally can't even.

Being an expert on these kinds of trades I can confirm this poster has NFI.

He alludes to the fact that even if all we give for Caddy is pick 24 it doesn't mean that Geelong don't get a first round pick. He then contradicts himself by suggesting we will give GWS pick 24 and 27 to ensure they send pick 15 to Geelong.

Then he goes into something that involves their picks getting downgraded so GWS get some points.

Anyways I can solve his little problem without it actually costing us 2 second round picks

We trade Geelong pick 24 for Caddy
Geelong trade GWS pick 24 + 42 for Pick 15 this gives GWS a net gain of 68 points.

Geelong also cover off one of their two required firsts (unless they have to be next year).

 

[Sassafras]

My pet cat had a full meltdown tonight. Omen? I think so.

Is it a marmalade cat?

 

[bananatigz]

Boob_Radley has an almost 1:9 post to like ratio WTF

 

[HaroLad]

You're getting confused sweetie.
GWS rate him at #15, not you. You are not GWS.
Maybe you rated him at #30, therefor you would be getting more than the last offer.

To be honest I can't see how a 31 year old with injury problems is worth 15 (Lewis deal is about right).

Just no point in trading Caddy for picks.

 

[tigs2010]

Is it a marmalade cat?

It can be whatever cat you want. It's melted now.

 

[_Cayz_]

To be honest I can't see how a 31 year old with injury problems is worth 15 (Lewis deal is about right).

Just no point in trading Caddy for picks.

He's 29 bb.

 

[Al Kemy]

It's pretty simple guys.

You lot wanted Caddy as a straight swap for Lids - we said no as we think Caddy carries more value.

It's now looking likely that he will go to GWS for pick 15.

Why would we then trade him for pick 24 if we think he carries more value than someone who went for 15?

Not to mention that Selwood said "he will be at Geelong in "2017".

because we paid maybe $800,000 for that pick? Its not about players value this trade. I know its hard to take. Just go to bed .

 

[docko911]

To be honest I can't see how a 31 year old with injury problems is worth 15 (Lewis deal is about right).

Just no point in trading Caddy for picks.

Who's 31? Deledio is 29

 

[tigs2010]

I'll be completely honest and say I'm scared to go to sleep and this is on 250 pages when I wake up.

 

[3rdManUp]

It's pretty simple guys.

You lot wanted Caddy as a straight swap for Lids - we said no as we think Caddy carries more value.

It's now looking likely that he will go to GWS for pick 15.

Why would we then trade him for pick 24 if we think he carries more value than someone who went for 15?

Not to mention that Selwood said "he will be at Geelong in "2017".

Things change mate. Moves made, bluffs called. Just the way it goes

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

me and you can have a scat party with him

 

[Rancid_Beasties]

I can see from the perspective of other clubs that he might not be, but we don't want draft picks, we want to keep our quality players.

It will be so delicious tomorrow when you guys relent and accept pick 27, with us having refused to give you 24

 

[TiggerMan22]

Regardless, we will be much weaker heading into 2017 if we lose him and clearly that's not what any team needing to win a flag now wants.

shouldve got Lids if youre aiming for a flag.

 

[_Cayz_]

I'll be completely honest and say I'm scared to go to sleep and this is on 250 pages when I wake up.

Can confirm, I'm going to spam this thread all night long .

 

[docko911]

I'll be completely honest and say I'm scared to go to sleep and this is on 250 pages when I wake up.

Expecting to get to 10,000 tomorrow.

Threads that is

 

[tigs2010]

Can confirm, I'm going to spam this thread all night long .

I need some sleep.

Just weighing up whether to jack it to the Geelong trade thread or the bouncing **** in this thread

 

[HaroLad]

Richmond fans, I will ask you this.

Why would a club going all out for a flag next year want to trade their third/fourth best midfielder for an 18 year old who probably won't play a game next season?

 

[THE THIN MAN]

Is it a marmalade cat?

 

[docko911]

Richmond fans, I will ask you this.

Why would a club going all out for a flag next year want to trade their third/fourth best midfielder for an 18 year old who probably won't play a game next season?

Because you are over your salary cap

 

[Sassafras]

I'll be completely honest and say I'm scared to go to sleep and this is on 250 pages when I wake up.

Just have an eccy coffee.

 

[Tiger4Ever]

Looks like Sadaam!

 

[TiggerMan22]

Richmond fans, I will ask you this.

Why would a club going all out for a flag next year want to trade their third/fourth best midfielder for an 18 year old who probably won't play a game next season?

Lids isnt even a mid, the player we pick up will play